Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do lots of people afford the brand new luxury cars ?

361 replies

Stroganoffo · 02/02/2023 15:24

Keep seeing 22 plate Mercedes, Audi , BMW and tesla, when I was little these were quite rare as only the wealthy had them. Now it seems everyone has one considering the average wage isn't that high and the cost of one is 50k. I have a good wage and still don't want to fork out lots. How are people affording them. Is it all on credit ? Aren't people worried with everything else going up and the cost of living crisis ?.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
xILikeJamx · 02/07/2024 13:42

Keith there raising a year-old thread from the dead because other people don't want to explain what they spend their money on.

Doubtless that some can get themselves into financial difficulty while reaching for things they can't afford, but I'll never understand the mindset of those that go around screeching "You can't afford that!!" at strangers who have nice things.

I'm not aware of German car manufacturers forcing tens of thousands of people into bankruptcy every year, so it can't be all that bad Keith. The last sentence of your post should be nominated for "Stupidest line of the year"

SummerTimeIsTheBest · 02/07/2024 12:59

Mine’s a motability car. I’d do anything not to need a motability car but it is what it is. Before I claimed PIP, we had an older car which we paid £3k in cash for.

GasPanic · 02/07/2024 12:31

Because "financial innovation".

Cars used to be a bit like most things. You get one when you pay the money for it.

Then the financers got in on the act.

Pushing the cost of the car to a monthly payment means several things :

i) It makes the car more affordable in the short term, the tradeoff being that it is more expensive in the long term. This works the same way as mortgages, and means that financers and car companies can push the prices of cars up and skim off money for themselves.

ii) The car company can "capture" your business by making it very expensive for you to exit the plans, so you end up permanently on a plan with them to replace cars.

So paradoxically cars now are more affordable, but ultimately more expensive than they have ever been.

This is a bit like houses where the actual cost of the house is ultimately irrelevant, it is whether you can service the mortgage payment that really determines where you can live.

The benefits are to the consumer, who rather than having to save for years gets instant gratification and the ability to have a new car without having to save for it, at the penalty of paying much more in the long term. And to the financers and car companies who line their pockets with more money that they can skim off, and also confuse the customer as to what they are actually getting into with reams of small print.

Always apply the old addage. If something seems to good to be true, it usually is.

When you go into a car showroom and they push you to go onto finance/PCP, it is because it will ultimately benefit them. Not you.

Keith1616 · 02/07/2024 12:08

Mercedes, Audi , BMW and tesla are all poor people's cars. Those cars clutter up council estates, parked on the streets, in front of houses too small to have drives, proudly displaying how much debt the 'owner' will take just on to impress other, complete stranger, luxury car drivers. Try telling them this and they'll blind you with the sheer stupidity arguing how they can afford the payments but brush off any questions about their pensions or actual assets. They must be trying to convince themselves as they say YOLO I'll be ok on £800 a month state pension or that they don't want to retire early because I don't believe it.

I won't even accept a lift in a car like that as it's a massive red flag that the ride will be an ego fueled death trip controlled by a moron.

Kittycat37uk · 25/07/2023 14:18

Financed up to their eyeballs or mobility whips this is what I've found around my estate anyway. Also a lot of ppl round my way deal drugs and have business they wash money thru so doesn't surprise me either.

Badbadbunny · 25/07/2023 12:23

Blossomtoes · 25/07/2023 11:53

You’re living in the past @Badbadbunny. There are waiting lists for new cars now. We ordered ours in June last year and we get delivery next week. Dealers get commission for selling PCP and finance deals, they’re not going to forgo those and lose more money by offering discounts.

