Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to move south?

143 replies

Oohlalaaaaaa · 26/03/2023 10:31

Currently live in Central Scotland. My partner is from Dorset. We have primary school aged children with one due to start high school this year. I think we would enjoy a better quality of life down there.
I'm a bit worried my kids would be picked on and not accepted for having scottish accents or for being outsiders. Is this silly? 🤔
Also is it cruel to uproot 3 perfectly happy children, especially one at age 12 (she has strong friendships, the other 2 not so much)? Am I being selfish? I'm scared that if it goes wrong for them it will be my doing. Any advice would be appreciated.

OP posts:
infinityminusone · 26/03/2023 20:11

Why don't you consider somewhere like Moray - it has a micro-climate, so the weather is drier and warmer than other areas of Scotland and it has beautiful beaches, gorgeous countryside and there are many good pubs to have a Sunday roast in! Scotland's reputation for drugs is justified, but mainly in the inner city areas. The places I saw people openly using and selling drugs in England were 'lovely twee' towns, so be careful what you wish for.

NosnowontheScottishhills · 26/03/2023 20:01

Ndd135632 · 26/03/2023 10:54

OP there won’t be any issue with Scottish accents down here. Not like the English accent in Scotland if that is what you are thinking.

This is total rubbish I have a very English accent and the all the Scots Ive met are lovely and friendly much friendlier than any English Ive met.
OP do you know Dorset (I do)? Most English people living in Scotland that I know comment on how much quieter Scotland is compared to England, the population density is significantly less it is approx. 2/3 the size of Englands with a population on just over 5 million and nearly 4 of those live in the central belt. Life here is much quieter and more relaxed here than in England, Im writing as someone who'd never stepped a toe in to Scotland for my first 50 years. Ive lived in many parts of England and personally don't think you can beat Scottish landscape, mountains hills uplands moorlands pasture its so varied and there's water everywhere e.g. lochs, burns, river and wonderful and varied coastline. I agree the weather is a bit shit especially on the west side rain rain rain but the light, the ever changing landscape and the total peace and quiet more than compensate for this.

Blip · 26/03/2023 19:47

What's your budget like?

Crikeyalmighty · 26/03/2023 19:26

I would look at Wimborne, Christchurch, Dorchester , salisbury (not close to coast but a very easy and nice route) and even further east to Chichester and Eastbourne or west to Exeter

We live in bath which I like but it's expensive and it's not that close to coast either.

I like Poole and Bournemouth but do note what people on here say.

WhyPie · 26/03/2023 19:23

@colouringindoors I live in dundee and wouldn't recommend!

colouringindoors · 26/03/2023 19:17

*uni fees

colouringindoors · 26/03/2023 19:15

Hmmm Scotland has the major advantage re school fees imho and cost of living in Southern England can be very high. But yes Scotland does have a significant drug problem and is cooler than the South coast. I would think about moving to SE Scotland - much drier, sunnier, coast on your doorstep.

For example, Dundee has a growing creative industry, has record breaking sunny days and is often voted best place to live in Scotland. Don't know what your budget is but you could get a really nice 4 bed detached for less than £400k.

This new build is £340k
www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/131236547#/?channel=RES_NEW

Dorchester on the other hand 4 bed semi £375k less nice.
https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/125748020#/?channel=RES_BUY

Lots of other SE Scotland options too inc St Andrews, Edinburgh and surrounds...

If money is no issue, sure move south...

Check out this 4 bedroom semi-detached house for sale on Rightmove

4 bedroom semi-detached house for sale in Fourgates Road, Dorchester, DT1 for £375,000. Marketed by Connells, Dorchester

https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/125748020#/?channel=RES_BUY

MyOtherUsernameIsDave · 26/03/2023 18:52

I grew up in a pretty market town, there was an enormous drugs and drink problem because there was nothing to do.

slowquickstep · 26/03/2023 16:50

There is over 100 miles of coast in Ayrshire and you pick the worst 3 miles ! Just be honest with your family, you hate being in Scotland. What if they want to stay, what if the children don't like the south coast ?

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 16:45

Oohlalaaaaaa · 26/03/2023 15:53

Yes you can physically reach the coast in 1 hour but it is not particularly nice eg Troon, Ayr. Further up north absolutely stunning but that wouldnt work for us. Countryside is ok from where I live but overcrowded on nice days and full of litter. Just saying what i find.
Weather is crap pretty much all year. Argue over that if you want.

I would like to be near to coast, decent train service, nice countryside but not too small-minded/villagey. Good schools.

Troon and Ayr beaches are not the best - have you deliberately picked the worst ones? There are far prettier places nearby, or if you go east.

Where down south are you thinking of? Because there is obviously a far higher population density down there; therefore overcrowding is going to be far worse. And the train service here is generally good in comparison to many places.

dreamingofsun · 26/03/2023 16:07

so what sort of property do you want and how much money do you have? Think in terms of 450k for a 3 bed semi - obviously varies on the area etc. And what sort of jobs will you all be looking for? If its in retail, carehomes, public sector or tourism you are OK.

Oohlalaaaaaa · 26/03/2023 15:53

Yes you can physically reach the coast in 1 hour but it is not particularly nice eg Troon, Ayr. Further up north absolutely stunning but that wouldnt work for us. Countryside is ok from where I live but overcrowded on nice days and full of litter. Just saying what i find.
Weather is crap pretty much all year. Argue over that if you want.

I would like to be near to coast, decent train service, nice countryside but not too small-minded/villagey. Good schools.

OP posts:
Busybody2022 · 26/03/2023 15:40

Interesting view points.

