Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

State school Uk vs International school abroad

62 replies

Lentilsandyoghurt · 06/04/2023 12:05

Hey all,

I know not many of you have such experience but I am wondering whether a good state school in the Uk will provide better education and opportunities for my kids or an international school abroad that follows British curriculum is better.

We are not originally from the Uk, we come from a EU country and we may need to good soon back for family reasons.

The kids are still young, primary school kids and have been raised as bilingual.

What do you think will be best for them?

Eventually in 10 years time they will return in the Uk to study as they will follow the British curriculum no matter where we will be.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Honeymoon81 · 02/06/2024 10:22

AmeliaG76 · 11/12/2023 18:09

I have experience of UK independent school, UK state school and International school with British curriuclum in the Algarve, Portugal. Hands down, my son prefers the international school and his transformed his confidence, social circle, opportunities and level of fun and engagement. He absolutely loves going to school and has friends from all over the world. Plus, the teachers are really happy as they´re all living in the sunshine!!! Did you already decide on somewhere to go? His school has about 40 nationalities but English is the language they are taught in, by native English speakers, as well as learning the local language. 😁

Hi, sorry for reactivating this post. We are moving to the Algarve with our teen daughter. Do you mind telling me which international school your child attend?

Valeriekat · 11/12/2023 18:38

DominoRules · 06/04/2023 12:11

My kids have been to international schools abroad (British curriculum) and now back in U.K. state school - to be honest overall there’s not much difference between it. International was better for sports/creative side but I would say the state has better foundations for maths and English. I would imagine if they’d stayed at either there won’t have been a huge variation in GCSE results etc

There is a vast difference in the quality of International schools though. They really aren't all the same.

AmeliaG76 · 11/12/2023 18:10

Greece or Cyprus?

AmeliaG76 · 11/12/2023 18:09

I have experience of UK independent school, UK state school and International school with British curriuclum in the Algarve, Portugal. Hands down, my son prefers the international school and his transformed his confidence, social circle, opportunities and level of fun and engagement. He absolutely loves going to school and has friends from all over the world. Plus, the teachers are really happy as they´re all living in the sunshine!!! Did you already decide on somewhere to go? His school has about 40 nationalities but English is the language they are taught in, by native English speakers, as well as learning the local language. 😁

mandcharp · 09/06/2023 15:43

If they wanted to come to uni in UK they would have to pay international fees which are at least double. I saw you put that the family are putting emotional pressure to go back...just be sure you are making the right choice for the right reasons - your family unit first! We are in similar predicament having to make a choice as a dual nationality family (no pressure from family though it's to do with work) - I wish you the very best with your choice and admire you wanting to do the right thing by your larger family group. xx

Lentilsandyoghurt · 10/04/2023 13:30

Thanks all!

Yes, we are prepared for private English lessons. This is very common in Greece and that’s why most Greeks speak English very well.

The only other viable option would be to enroll them in an international school in Greece and then let them study in an English taught course Europe but not in the Uk.

OP posts:
MumInBrussels · 10/04/2023 12:58

One thing I would say when considering enrolling kids in a local education system is the extent to which you'd like them to be fluent in English as adults, and the work it would take from you to develop this. Most education systems don't produce English fluency where it's taught as a foreign language, just as the UK system doesn't generally produce fluent French or German speakers...

If you'd like your kids to read and write English to a native level, you probably will need to arrange lessons outside school. Is this something you'd be able to provide? Would you mind if they don't read and write English well as adults? (We've managed to keep up spoken English by watching telly in English and talking exclusively on English at home, but as our kids get older, the written side of things is increasingly obviously an issue. I imagine it would be even more so if they're using a different alphabet at school.)

LlynTegid · 10/04/2023 12:40

Sorry I have no knowledge of the Greek education system to be able to offer any constructive thoughts.

lanthanum · 10/04/2023 12:36

Chocchops72 · 07/04/2023 03:43

Be aware that if your children are living outside the UK before going to Uni, they will probably be treated as international students. The fees are much much higher. This applies even if they have British nationality, it’s usually assessed on résidence not just nationality.

I was going to mention this. I know someone whose family went back to their home country for similar reasons to you. She returned to the UK for A-levels, but has to take a year out because she needs three years residence to qualify as a home student.

Lentilsandyoghurt · 10/04/2023 12:20

I feel that the only viable and sustainable way forward for us is to return in Greece and for the kids to adjust to the Greek curriculum.

Brexit has made it so difficult for all Europeans to live and study in the UK.

OP posts:
Lentilsandyoghurt · 10/04/2023 11:12

Yes, we all have dual citizenship and British and EU passports.

But apparently having Uk passport doesn’t automatically grand you home uni fees…

OP posts:
LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 10/04/2023 07:44

do you/they have British citizenship. It might not be so easy to return if not, can you get dual before you leave?

Lentilsandyoghurt · 10/04/2023 07:04

This is scary but thank you for the eye opening info. I hadn’t thought of Brexit impact.

As international school fees plus uni international fees for two kids is unaffordable for us, we are now discussing seriously the option to go back in Greece and the kids to follow Greek curriculum and attend a Greek uni.

As I said our DC1 is in year 2. Do you think we missed the boat and it would be too upsetting for the kids to relocate and change curriculum now?

OP posts:
Chocchops72 · 10/04/2023 06:29

Lentilsandyoghurt · 07/04/2023 06:56

@Chocchops72 and @Nimbostratus100 what you said is mind changer!

Both kids are British nationals, have Uk passports and were born in the Uk.

Will they have no access to student loans and we will have to pay for international uni fees if they graduate from a school abroad?

