Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why there are so many kids with mental health problems?

435 replies

Newmama29 · 25/06/2023 09:42

I’ve been scrolling through some threads recently & I find people are talking a lot about their kids/teenagers having mental health problems. Why is this so prominent now? I, myself, was only a teenager 10 years ago so I am baffled as to how many people claim their teens have mental health problems. Is it just that we talk about it more or is society causing this?

OP posts:
DelphiniumBlue · 25/06/2023 12:00

Social media. Lockdown. Under funded services. Poor /absence of permanent housing. More awareness.

islandofserenity · 25/06/2023 11:59

Clementineorsatsuma · 25/06/2023 11:34

Why do you say"claiming"?
You're implying it's not true.
Are you saying that because you didn't have any MH problems then they don't be real?
I have 3 of the younger generation of my family (of a total of 8) with MH problems. Should I tell them that it's not real because you say so? A debilitated daughter who struggles with life every single bloody day. I'll just go and tell her that she's wrong- because yet again someone with no experience or psychiatric qualifications says so.
Good grief. Stay in your own lane. Please.

Totally agree clement. Some of these posts are so lacking in compassion and understanding. Makes me mad! 2 out of my 3 children suffer from anxiety. Some posters on mumsnet should walk a mile in someone's shoes before commenting!!!
And that's me being polite!

GlitteryUnicornSparkles · 25/06/2023 11:59

dayslikethese1 · 25/06/2023 10:21

I have been wondering this too. I don't have kids but from talking to colleagues who have teens it seems they don't go out or have friends IRL. Not sure how common that is. Another thing I've noticed is that they aren't expected to have a PT job or do any chores. When I was at school (early 2000s) we all had a Saturday job or say babysitting. I think it helped me build competence as I had to speak to people and be vaguely competent. But perhaps that is not allowed anymore.

I agree with the job thing too. At 14/15 I was working Saturdays and at 16 I worked part time around college.

These days places don’t seem interested in taking on anyone under 16 often even 18. So even opportunities to earn for themselves and gain some work ethic is lacking.

Mortgagewoes1 · 25/06/2023 11:57

Disagree tbh. I'm damn resilient and so was my father.

I'm talking about from an early age.

I don't stress over my kids falling over unless I see a major head injury/concussion for eg. Some parents are literally pandering over a cut knee. Brush it off, walk if off, it's fine, chop chop. Kid at my daughter's tennis was in crying hysterics having been hit by a ball in the shoulder by surprise (not even hard) - Mum ended up rushing onto court and making matters x10 worse removed her from the match due to a possible fracture (!!!) My kid slipped during a rally and cut open her leg on a hard court- carried on playing and simply wiped the blood away at change of ends. Politely asked for a plaster. Even the coach commented to me thank god there's one kid who's not so bloody dramatic and over emotional.

We created these weak children who then have turned into weak 20 and 30 somethings.

I'm proud to be resilient. There's worst things happened to people but we over sympathise and over indulge all the time.

islandofserenity · 25/06/2023 11:56

changeyerheadworzel · 25/06/2023 11:54

Your ignorance is astounding.

XelaM - what the actual duck?!!! your lack of compassion/understanding is astounding! i hope none of your kids ever suffer with depression/anxiety. one of the most unbelievable posts ive ever read on mumsnet.

QwertyWitch · 25/06/2023 11:56

and lack of exercise. There's research that shows that exercise impacts mental well-being positively.
Drs 'prescribe' that along with getting out in nature therapy.

miniaturepixieonacid · 25/06/2023 11:56

I've done school inset training on this recently. Most recent stats are that 20% of, i think, 8-18 year olds have diagnosed anxiety. And that's without all those who struggle and aren't diagnosed. I thought it was a typo for 2%. Really couldn't believe it. But apparently not.

2011 was the start of the first bug increase in mental illness in young people apparently. Coinciding with the invention of the smart phone. They took away young people's escape, privacy and alone time.

islandofserenity · 25/06/2023 11:54

Stickybackplasticbear · 25/06/2023 09:52

Oh come on op try harder. Baffled?

Just say what you mean if you're gonna be really prejudiced at least have the guts to say it. What you seem to mean is have we gone all soft and focused too much on emotions and feelings in the modern day. With all these people 'claiming' to have mental health issues.

Totally agree stickybackplasticbear!
My son was diagnosed with anxiety aged 9.
one of my daughters diagnosed this year with anxiety.
Ive suffered with my mental health since age 12. Diagnosed with EUPD in 2018 but ive always thought i had ASD [ high functioning asperger's) and a new psychiatrist is testing me for this now.
Was absolutely devastating seeing my son so anxious from aged 2. ( HE was our 1st born).
Someone has listed all the reasons why young people are diagnosed with mental health problems -I'm not going to repeat them.
To be honest OP, your post touched a raw nerve, I've been on anti depressants since i was 18 ( MY Mum became unwell with breast cancer then died from it!)
Please walk a mile in someone's shoes before judging. My 12 year old daughter has struggled with social media comments since starting high school.

changeyerheadworzel · 25/06/2023 11:54

XelaM · 25/06/2023 11:49

I so agree. All the drama about how during Covid kids were asked to not go to school for a few months and now they're apparently forever traumatised by it. Quite ridiculous when you think of what kids of previous generations had to live through.