No, I'm really not. Just did it two months ago when we bought our latest car. Yes, there are waiting lists for "some" cars, maybe lots of cars, but at the same time, there are dealerships who do have cars available, particularly ex-demos at certain times of the year. Dealers still have to register demos and at the end of the "demo finance period", they have to shift them on as they have to buy them. Likewise they're still allocated cars for their showrooms and pounds, which, again, they have to shift at the end of the finance/loan period if they've not already sold them or swapped them with another dealer. Yes, I know different manufacturers have different "deals" with their dealerships, and yes, I know, the "new model" will bring them all in line eventually, but for the time being, a lot of the "old" ways of working, car allocation and financing continue as previously!

I'm fully aware of the shifts/trends in car dealerships - I've worked in/for them for decades, and I know exactly how the "new" model works re leasing/PCPs etc. I also know that the networks of new dealerships are falling fast and that eventually it'll all be remote/online and "dealerships" will basically be nothing more than servicing/repair hubs and working on commissions. But we're not there yet and there are still deals to be had if you're flexible and willing to walk away and go elsewhere. Like I say, I successfully did it just two months ago and have a lovely shiny car on the drive to prove it - not our first choice of colour or model, but it's fine and it was available to virtually drive away! Our local dealer couldn't do a deal, but one in a different town 100 miles away could (which we just popped into on the off chance during a short break there), the salesmen brought it round from their compound, we liked it, and we drove home in it the next day. Maybe we were lucky (again). But we've never been too fussy and always happy to accept whatever colour/model they were willing to do a deal on within reason.

Bonfire23 · 25/07/2023 11:57

Blossomtoes · 25/07/2023 11:53

You’re living in the past @Badbadbunny. There are waiting lists for new cars now. We ordered ours in June last year and we get delivery next week. Dealers get commission for selling PCP and finance deals, they’re not going to forgo those and lose more money by offering discounts.

That ^^
We don't give discount for cash and waiting lists have been around 18 months

Blossomtoes · 25/07/2023 11:53

You’re living in the past @Badbadbunny. There are waiting lists for new cars now. We ordered ours in June last year and we get delivery next week. Dealers get commission for selling PCP and finance deals, they’re not going to forgo those and lose more money by offering discounts.

Badbadbunny · 25/07/2023 11:48

Shade17 · 25/07/2023 11:23

We pay cash when we buy new cars, then drive them until the wheels fall off. I guess we're financial idiots.

Yes, you are. You could’ve had the capital working for you for the first three years of ownership. There are still 0% or low rate deals available, for example Volvo have 0% as long as you pay a 50% deposit. Only a complete moron would buy one outright.

Realistically, there aren't always the 0% finance deals available and you can usually negotiate a better deal if you pay upfront and outright, especially if you're "open" to different colours/models as dealers often have some new cars they need to sell quickly so a pretty high discount can be haggled! Two of our least 3 brand new cars we've bought outright we negotiated better deals than we could have got with 0% finance. The best was a whopping 25% discount from list price, plus a proper spare tyre, branded mats and a towbar - list price was £20k and we got all that for £15k. The time before we got 20% off list price. We asked at the time, and those deals wouldn't have been on the table if we'd gone with their 0% finance deals. We've used 0% finance twice but only when we couldn't get a better deal with upfront payment. All the other times, 0% wasn't available and we crunched the numbers to determine that the "low" interest finance deals available weren't cheaper than just paying outright as we couldn't get better interest on savings at that time.

You really have to get the alternatives, do the negotiation, then do the number crunching. You also have to know the best times of year to get the "cash deals" - usually just approaching the quarter ends when dealers are desperate to sell a few more cars to hit their bonus targets or when they've had cars in their pound for a few months that are about to go off the dealer finance/loan scheme and they have to actually pay for them, so again, desperate to shift a car and get money in the bank! (I worked as an accountant for two different main dealerships, so understand how the financing/bonus schemes work, so know how and when to haggle!).

Shade17 · 25/07/2023 11:23

We pay cash when we buy new cars, then drive them until the wheels fall off. I guess we're financial idiots.

Yes, you are. You could’ve had the capital working for you for the first three years of ownership. There are still 0% or low rate deals available, for example Volvo have 0% as long as you pay a 50% deposit. Only a complete moron would buy one outright.

