Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stepdaughter eating too much fruit

639 replies

Katey83 · 04/05/2023 22:47

My dsd, 7, moved in with us full
time back in January. Our situation is that I am higher earner and breadwinner on Mat leave with 5 month old baby, husband does some part time work that doesn’t bring in much (he runs our family vehicle and contributes towards household costs such as shopping etc). Dsd’s mother does not contribute towards her expenses while she is living here (indefinitely for now).

At the moment, we are on a tight budget due to my mat leave - and one thing driving me crazy is dsd eating all our fruit. We will buy a weekly shop with 2 bunches bananas, few punnets of berries, peaches, melon, grapes, tangerines etc and she will eat her way through the lot in two days. For example, yesterday she ate a punnet and a half of raspberries, three peaches, four tangerines, some grapes, a slice of melon and two bananas. This is on a school day (so she eats this at breakfast and in the evening). She is then obviously reluctant to finish a proper evening meal or try anything she dislikes. She also has had a couple of accidents with loose stools (imo this is from bingeing on fruit). She takes from the fridge without asking and leaves nothing for DH and I.

I’ve spoken to my dh about this and he says she is a growing child and at least fruit is good for her - fair enough I buy fruit partly for her to eat, but the amount seems greedy to me, and beyond what is necessary for a healthy child. I think reasonable is a small
bowl of berries and grapes along with a tangerine and banana after school as a snack and then one piece for dessert. She can also have melon and banana for breakfast along with cereal and a yoghurt. I want her to learn that food costs money, we don’t have a bottomless pit of it and you don’t just gorge on whatever you want because you are bored/tired/didn’t eat your dinner, you ration portions in a family so everyone gets a fair share, and sometimes eat less tasty things to maintain a healthy diet.

We provide substantial breakfast, lunch and dinner portions, and I try to accommodate her tastes (though she can’t just have fish fingers and strawberries as a diet, which would be her preference).When she first came to us she was also gorging like this on sweets - that’s been easier to nip in bud as dh can see how unhealthy it is. I want to handle this in a compassionate way, would I be unreasonable to stop buying fruit until dh agrees to a sensible ration for dsd?

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 06/05/2023 11:37

Efacsen · 06/05/2023 11:32

'Not a big deal' if she soils herself at school or at a friends party??

She doesn't need that humiliation, she's got enough to deal with

Exactly!
@LimePi

Efacsen · 06/05/2023 11:32

'Not a big deal' if she soils herself at school or at a friends party??

She doesn't need that humiliation, she's got enough to deal with

LuckySantangelo35 · 06/05/2023 11:30

LimePi · 06/05/2023 11:28

ive commented on loose stool above - it’s not a big deal and fruit is much more healthy than constant toast everything, or sandwiches all the time.
And it is not ‘tons’ of fruit - I ate that much and continue to do so. Instead I don’t have sweet tooth and don’t care about chocolate, sweet or pastry. Berries are very healthy option.

and yes, they as a family need to accommodate the needs of their kids (BOTH) so yes she or husband need to work more or get better paying jobs. Whether it’s fruit, extracurricular activities later on, etc

is she going to moan that step daughter needs clothes as a teenager? Or wants to do some extra curricular activities or clubs? Sure, one can wear secondhand and noone REALLY needs new fashionable clothes, or can just sit at home after school. Right? P-lease

@LimePi

lol yeah op go out and get a better paying job so that you can keep buying all this fruit! In the real world, people limit themselves, make their food shop last, etc.

LimePi · 06/05/2023 11:28

LuckySantangelo35 · 06/05/2023 11:13

@LimePi

you are being ridiculous
it is “not a bit of fruit” - it’s tons!
and she is soiling herself from it so it’s hardly good for her is it?!
and are you seriously suggesting that op works more hours in order to keep buying loads of fruit ?!

ive commented on loose stool above - it’s not a big deal and fruit is much more healthy than constant toast everything, or sandwiches all the time.
And it is not ‘tons’ of fruit - I ate that much and continue to do so. Instead I don’t have sweet tooth and don’t care about chocolate, sweet or pastry. Berries are very healthy option.

and yes, they as a family need to accommodate the needs of their kids (BOTH) so yes she or husband need to work more or get better paying jobs. Whether it’s fruit, extracurricular activities later on, etc

is she going to moan that step daughter needs clothes as a teenager? Or wants to do some extra curricular activities or clubs? Sure, one can wear secondhand and noone REALLY needs new fashionable clothes, or can just sit at home after school. Right? P-lease

LuckySantangelo35 · 06/05/2023 11:27

LimePi · 06/05/2023 11:19

A bit of loose stool here and there is not a big deal. I can get loose stool if I eat lots of apricots or pears but it is not damaging to health for christ’s sake, it’s just par for the course because some fruit have this effect:

If you are literally ‘unwell’ from fruit it is maybe because you don’t eat it enough and your body is not used to fruit and veg but is instead used to heave carbs/protein.