Your ignorance is astounding.

QwertyWitch · 25/06/2023 11:53

They just demonstrates a lack of understanding and empathy. Nobody is helped by being told to 'get on with it'

But sometimes they are. Depending what it is of course but so many parents shelter their kids from everything they find uncomfortable.
They don't do chores, dont need to do homework well, don't need to visit grandparents, dont help out in any capacity. Just numb themselves with screens.

Swrigh1234 · 25/06/2023 11:53

Newmama29 · 25/06/2023 09:53

I really want to reiterate that I am not trying to be rude at all by this thread. I am interested in hearing other people’s opinions & experiences that are behind this topic. I’m not passing any judgement.

Covid really done a number on everyone’s mental health so I can understand how teenagers are so strongly affected by this. Really makes you wonder how many people are going to be more affected by the after effects of the pandemic than Covid alone.

Covid didn’t do anything. Lockdowns did. It was a choice to lockdown healthy adults and even children who are virtually no risk at all.

You just need to go back and read the threads on this very forum, where morons who frequent MN were screaming demanding harsher restrictions. Oh well, you got what you asked for.

XelaM · 25/06/2023 11:53

NotmyRLname · 25/06/2023 11:46

In my view as a parent of teens and as someone who is working and studying in mental health I think it’s a number of things. This is not to judge or blame anyone but-
I think that we as a society have a very unrealistic expectation on how we should be feeling and therefore how our children should be. We stop our children developing emotional resilience and neuroplasticity because we do everything we can to stop our children feeling pain, sadness, anger or hurt. This is understandable don’t get me wrong! And I do the same! But unfortunately the brain needs to “practice” these when young on a small scale often in order to create resilience/neuroplasticity. But I see so many parents who will do anything to avoid their child feeling left out/ picked on/ dissapointed/ failing at something/ being bored… but all these things are important learning and practicing opportunities.
I also think this is compounded by societal messages and social media that encourages us to compare, “live our best lives” have the best of everything.. so our expectations and especially those of young people are completely warped.
I also think that we err on the side of caution and over-diagnose normal teen emotions as something more sinister. When we were younger it was written off as “teen angst” which everyone has and then mostly grew out of it once our brains put themselves back together again after teenhood finished. But now we are giving out the message that these feelings aren’t normal. Instead of telling our kids that feelings come and go in peaks and troughs throughout life we give it a name and try and fix it- giving them the message that it’s something wrong with them. That in itself can cause anxiety and make things feel much worse. So now these kids not
only feel that way but also feel worried that its
not normal and common.
I think we have somewhat mollycoddled our kids into this unfortunately.

lastly and probably the most important thing is that we aren’t living as naturally as possible. Kids don’t get outside enough, they aren’t left alone enough to explore a bit of danger, challenge themselves and experiment because of our own fears. Society is now safer in many ways yet how many kids go off exploring in nature with just their friends anymore?? Screens are messing up their circadian rhythm (as is ours) and the overall effect is being seen in kids now.

👏🏼 All of this!!

cansu · 25/06/2023 11:52

1.social media and doing adult things earlier.

  1. Diagnosing anxiety when the feelings are normal for the situation. E.g. kid is worried about friendships and doesn't want to come to school is described as anxiety and requires mental health support.
ZZpop · 25/06/2023 11:52

My son has severe anxiety due to his autism and severe learning disability including society not catering for his needs. The mental health of people like him was not even considered until very recently.

Tessisme · 25/06/2023 11:52

I so agree. All the drama about how during Covid kids were asked to not go to school for a few months and now they're apparently forever traumatised by it. Quite ridiculous when you think of what kids of previous generations had to live through.

Fucking hell. I think there was a bit more to it than not going to school for a few months. The ignorance of some people blows my mind.

WandaWonder · 25/06/2023 11:50

I think the world has gone from not doing enough for genuine MH issues to way over the top every little thing has a 'anxiety' or some other label attached to and over the top thinking and complicating everything, for example a lot of the threads on here

wildfirewonder · 25/06/2023 11:50

Mortgagewoes1 · 25/06/2023 11:43

Because every time someone is sad, or a bit anxious they've got 'poor mental health' I do think we create a lot of this - my nan's generation would have said 'pull your bloody socks up and get on with things' I think she'd be turning in her grave right now.

Embarrassing that 20 year olds were fighting in WW2 and were grown men. Can you imagine what they'd think of today's society?

Many of those young men were broken by their experiences. They drank, beat their wives/children, got into fights, got into other difficulties.

I think they would think today's society was a lot less unsupportive. MH issues amongst those who were in the forces are very common.

XelaM · 25/06/2023 11:49

Mortgagewoes1 · 25/06/2023 11:43

Because every time someone is sad, or a bit anxious they've got 'poor mental health' I do think we create a lot of this - my nan's generation would have said 'pull your bloody socks up and get on with things' I think she'd be turning in her grave right now.