Badbadbunny · 25/07/2023 10:52

Lease costs aren't as expensive as you'd think. A lot of the BMW's, Mercs etc are pretty low spec so aren't as expensive to buy as you'd think.

Re the leases, you're not "buying the car", you're just paying the depreciation over the 3 years. You hand it back after 3 years, and have nothing to show for it. Even worse if you pay an upfront deposit to reduce the monthly lease cost - that's gone forever. "Top" brands such as BMWs, Mercs etc tend not to depreciate as much as middle of the road cars due to the active second hand market, so the depreciation over the first three years isn't as bad.

Basically, if you can afford £300-£500 per month lease payment, you can have a BMW or Merc on your drive. But after 3 months, it gets taken away and you don't have anything to show for it. (Unless you buy it from the lease firm with a "right to buy" or balloon payment equal to the market value at the end of the lease).

Other than that, lots of people have "illegal" income/earnings typically involved in drug dealing or money laundering, or plain old tax evasion by not declaring income, or rich mummy/daddy, etc.

And as others have said, company cars are an attractive "perk", - I've seen stats showing the majority of Teslas are company cars because of the tax perks to both the company and the employee - much better tax allowances to reduce business taxes and minimal benefit in kind tax on the employee. Same with the 4 door crew cab pickup trucks (Mitsubishi Shogun etc) which seem very popular with wives of self employed scaffolders, roofers, driveway firms etc - where they're pretending to be used in the business but in reality, it's just for the wife's school run and drive to have her hair/nails done!

Rosscameasdoody · 07/02/2023 19:41

x2boys · 06/02/2023 20:51

Or sorry to.point have a child who receive the highest rate in mobility for DLA,we have a mobility car as my son get,s
HRM under the severe mental impairment component

Yes - also paid for child DLA for a child under 16 and will be reassessed when they reach that age and transition to PIP.

Thirtyandflailing · 06/02/2023 21:51

They’ll be leasing. I used to lease a brand new Mercedes cla was around £400pm. I currently own a 5 year old Range Rover outright but will be selling this soon to lease something brand new again. For me it’s easier to have a car fully maintained and is a good option but only if you won’t miss the £££ every month

x2boys · 06/02/2023 20:51

Rosscameasdoody · 06/02/2023 19:55

Yes. But you have to be able to put down thousands of pounds as a deposit on a car that will be handed back in three years. Most disabled people don’t care about status symbol cars - they only care about something they can easily access to drive and that will be reliable enough to get them from A to B comfortably and safely. The first thing to say is that being unemployed has nothing to do with getting a disability - Motability - car. You have to be severely disabled and in receipt of the higher rate mobility component of PIP - very difficult to claim successfully. Motability don’t offer cars for sale - they are lease only. If you are seeing high end cars in your area and think they are motability cars, you have to consider one thing. If you require complicated adaptations in order to be able to drive a car if you’re disabled, or if you require wheelchair access, then high end vehicles are likely to be more suitable to these adaptations than the basic ones - even if you require an automatic transmission, they fall into the higher end category on motability. There is a fund provided by motability to finance these adaptations for people who need them, and that may be what you’re seeing.

Or sorry to.point have a child who receive the highest rate in mobility for DLA,we have a mobility car as my son get,s
HRM under the severe mental impairment component

Rosscameasdoody · 06/02/2023 19:55

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

Yes. But you have to be able to put down thousands of pounds as a deposit on a car that will be handed back in three years. Most disabled people don’t care about status symbol cars - they only care about something they can easily access to drive and that will be reliable enough to get them from A to B comfortably and safely. The first thing to say is that being unemployed has nothing to do with getting a disability - Motability - car. You have to be severely disabled and in receipt of the higher rate mobility component of PIP - very difficult to claim successfully. Motability don’t offer cars for sale - they are lease only. If you are seeing high end cars in your area and think they are motability cars, you have to consider one thing. If you require complicated adaptations in order to be able to drive a car if you’re disabled, or if you require wheelchair access, then high end vehicles are likely to be more suitable to these adaptations than the basic ones - even if you require an automatic transmission, they fall into the higher end category on motability. There is a fund provided by motability to finance these adaptations for people who need them, and that may be what you’re seeing.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 06/02/2023 16:14

Neededanewuserhandle · 06/02/2023 16:06

Rolls/Bentley/Ferrari would be posh/exclusive.