Yes it is correct. Though it’s not to do with where they go to school as such, it’s down to residency.

for UK nationals already living in the EU when Brexit happened there is a 7-year window where they can qualify for ‘home’ fees and student loans, so that’s up to around 2027 I think. After that, they are treated as EU students - which now means as international students.

your children won’t even qualify for that: they’ll have to follow the residence rules which usually means being resident in the UK for three years prior to starting study.

each home nation has its own variation on these rules and each university interprets the rules slightly differently, but that’s the bottom line.

itsabigtree · 08/04/2023 13:38

I live abroad and a friend of mine used to work at the international school here but she quit due to terrible behavior. The majority of students where locals kids who had been kicked out of school. Not much English is despite despite being international. But everyone that moves here thinks it's the best place to enroll their children.
As they're bilingual I would enroll them in a regular local school in the EU country. It obviously won't be UK curriculum but the standard of education is highly superior to England in a lot of European countries.

Cherrybl0ssm · 08/04/2023 12:31

Place marking. My kids have done both. I’ll be back soon to update.

PinkPomeranian · 08/04/2023 12:29

There was a more holistic approach at the British international school I attended than the Ofsted outstanding comprehensive I moved to back in the UK. The independent international school had fewer arbitrary hoops to jump through.

dcbc1234 · 08/04/2023 12:24

Why can't you buy in cover for the day off?

Rumplestrumpet · 08/04/2023 07:42

I can offer our experience if it helps:

We moved back to our home country last year because we wanted to support our elderly parents and for our kids to connect with their heritage, culture and language. We chose an international school because we thought it offered the best education, and would allow them to reintegrate the UK system later. But in truth academically it feels quite similar to our "Ofsted outstanding" school back in the UK.

However, it's been wonderful for them to feel submerged in local culture, and they definitely feel more connected to that side of their heritage already. They've built a relationship with their grandparents and cousins they just didn't have before.

So I'm glad we came. BUT we agreed it would be for 3-5 years max, and that we'd come back to the UK in time for my eldest to start secondary. Personally I don't want to live here much longer than that.

Lentilsandyoghurt · 08/04/2023 07:32

Thank you all!

To put things into perspective and explain why it’s now or never, we are Greek.

Greeks have different alphabet, let alone Grammar etc.

If kids need to follow the Greek national curriculum then we really need to go back ASAP.

My eldest is Year 2 , meaning 6 years old, and would have been in Year 1 in Greece this year, there is no reception in Greece.

My youngest is in reception, meaning that he can start in Year 1 in Greece next year which is the first year in Primary school.

It would not be easy for the kids to go back in 3-4 years time as it would have been impossible to them to catch up with the language.

Also, our parents (both sets) have iPhones and we FaceTime them every day, they are already part of our lives.

The problem is their health. Even if we buy them help in support, this person normally takes one day per week off. Who will look after them on this day? My grandma is in a very poorly state and I know that she can’t stay on her own not even for hours.

Having said all that financially it would make sense to stay in the Uk and it will also be better for kids school-wise …

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 08/04/2023 00:47

It sounds very difficult

is there any reason why you have to go right now? Can you start going regularly for holidays over the next couple of years and see how it goes?

Youngishone · 07/04/2023 22:22

I would think about overall quality of life in your home country compared to the UK, housing etc. Also look carefully at the education system locally in case it suits your DC better. Most countries encourage proficiency in English and if they already speak English schooling in another language might give them opportunities. With Brexit the trajectory for the UK doesn't look good in the near future. Your own country might be more up and coming.

ChiefPearlClutcher · 07/04/2023 22:15

So many typos sorry.
When do we get an edit button?!?

ChiefPearlClutcher · 07/04/2023 22:14

*could live there

ChiefPearlClutcher · 07/04/2023 22:13

I really sympathise with you OP, we’ve had the same dilemma. When my second son was almost two I went back to our home country for 6 weeks to see if we could luve their. Really investigates everything, also all the hidden costs of things we take for granted in the UK, like healthcare, banking fees, security costs, schooling (it would have had to be private, whereas in the UK state schooling is still very good). In the end financially it absolutely did not make sense! When you add it all up we had a better and cheaper life in the UK with more opportunity for our children. The UK is also politically very very stable which is very important to me. Girls have a voice and opportunity.

Anyway, I digress our parents (both sets) were horrified that we were thinking of going back. They saw it as we ‘escaped’ to a much better life and opportunities, and could not understand why we would give it up to essentially go and care for people that have had their lives already. Does your parents actually expect you
to go back and care for them? You may find that a twice yearly trip (unless is Australia or Polynesia or somewhere
very difficult to get to!) with a meaningful and eventful, memory filled visit may be worth much than life in the daily
grind.
You can set things up to make life easier for them as I’ve said before. With £ you could probably also buy help in for them.
I send my parents a grocery delivery every now and then with treats that I know they won’t buy themselves. We also bought our kids smartphones way you get than their friends, purely because they can have an independent relationship with their grandparents, call and message them on their own time and whatsapp them photos of what they get up to during the day (star of the week, football wins, what they had for dinner, new toy, lego creation etc). Sometimes O just have my
mum on the whatsapp screen while I cook and we chat away, or she sees what goes on in the kitchen and the kids coming and going. They are very much part of our daily lives.
There are ways of doing it. The world is becoming a very small place and I can tell
you now, from one immigrant to another, the road to get here was damn hard and we worked our asses off for it. Think very carefully!! But also, I am biased. I love my life in England (three months to go till we’re back!) and I and thankful every single day for my British passport and the opportunities and protections I have.

Swipe left for the next trending thread