Bournemouth has been Dorset since 1974, that's 50 years next year.

I haven't actually been in Bournemouth Town center other than to the BIC I'm about 8 years and I live in Poole. I go to castle point for shop shopping. The best parts of the beach are the less central ones.

The weather is the best you are going to get in England, we usually avoid systems that come and get everything milder.

There are several excellent schools, you can't really go wrong. There are also the 4 grammar schools.

Locals seem to think its the wild west crime wise but if you look at national crime stats it is remarkably low.

There's parts to avoid, I generally won't go near Boscombe/Springborne as that is the dumping ground.

I'm originally from a rough part of Birmingham, maybe my perceptions are skewed but if you've been to any rougher inner city area then BCP is far from run down.

Bloody pot holes everywhere though!

QuickNameChangeForMeToday · 26/03/2023 15:05

ReverseFerret · 26/03/2023 14:51

Every experience is different.
I moved from SE England to Clackmannanshire and the entire family was subject to 'fuck off back to your own country', 'why can't you get jobs in your own country?' 'Sassenach', 'English Bitch', bricks thrown at our windows, cars egged, used sanitary towels put through the letterbox, refused service in shops, my brother was stabbed, twice....
That was in the 80's though so hopefully things have changed.
I'm still traumatised to this day.

However... I went to visit a 'friend' as an adult and she mocked my accent in front of her friends to save face... so maybe things haven't.

Just saying you can't predict any scenario.

That’s horrific!

Genuinely not like that where I live (west coast) in my experience.

StJulian2023 · 26/03/2023 15:01

But of course, there are nasty and lovely people everywhere.

I wouldn’t move in your shoes due to education and uni fees. One of my DC is considering a Scottish uni but it’s one full of English students so she won’t feel out of place 🤣

StJulian2023 · 26/03/2023 14:59

Noname77 · 26/03/2023 14:29

There’s no problem with the English accent in Scotland, what do you think we are?

Ha, my siblings and I were bullied relentlessly for our English accents and the first comment my dad got at a petrol station on the way up when we moved was a snide “Aren’t there any jobs in England?”

We’ve all moved back down south where we’re ‘normal’.

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 14:57

ReverseFerret · 26/03/2023 14:51

Every experience is different.
I moved from SE England to Clackmannanshire and the entire family was subject to 'fuck off back to your own country', 'why can't you get jobs in your own country?' 'Sassenach', 'English Bitch', bricks thrown at our windows, cars egged, used sanitary towels put through the letterbox, refused service in shops, my brother was stabbed, twice....
That was in the 80's though so hopefully things have changed.
I'm still traumatised to this day.

However... I went to visit a 'friend' as an adult and she mocked my accent in front of her friends to save face... so maybe things haven't.

Just saying you can't predict any scenario.

People from Clackmannanshire have no right to slag anyone’s accent 😂Im joking … kind of 😂

ReverseFerret · 26/03/2023 14:51

Oohlalaaaaaa · 26/03/2023 11:07

My English husband has never had 1 word about his accent up here. When I've lived in England it is constant "ooh you're not from round here are you?" Etc. Lol. It's like ye no shit sherlock. Don't think anyone cares up here. We have so many English people in the area of Scotland that I'm in.

Every experience is different.
I moved from SE England to Clackmannanshire and the entire family was subject to 'fuck off back to your own country', 'why can't you get jobs in your own country?' 'Sassenach', 'English Bitch', bricks thrown at our windows, cars egged, used sanitary towels put through the letterbox, refused service in shops, my brother was stabbed, twice....
That was in the 80's though so hopefully things have changed.
I'm still traumatised to this day.

However... I went to visit a 'friend' as an adult and she mocked my accent in front of her friends to save face... so maybe things haven't.

Just saying you can't predict any scenario.

Newusernameaug · 26/03/2023 14:51

I’m from a southern county and my dad lives in Poole - whilst I love it down there it’s over priced and there’s just soooo many people everywhere!
beaches are packed, parking is expensive, everything costs.

on the other hand, moved up north (NW Lakes) and love it here, strong sense of community, cheap house prices and cheap rent, some high salaries thanks to Sellafield, loads of things to do that don’t cost anything, beaches, lakes, mountains and Scotland to explore!

deplorabelle · 26/03/2023 14:47

I am another one struggling to work out where on earth you could be living in Scotland that doesn't have coast and/or countryside easily accessible. It makes me wonder how realistic you're being.

How long does it take you currently to reach the countryside and what do you do when you get there?

oviraptor21 · 26/03/2023 14:45

It's rather disingenuous to describe the weather as being only marginally better. It's significantly sunnier, warmer and drier in the south and south west and ten years of climate change is not going to suddenly make the south unbearable.
It's much more common to swim in the sea and participate in watersports.
There are many more days when it's nice to be out and about.

dreamingofsun · 26/03/2023 14:45

are you planning to rent or buy a house? if the latter what is your budget?

As others have said - you will be saddling any kids that go to uni with at least an extra 27k of debt each. Wages are low compared to property costs and public transport is poor (other than in large towns).

However, I wouldnt move from south coast.

Cece92 · 26/03/2023 14:43

Hi OP I'm in central Scotland too, I have immediate family in Liverpool and have stayed there for a bit, they bloody love the Scottish accent. Genuinely the kids will be fine, I work for a big company and used to speak on the phones to customers they loved that our call centre was in Scotland. Xx

WhyPie · 26/03/2023 14:41

I'm in a similar situation to you, which city are you in? (Just wondering if it's the same!)