Audis are a VW/Skoda in a posh frock - they share loads of mechanical parts between the VAG brands so all you are paying extra for is a badge and some marketing.

If you want exclusive - Ford sold way fewer Mondeos (before they axed it) than BMW sold 3 series. Audi, BMW, Mercedes etc are pretty much ubiquitous, not something anyone would get for exclusiviity.

it’s pretty much the same with all of them

Bentley bentayga shares parts with the Volkswagen Touareg.
ferrari shares with fiat
rolls shares with bmw

mercedes shares with Renault, the vans share with fiat.

new Volkswagen caddy is Volkswagen in the front ford connect in the rear.

VAG are just a bit more obvious about it than others.

Neededanewuserhandle · 06/02/2023 16:06

Amy1992Brighton · 06/02/2023 15:25

Slightly off topic but DH wants to get an Audi but I have heard they are quite "common" now?? Lots of the other parents at the school gates seem to have Audis so they don't seem as posh / exclusive as they once did.

Rolls/Bentley/Ferrari would be posh/exclusive.

Audis are a VW/Skoda in a posh frock - they share loads of mechanical parts between the VAG brands so all you are paying extra for is a badge and some marketing.

If you want exclusive - Ford sold way fewer Mondeos (before they axed it) than BMW sold 3 series. Audi, BMW, Mercedes etc are pretty much ubiquitous, not something anyone would get for exclusiviity.

MissConductUS · 06/02/2023 15:46

Audi is not seen as a very posh/exclusive brand in the US. That may be in part due to relatively poor reliability.

repairpal.com/reliability/audi

A friend traded hers in after the third time it had to be towed to the dealership under warranty. I think she replaced it with a Subaru.

Amy1992Brighton · 06/02/2023 15:25

Slightly off topic but DH wants to get an Audi but I have heard they are quite "common" now?? Lots of the other parents at the school gates seem to have Audis so they don't seem as posh / exclusive as they once did.

letitb · 06/02/2023 14:48

Well when I leased my bmw it was £50 a month cheaper than the ford equivilent... basically because your paying the depreciation and bmw and Mercedes hold their value more.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 06/02/2023 14:39

We pcp also, just traded in our current car with £2,500 part exchange given to us by garage with contribution etc towards a brand new car. I used to HP but never kept a car past the 3 years, this is working better for us

x2boys · 06/02/2023 14:36

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

You can but you would have to.pay a deposit running into the thousands .

BillieJeanmm · 06/02/2023 14:20

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

Bloopsie · 06/02/2023 09:26

Kittycat37uk · 05/02/2023 12:06

They will be either credited up to high heaven or could even be a disability whip. I live on a fairly poor council estate and the amount of brand new 22 plate cars I've seen park up and knowing most of the people on the estate I know for a fact someone who doesn't work could never afford an expensive new car so will be on DLA High rate mobility where they give u a car and all u have to do is pat for the petrol dwp pay insurance and tax etc

Dla high rate mobility is soooo hard to get, they have really toughened the criteria even epilepsy,limb discrepency etc dosent qualify for it.

we are looking for a new car, tourneo new ones are 60k second hand about 5 years old is 30ish k. What would be better pcp for a new or take a loan for older version and pay it off over 5 years?

Kazzyhoward · 05/02/2023 14:19

Low interest rates have made leasing more popular, but that is changing now that we have higher interest rates. The good deals people got a few years ago won't be replicated in the future when costs of borrowings are higher, and even more-so when the current "bubble" in used car prices ends.