Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School coming to home to view sick child - Normal?

719 replies

CandlelightGlow · 16/03/2023 10:59

I'm feeling really sensitive right now due to work stress so please be kind.

My 5 year old is off with chicken pox right now. He got the spots on Sunday, he's been quite poorly with it Monday - Tuesday, very sleepy, then very uncomfortable Weds waiting for the scabs to form. He's just started to feel better today but the school have an INSET day tomorrow anyway.

We just had a knock at the door, and it was a teacher from DS's school! He was very reluctant to come downstairs because he's only in his pants and thought the teacher was there to take him to school. She was very nice and said it's sad that they have to do this in this day and age but it's completely normal and they do it for everyone who's been off this length of time.

He's been off for 4 days? His older sister is at school so we've still done the school run every day. To be fair as it's an inset day tomorrow it will be over a week by the time he goes back on Monday. But I've never had a teacher come unannounced to our house to check on our child. Can someone reassure me it is actually normal and they don't think something bad of us! My poor boy is just ill. I've called him in and updated, updated again this morning saying he would be back on Monday!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CallMeCrazyButIDontLikeStoreBoughtPesto · 08/11/2024 07:05

And teacher/school already has a relationship with social services would be instructed on the basis of this visit. If sending a teacher seems extreme, sending SS is more so. Plus they wouldn't have the resource.

CallMeCrazyButIDontLikeStoreBoughtPesto · 08/11/2024 07:03

marchella · 08/11/2024 01:52

Also, how does the teacher/staff member actually know if the child is sick? They aren't doctors. Super weird system. If they are genuinely worried about the child surely that an issue for social services ? I'm still in shock that parents get fined if you take your kids on holidays during term time for and kids have to carry a blazer around all day. We are a bit less uptight about school rules where I live.

It's not just to check if the child's sick - which would be easy to see. More that you aren't abusing/haven't killed them. Kids with low attendance or regularly pulled out of school are a risk and it is a sign that something could be happening. The school and authorities have a duty of care.

Teachers etc seem to be the first to be blamed when kids are abused or worse but then we think it's odd they check!

marchella · 08/11/2024 01:52

Also, how does the teacher/staff member actually know if the child is sick? They aren't doctors. Super weird system. If they are genuinely worried about the child surely that an issue for social services ? I'm still in shock that parents get fined if you take your kids on holidays during term time for and kids have to carry a blazer around all day. We are a bit less uptight about school rules where I live.

Ilovecakey · 07/11/2024 14:42

Yes it is normal nowadays I think they do it to everyone of they have been off 4-5 days. Its since the government are going crazy over attendance. My son was sick so I rang the school and said he will be off for the next 2 day (as the rule of keeping them off 48 hours since they were last sick) and they tried telling me to bring him in the next day, I said no I won't be bringing him in.

premicrois · 07/11/2024 14:30

I have been a primary teacher for 20 years and never have I heard of such a thing. I am in Scotland though, England seems obsessed with attendance from the stories on here!

I'm also in Scotland and having read so many batshit stories about English school 'rules' I wouldn't even put mine in to the system.

Purpleturtle46 · 07/11/2024 09:49

CandlelightGlow · 16/03/2023 10:59

I'm feeling really sensitive right now due to work stress so please be kind.

My 5 year old is off with chicken pox right now. He got the spots on Sunday, he's been quite poorly with it Monday - Tuesday, very sleepy, then very uncomfortable Weds waiting for the scabs to form. He's just started to feel better today but the school have an INSET day tomorrow anyway.

We just had a knock at the door, and it was a teacher from DS's school! He was very reluctant to come downstairs because he's only in his pants and thought the teacher was there to take him to school. She was very nice and said it's sad that they have to do this in this day and age but it's completely normal and they do it for everyone who's been off this length of time.

He's been off for 4 days? His older sister is at school so we've still done the school run every day. To be fair as it's an inset day tomorrow it will be over a week by the time he goes back on Monday. But I've never had a teacher come unannounced to our house to check on our child. Can someone reassure me it is actually normal and they don't think something bad of us! My poor boy is just ill. I've called him in and updated, updated again this morning saying he would be back on Monday!

I have been a primary teacher for 20 years and never have I heard of such a thing. I am in Scotland though, England seems obsessed with attendance from the stories on here!