@LimePi

come off it, it’s an excessive amount of fruit for anyone to eat never mind a 7 year old!
and it is really expensive to buy that much - there is a cost of living crisis you know

Katey83 · 06/05/2023 11:26

Thanks for all the helpful suggestions - we tried a snack ‘plate’ yesterday and it was a success, with dsd helping to pick a range of snacks for the evening and happily not eating more than we had set aside on her special plate. For those saying I’m resentful and don’t care all I can say is please try being a stepparent for one day, let alone with a new baby and total financial responsibilities for the family and see how long you can go without a single stressed or negative thought. Expressing that in a call for help in a parenting forum is not the same as abusing or mistreating a child.

OP posts:
Crikeyohreilly · 06/05/2023 11:22

Eating all your fruit? Honestly 🤣 says quite a lot about you this post I’d be embarrassed to be quite honest.

LuckySantangelo35 · 06/05/2023 11:19

GoldenFarfalle · 06/05/2023 11:17

Totally agree with you! Well said. All these people saying how bad is eating so much fruit but they are recommending to eat toast.. which is worst than fruit. Is just because fruit is more expensive and as she is step daughter she doesn't deserve it..

I feel sad for that little girl.

@GoldenFarfalle

no, it’s because she’s eating so much fruit that she’s making herself ill and soiling herself. Did you miss that bit?

LimePi · 06/05/2023 11:19

CheeseandMarmiteToasties · 06/05/2023 10:34

My daughter went through something similar when she was about your dsd’s age. Her friends at school were giving her the apples out of their packed lunches to eat. Her friends’ mothers would reassure me before play dates that they had bought fruit for her! She’s 12 now and still likes fruit more than my other daughter but is not eating six apples in a day anymore. In the fruit years, I bought the more inexpensive fruit such as apples, oranges and bananas. As other posters have rightly said it is the berries that are crippling. I also buy a lot of frozen fruit and my daughter makes herself smoothies. Costco is very good for this.

A bit of loose stool here and there is not a big deal. I can get loose stool if I eat lots of apricots or pears but it is not damaging to health for christ’s sake, it’s just par for the course because some fruit have this effect:

If you are literally ‘unwell’ from fruit it is maybe because you don’t eat it enough and your body is not used to fruit and veg but is instead used to heave carbs/protein.

GoldenFarfalle · 06/05/2023 11:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Totally agree with you! Well said. All these people saying how bad is eating so much fruit but they are recommending to eat toast.. which is worst than fruit. Is just because fruit is more expensive and as she is step daughter she doesn't deserve it..

I feel sad for that little girl.

LuckySantangelo35 · 06/05/2023 11:13

GiraffeLaSophie · 06/05/2023 10:20

Have you missed the part where she’s soiled herself several times recently? So clearly it’s not ‘great’ for her. If I ate that much fruit (and it is a huge amount of fruit for anyone to eat) I would feel unwell, and I weigh considerably more than a 7 year old girl.

There’s nothing wrong with teaching a 7 year old portion control, so long as it’s done sensibly. It’s not a good idea for anyone to just sit and regularly eat to excess, regardless of what they’re eating.

@LimePi

you are being ridiculous
it is “not a bit of fruit” - it’s tons!
and she is soiling herself from it so it’s hardly good for her is it?!
and are you seriously suggesting that op works more hours in order to keep buying loads of fruit ?!

CheeseandMarmiteToasties · 06/05/2023 10:34

My daughter went through something similar when she was about your dsd’s age. Her friends at school were giving her the apples out of their packed lunches to eat. Her friends’ mothers would reassure me before play dates that they had bought fruit for her! She’s 12 now and still likes fruit more than my other daughter but is not eating six apples in a day anymore. In the fruit years, I bought the more inexpensive fruit such as apples, oranges and bananas. As other posters have rightly said it is the berries that are crippling. I also buy a lot of frozen fruit and my daughter makes herself smoothies. Costco is very good for this.