Embarrassing that 20 year olds were fighting in WW2 and were grown men. Can you imagine what they'd think of today's society?

I so agree. All the drama about how during Covid kids were asked to not go to school for a few months and now they're apparently forever traumatised by it. Quite ridiculous when you think of what kids of previous generations had to live through.

AlanJohnsonsBeemer · 25/06/2023 11:48

Increased awareness
social media
social contagion
lack of resilience.

Every child I know that has serious mental health problems is addicted to their phone and TikTok/Insta etc. it might be a correlation but it is enough for me to keep DD off it for as long as possible. She kicks off about DS having Insta at 12 or 13 and it didnt do him any harm, but I have changed my view.

The girls I know that are suffering don’t all have busy, over worked parents or shit diets or lack of fresh air, or too much/not enough money in the house, the social media thing is the one common factor.

wildfirewonder · 25/06/2023 11:47

Newmama29 · 25/06/2023 09:47

@Sirzy did you have a mental health condition though or were you just struggling with normal teen stuff? I’m not asking to be rude, I’m genuinely interested in this & the sociological change in mental health. I would say I had some tough times growing up, but I wouldn’t have diagnosed myself with depression & anxiety.

I do not understand the attitude of 'I did not think I had depression so am going to act as if the depression other people are experiencing is not real'.

There is so much information online about why there is a big increase in MH problems amongst young people.

NotmyRLname · 25/06/2023 11:46

In my view as a parent of teens and as someone who is working and studying in mental health I think it’s a number of things. This is not to judge or blame anyone but-
I think that we as a society have a very unrealistic expectation on how we should be feeling and therefore how our children should be. We stop our children developing emotional resilience and neuroplasticity because we do everything we can to stop our children feeling pain, sadness, anger or hurt. This is understandable don’t get me wrong! And I do the same! But unfortunately the brain needs to “practice” these when young on a small scale often in order to create resilience/neuroplasticity. But I see so many parents who will do anything to avoid their child feeling left out/ picked on/ dissapointed/ failing at something/ being bored… but all these things are important learning and practicing opportunities.
I also think this is compounded by societal messages and social media that encourages us to compare, “live our best lives” have the best of everything.. so our expectations and especially those of young people are completely warped.
I also think that we err on the side of caution and over-diagnose normal teen emotions as something more sinister. When we were younger it was written off as “teen angst” which everyone has and then mostly grew out of it once our brains put themselves back together again after teenhood finished. But now we are giving out the message that these feelings aren’t normal. Instead of telling our kids that feelings come and go in peaks and troughs throughout life we give it a name and try and fix it- giving them the message that it’s something wrong with them. That in itself can cause anxiety and make things feel much worse. So now these kids not
only feel that way but also feel worried that its
not normal and common.
I think we have somewhat mollycoddled our kids into this unfortunately.

lastly and probably the most important thing is that we aren’t living as naturally as possible. Kids don’t get outside enough, they aren’t left alone enough to explore a bit of danger, challenge themselves and experiment because of our own fears. Society is now safer in many ways yet how many kids go off exploring in nature with just their friends anymore?? Screens are messing up their circadian rhythm (as is ours) and the overall effect is being seen in kids now.

chemistnightmare · 25/06/2023 11:46

my nan's generation would have said 'pull your bloody socks up and get on with things'

They just demonstrates a lack of understanding and empathy. Nobody is helped by being told to 'get on with it'

Jesseweneedtocook · 25/06/2023 11:45
  1. Tik tok, Instagram, other social media but especially these two.

  2. Covid.

  3. we're open and accepting of mental health issues to a fault nowadays. It's gone too far and now everyone has anxiety.

  4. parents and schools are failing to instil resilience in young people meaning they struggle to handle criticism or anyone who has a different opinion.

Mortgagewoes1 · 25/06/2023 11:43

Because every time someone is sad, or a bit anxious they've got 'poor mental health' I do think we create a lot of this - my nan's generation would have said 'pull your bloody socks up and get on with things' I think she'd be turning in her grave right now.

Embarrassing that 20 year olds were fighting in WW2 and were grown men. Can you imagine what they'd think of today's society?

Orchidgal · 25/06/2023 11:42

DemiColon · 25/06/2023 11:35

Something to remember with the social media thing, which all the experts say is key:

It's not just about the content. Comparing apparently perfect lives, bullying, etc.

It's also about the way it changes brain function (gaming does this too.) It means kids don't find the same satisfaction from doing other things, and they experience withdrawal symptoms when they are off sm or gaming. It works the same way as gambling addiction, and if you think about how much time many kids spend on sm, it is like they are at the slot machine all day, every day. it's in their pocket.

It's also the time they are not doing other things. And actually opposite things. It's the time they are not with other people, building real relationships. Online relationships don't work the same way and don't have the same kinds of fulfilling outcomes.

it's the time they are not alone with their thoughts, or bored, or resting and sleeping, even.

And it's the time they are not playing sports, baking, reading a book, noticing their mum needs a hand and pitching in, etc.

Hours out of the day that used to include these other things, plus what is really a state of addiction.

It's a huge change in brain function, not just exposure to bullies or bad media.

Absolutely. 100%.