CallMeCrazyButIDontLikeStoreBoughtPesto · 07/11/2024 06:53

I know this is an old thread but can't hurt anyone seeing it. This is standard process at most schools and it's a good thing. We had it when DD was off for 4 days. It's on the 4th day it kicks in and I don't think they expect much. DD was in bed sleeping, DP was on a call and I was out working so we didn't answer the door. I called the school and explained. I said I was going to pop in to show them the evidence of me contacting a doctor, evidence of her sickness and that was enough for them.

I likely wouldn't have let them in had I been there as I would have been working and if she's sick I may not be keeping up with the cleaning to a high enough standard for people to see. I think they would have been ok with that.

AgentJohnson · 07/11/2024 05:47

I am definitely happy to accept that, but if it's not routine I can't help but feel bad that they would consider me the kind of home where my children would be in trouble.

I can understand that you are taking this as some slight on your parenting but it really isn’t. I suspect that without the lateness this probably wouldn’t have been an issue. Late is late and even if it’s a few minutes it’s still late. The other kids coming in just as you’re leaving could have had their lateness authorised or they would be getting a visit too.

Sadly this kind of check is unusual purely because most schools don’t have the resources or it isn’t a priority, your children’s school has and does. As another mentioned upthread, something might has happened in your children’s school in the past and now they super vigilant.

Use this experience to work on your child being in school on time.

mnreader · 07/11/2024 05:28

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

marchella · 07/11/2024 05:18

Holymargarita. There is no way I would let a random teacher into my house. Social services, sure, police, sure, some dude from school. NO. It's seriously beyond my understanding as a non-UK resident.

V0xPopuli · 06/11/2024 14:52

Processes like this exist not based on any judgement of particular family/parent/child, they are there knowing that an overzealous policy stands a better chance at spotting an issue.

They are willing to accept that it means a slightly bonkers level of scrutiny of normal absences, in order to give a better chance at identifying the kid kept off because:

  • the family have gone on holiday
  • the child is well but school refusing
  • the kid has been abused/neglected
Addry72 · 06/11/2024 14:43

CandlelightGlow · 16/03/2023 10:59

I'm feeling really sensitive right now due to work stress so please be kind.

My 5 year old is off with chicken pox right now. He got the spots on Sunday, he's been quite poorly with it Monday - Tuesday, very sleepy, then very uncomfortable Weds waiting for the scabs to form. He's just started to feel better today but the school have an INSET day tomorrow anyway.

We just had a knock at the door, and it was a teacher from DS's school! He was very reluctant to come downstairs because he's only in his pants and thought the teacher was there to take him to school. She was very nice and said it's sad that they have to do this in this day and age but it's completely normal and they do it for everyone who's been off this length of time.

He's been off for 4 days? His older sister is at school so we've still done the school run every day. To be fair as it's an inset day tomorrow it will be over a week by the time he goes back on Monday. But I've never had a teacher come unannounced to our house to check on our child. Can someone reassure me it is actually normal and they don't think something bad of us! My poor boy is just ill. I've called him in and updated, updated again this morning saying he would be back on Monday!

Hi I am sorry this is late
However. My daughter had the same for my grandaughter who had scarlet fever. I actually hit the roof as this upset my daughter.
I thought I have never heard of this . So I spoke to my friend Google.
The first thing that came up was .about ECHR. and parents have the right to refuse a home visit.
They have "reasons" which are . Child absent for no reason.
School can't contact parent or guardian.
Or The school has received a concerning report.
I am sorry but I totally disagree with this invasion of privacy. A mum ( or dad ) has enough on their plate with looking after a sick kid.as well as normal stuff. To feel accused of being improper. To me is really the last straw.
IF there is true reason for concern IE: Childs safety or welfare ? The social services or even police should be called. .
Please excuse my indignance.
I was a single parent when men just "were not ". Or definitely not common practice. I had to fight in many ways as it was general common thoughts that "A man cannot be a single parent it has to be.a woman"
I swear I couldn't take my baby daughter into mother care mothers room to change her bum when she was changing onto solid food and had stingy pooh. ( as many will know on here )
I had to fight to get use of disabled toilets to again change her nappy. When. I was told by toilet attendant to take her in men's.... I saw manager. Fixed.
Getting on a bus ? Women would watch me getting all our shopping buggy and baby on a bus stone. No "Can I help you " ( as I would allways offer ). Some old lady said "give me the baby son ".
I am sorry I digress. But my point I'd not everything is visible on surface.
It is said as we have often heard. "One is innocent until proven guilty".
So I think it's wrong if you say "my child is sick" That should be taken as fact unless or until proven otherwise.
My daughter goes drs and gets a stamp when child off sick . WHAT THE HELL as if she doesn't have enough to do.
Ladies ( and any gentlemen). I am onside and I will fight this with all my ability .
So please . STAND YOUR CORNER. DO NOT ACCEPT THESE UNANNOUNCED VISITS.
If you wish to play their game. When you get child diagnosed (if you do). Ask Dr "How long should I keep off school"? And ask for a supporting note .
If your child wakes up eith sickness and dioreah ? What is school rules ??? Keep child off for 3 days.
So I think it's a It's a good for all. Not wats good for one not good for another.
Kindly
Adrian