GiraffeLaSophie · 06/05/2023 10:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Have you missed the part where she’s soiled herself several times recently? So clearly it’s not ‘great’ for her. If I ate that much fruit (and it is a huge amount of fruit for anyone to eat) I would feel unwell, and I weigh considerably more than a 7 year old girl.

There’s nothing wrong with teaching a 7 year old portion control, so long as it’s done sensibly. It’s not a good idea for anyone to just sit and regularly eat to excess, regardless of what they’re eating.

BabyTa · 06/05/2023 10:13

Just reading what she is eating makes me feel physically sick. At 7 year old she should be asking for a snack not helping herself as of course she'll overeat. Sounds like irresponsible parenting not to manage this properly, like your husband is just hiding form a difficult situation. Either stop buying fruit or get him to sort it out

Beeboob · 06/05/2023 10:12

Sounds like comfort eating, but is definitely too much fruit. If she haw cut down on gorging on sweets, they may be a replacement for her. Fruit is high in sugar still and bad for the teeth, but if she doesn't have it available at her mums house, she might gorge on it because it hasn't been available before and feels like a luxury.

Beetrootlady · 06/05/2023 09:59

Although you mention compassion in your original post it doesn’t come across that you have much compassion for your dsd. It comes across as you taking out your resentment for your other half’s lack of earning on her. She needs clear guidelines around the fruit issue but is a young child going through lots of disruption and changes, the last thing she needs is your resentment.

abs12 · 06/05/2023 09:57

At first I thought you were being a dick. Then I read the amount of fruit and your considered responses. You are spot on in all you have said. Restrict acces and get DH on side. Carrot sticks and cucumber will be way better than all the fructose. YANBU in any way shape or form. Tou sound like a well rounded empathetic step mother/new mother doing a damn good job.

Stripedbag101 · 06/05/2023 09:32

Samlewis96 · 06/05/2023 09:27

Why? She's living with her dad. What's the difference? I lived with my dad st that age and made not a shred of difference

But you must have missed your mum? Unless there was some very complex emotional or physiological issues at play?

it seems incredibly emotionally unaware to question why 7 year old who moved out of her mums house just five months ago would miss her mum.

Samlewis96 · 06/05/2023 09:27

ejbaxa · 05/05/2023 00:52

Does she eat nuts? Nuts would be a better snack than all that fruit. And more filling.

Other than that, I would put what she can have in a box each day and perhaps put extra punnets etc on high shelves behind other items.

She sounds like she is really struggling though. I cannot imagine not living with my mum when I was 7.

Why? She's living with her dad. What's the difference? I lived with my dad st that age and made not a shred of difference

Anna1953 · 06/05/2023 09:02

Your SD is 7 do you even know if she understands the issue ? Did you even think about her before going on off a rant here and calling her greedy? GREEDY? Really? She's going through so much change perhaps be more empathetic.

Nikkidannih · 06/05/2023 08:57

I clicked yes you are being unreasonable because I think not buying fruit at all is
an unreasonable reaction.

However putting limits on snacks is not unreasonable even if it is fruit. Maybe you could let her choose her own little lunch box or fruit bowl and fill it with the snacks she is allowed to eat for the day, and once they are gone they are gone. Also putting everything else out of sight, out of mind. At this age impulse control Is still developing so she could be eating out of impulse when seeing the fruit. Good luck.

purplehair1 · 06/05/2023 08:51

Buy less fruit? If it’s not there she can’t finish it all off.

GabriellaMontez · 06/05/2023 08:46

Tarantullah · 06/05/2023 05:08

I am not sure why you are outsourcing the parenting to your husband

Because she's his child?

And he only works part time. And the OP has a new baby.

Casperroonie · 06/05/2023 08:45

Casperroonie · 06/05/2023 08:43

What an absolutely horrible post. She's asking for an opinion and you've attacked her.

She's just had a baby herself.

Your response says a lot about you and it's not nice.

This is in response to limepie post!

Casperroonie · 06/05/2023 08:43

What an absolutely horrible post. She's asking for an opinion and you've attacked her.

She's just had a baby herself.

Your response says a lot about you and it's not nice.