School coming to home to view sick child - Normal?
School coming to home to view sick child - Normal?
applecartsonthehill · 24/03/2023 14:57

Never heard of this happening.

UndertheCedartree · 24/03/2023 14:31

CelestiaNoctis · 18/03/2023 02:30

I'm curious on what would happen if you refused or they wouldn't come downstairs. My child is suspected autistic and definitely wouldn't want a teacher seeing her in her underwear. I understand why they would wanna check incase of neglect or abuse but genuinely what would happen if as you said the child was elsewhere or unwilling to come down. Also it should definitely be on their website and a clear policy parents know about. It's almost like it is hidden to catch parents out or something if they're lying about a holiday or whatever.

When staff came to my house recently my DD was in her room and I didn't want her to come down to a cold doorstep so she just waved at the staff from the window.

Lovelyveg82 · 21/03/2023 10:43

The good news is that at least it seems now the Op will make more of an effort not to be regularly late.

Lovelyveg82 · 21/03/2023 10:42

This wasn’t a teacher

this person was the school pastoral care worker

I am inclined to trust that she knew the law, the school’s policy and her own experience when she turned up at the OP’s house. Added to which, she would have liaised with the child’s teacher and the HT would also have been advised.

So a professional, a teacher and a HT would all have been supportive of this visit.

Unlikely to hear why from the Op

LolaSmiles · 21/03/2023 10:04

lieselotte
Persistent lateness is classed as a safeguarding concern though.That doesn't mean every child who is late is being harmed, but it is something we have to look for.

I think a lot of people think safeguarding is about what happens when a child discloses abuse/neglect/harm, or what happens when staff notice bruises or injuries, but it's not just that. Children don't always disclose.

Often it's about different members of staff or different professionals noticing different things.

One person might notice a pattern in attendance or lateness & report it, another person notices that the child seems unusually withdrawn or emotional at times so reports it, several weeks later a member of lunch staff overhears the child saying they don't like it when mums new partner comes to visit so reports it. None of those members of staff know what the others have noticed, but the DSL will have the information and seek professional advice from relevant agencies about what to do. It could be that the child is finding the introduction of a new partner quite difficult and there's nothing more to it, or it could be that the child is experiencing harm, but the decision on what to do comes from further up, not individual teachers.

Lovelyveg82 · 21/03/2023 09:47

Of course a welfare check needs to actually see the child in question!

lieselotte · 21/03/2023 09:27

The school has made the decision that it fits their policy to do a welfare call, a call that could have easily been avoided probably if the two parents had just been in touch to report the absences

Assuming that neither parent had called, the school could have phoned first. If it didn't receive a response, it could then have dropped round to the house (I guess). But demanding to see a child who is sick in bed? That is way beyond what was needed in this situation. Parent says child has chicken pox - school accepts that and moves on - it will be obvious when the child returns anyway as they will probably still have a few spots. Persistent low level lateness is hardly a safeguarding issue - you only have to read all the posts on here where MNers routinely justify their inability to be on time for anything. It's hardly a safeguarding issue, although annoying and inconsiderate and usually avoidable.

Lovelyveg82 · 21/03/2023 06:01

@BalletBoss in what capacity have you spoken to a lot of families who were treated similarly, so yes, I’ll talk about it.

parents at your children’s school?

BalletBoss · 21/03/2023 02:01

Crumpetdisappointment · 20/03/2023 18:39

that is your case @BalletBoss but for goodness sake this does not apply to ALL Children so please dont berate safeguarding in general.

you may not have liked what happened to you but so many children need welfare checks, it is wrong to raise your case

I’ve already said that since this happening I’ve spoken to a lot of families who were treated similarly, so yes, I’ll talk about it. You don’t get to tell me not to raise our case.

Interestingly, the school did make some changes afterwards as they admitted their procedure was problematic. And some of the staff were spoken to about their attitude apparently.

Many kids do need welfare checks but the more time they waste on situations like ours, they’re not seeing kids or parents that do need help.

Safeguarding should never be a box ticking exercise but that’s exactly what it has become in many schools and that should be raised.

Again, tell me what viewing my child asleep in bed would have told them about his welfare other than he is alive. For an at risk child, it would not help that child at all.

Yoyo2021 · 20/03/2023 22:01

Crumpetdisappointment · 20/03/2023 18:39

that is your case @BalletBoss but for goodness sake this does not apply to ALL Children so please dont berate safeguarding in general.

you may not have liked what happened to you but so many children need welfare checks, it is wrong to raise your case

But @BalletBoss son had been seen by doctors regularly!!!!! It makes me so cross!!!

The comments about them doing it to check the child’s not gone on holiday with parents is ridiculous. Let’s check on our teachers each time they have time off send someone into their room to see them !

LolaSmiles · 20/03/2023 21:39

CandlelightGlow

If it helps OP, I used to think some of the policies and warnings were over the top before I worked in the field. I remember volunteering and sitting in basic safeguarding training thinking "really???" to some of it.

Now I totally understand why policies have to consider what if and be applied to everyone and why schools have to follow up things. It's not because they're being accusatory to anyone, but because it's another layer to try to prevent children slipping through the net.

Up thread I mentioned that I rang in late with a poorly DC once and when I spoke to them they they had me on the list to call because they hadn't heard. If I'd not called and they hadn't heard when they phoned, they'd have done a visit. It wasn't personal to me, nor would it have been overkill, but I can imagine others without safeguarding experience might take it personally.

CandlelightGlow · 20/03/2023 21:25

I do think people take things crazily far though. Part of my anxiety is that I'm highly critical of myself so when I'm worried about anything I have a tendency to centre myself in the situation and assume something I have done is the cause. Me pointing out that because we are sometimes very slightly late because I walk 2 young children in daily from an out of catchment house has become "incapable of getting to school on time"

When I'm not feeling anxious I can be rational and resilient but I would ask you to remember how your words may impact and genuinely affect someone who is already struggling.

OP posts:
CandlelightGlow · 20/03/2023 21:19

LolaSmiles · 20/03/2023 19:43

But you are the one that came up with the extreme ‘what if’ scenario. The one that could happen at any time of the year, not just the 75% of the year that kids armrest expected in school.

It’s not a problem schools following up when there is a genuine concern; of course not. In OP’s case, her DC had a common but nasty childhood illness which she reported to the school the first day. We all know it will take a week (best case scenario) to get better, so there was no need to visit or see her child.

Ok so the whole point of safeguarding is to ask 'what if'. It's not about being extreme.

Schools expect to see children during term time. They do not expect to see children during the holidays.

If we take your idea that because bad things can happen in the holidays schools should abandon their legal safeguarding duty then great. I guess you're also fine with us:
not reporting low level concerns in term time because worse could happen at weekends
not recording changes in a child that could form part of a safeguarding jigsaw because they might also be like that in the holidays
not get involved in anything for term times because considering the what if situations is silly when so much could happen in the holidays

The OP's school has an attendance policy. The OP didn't inform the school in line with policy because they were too busy. The SAHD also didn't inform the school either for whatever reason. They also seem incapable of getting their child to school on time. We also have no idea what else is going on or what else might have been said in real life. The school has made the decision that it fits their policy to do a welfare call, a call that could have easily been avoided probably if the two parents had just been in touch to report the absences.

To confirm, our ringing/messaging in was fine and not a problem. I've messaged in before as the phone system is also automated anyway. I pondered whether that might be a reason for the visit while I was in a bit of a fuzz but it was just a blanket policy (confirmed by school and other parents)

I've also messaged for previous short term absence (say, DD has temp so phone in on day 1, message on day 2). It's just not an issue the way it has been taken up by some posters, our school has a specific reception option to message and they reply to confirm, it's not like I'm messaging class teachers hoping they would pick it up. If they hadn't confirmed by return message I would have called.

Sadly I don't have time to go all the way back through but it's really interesting how many further replies this thread got! I had moved on once I'd stopped being anxious and life has moved on, D S is much better. Thanks for all the words of support while I needed them!

OP posts: