Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Permanent exclusion-how do I find a new school that will take an excluded child?

635 replies

Alwaystoblame · 27/05/2022 14:10

Posting for traffic.
How do I go about finding my Dd a new school if she's been permanently excluded? How likely are good schools to take her on in year 10 with an appalling attendance and behaviour record? She's very bright and doing very well academically when are bothers to go to class and do the homework. Attendance in in the 60s for this year. Even when she dies go in she is late and/or truants classes.
I have 2 previous threads about the issues she's having but I wanted to ask specifically about new schools without getting detailed.

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 28/05/2022 09:57

Sherrystrull · 28/05/2022 08:04

Op, having heard about her behaviour you seem to be focusing on the wrong things. I was shocked reading about what she had done to others and yet you don't really seem bothered about that. There are multiple children who are miserable because of her. Any other school will rightly be very wary about taking her. I think the PRU is the best option, not only for her but the safety of others.

I don't agree with this.

OP has repeatedly said what her DD has done is awful and she's gutted she's done it.

But it's also fair enough she's reflecting how sad it it that her dd has lost her way and become the person she is now.

You can hate your child's behaviour whilst still living and worrying for them because their your child.

FloweryCurtainTwitcher · 28/05/2022 09:55

Galaxyrippleforever · 27/05/2022 16:34

A PRU will take her.

And where are the mythical PRU places?

emaline83 · 28/05/2022 08:41

PixellatedPixie · 27/05/2022 14:55

If she’s smart but has behavioural issues and doesn’t like going into school then is there a way she could just do her work from home? Like a home schooling arrangement? There must be a reason she doesn’t want to be in school!

This. I don't know the back story as haven't seen the other threads people are mentioning but I have a friend who teaches at an online British international school. She says there are more and more of them opening now since covid and a lot of the kids that are enrolling at hers this year are in the UK rather than expats but for a range of reasons regular school isn't working for them. Worth looking into. But as a teacher too, I would think repeating year 10 is going to be essential as sounds like she's missed a lot.

Dashdotdotdash · 28/05/2022 08:22

The view of rolling hills and ancient woodlands has clearly done nothing for your daughter, so maybe a change will help. She needs to reflect on the fact that she is fortunate not to be in youth custody.

PumpkinPie2016 · 28/05/2022 08:19

I'm sorry you are going through this OP - it sounds horrendous. While the fair access protocols exist to help pupils who have been excluded find a school, there are limits.

Your daughter's behaviour sounds extreme and she is a danger to others - violently attacking other pupils and sending messages to the point that the police are involved goes beyond a teenager being challenging. She has, ultimately, committed a crime.

I think a PRU is the most likely option and it may be best for your daughter. The staff in PRUs are trained to deal with challenging pupils and the groups are very small.

I hope a solution is found 🌺

Oligodendrocyte · 28/05/2022 08:18

I feel for you as her parent. Your devastation comes across in the posts, and I can see you want better and brighter things for your child.

Ultimately, I think I'd take a huge step back and let her face the consequences of her actions. Whilst she's always got people in her corner, excusing her behaviour, she won't change. Maybe she doesn't want to change, and that's on her.

At 15, she knows right from wrong. She's a violent thug. Her behaviour is abhorrent and she needs to learn the reality. Personally, I wish the law was harsher on dealing with violence committed by teens. Maybe she'd buck up if she could see she was destroying her own life by not receiving an education and getting a criminal record.

It's saddening to know her victims have suffered this, by being physically attacked and the cyber bullying telling someone to kill themselves. I was bullied for years. It never leaves you, and causes so many issues. Your daughter is ruining many lives.

Sherrystrull · 28/05/2022 08:04

Op, having heard about her behaviour you seem to be focusing on the wrong things. I was shocked reading about what she had done to others and yet you don't really seem bothered about that. There are multiple children who are miserable because of her. Any other school will rightly be very wary about taking her. I think the PRU is the best option, not only for her but the safety of others.

Sortilege · 28/05/2022 00:59

I can’t believe she’s been beating people up and you’re concerned that she’s lost a view of ancient woodland.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 28/05/2022 00:47

OP having read both this thread and your one about her bullying violent behaviour I can't see how getting another school to take her would benefit her or anyone else. Nothing changes, so nothing would change. The same behaviour would occur again. She would discount permanent exclusion as something to worry about as her and her Dad would just think she'd move schools again. She's not sorry for the violence or the bullying or the mental abuse she's heaped on other children and she would do it again, more children would suffer. I'd hope my school wouldn't accept a child who behaved like that. This sort of bullying can leave permanent mental scars on children and cause PTSD.

Having actual consequences, like going to a PRU might possibly get her to think about what she's done and see that the behaviour is unacceptable. A managed move wouldn't achieve that. She needs to feel the natural consequences of her behaviour. I'd be much more worried about the path she's on threatening violence then her achieving GCSE and University entrance. There are ways to go to university later, right now she needs to know her behaviour is unacceptable, the behaviour needs to stop before it results in life long consequences, referral to a PRU might be a step towards that.

I'm sorry for what you are going through, but trying to protect her from the consequences of her behaviour helps no one, including her and you. Make it clear to her you are there to support her when she's ready then take a big step back.

SD1978 · 28/05/2022 00:29

I'm sorry- and I know it goes against everything that you want to do- but stop. If she and him reckon that it's all going to be plain sailing getting in somewhere- leave them to it. Let her know she's always got your love and support, and be there when it all falls down. Let her and her dad sort it, since they seem to think they can

Johnnysgirl · 28/05/2022 00:27

She's not coping now...

Alwaystoblame · 28/05/2022 00:26

It's relevant to how she'll feel about a new school. She's been brought up in a nice area and it will be a huge change for her. She doesn't cope with change at all. I'm just feeling very sad tonight for her. I love her and want her to be happy and healthy. I worry about how she will cope. I know she has very little in the way of choices now and it's up to her to make the best of wherever she goes. This is not what I wanted for my Dd at all. She was doing so well in years 7-9 and it's devastating to see her this lost. But the welfare of the other kids is important and she's gone too far now and they deserve to go to school without fear.

OP posts:
CoralBells · 28/05/2022 00:23

She needs to be away from the school for the children's safety and will being. You said yesterday that she messaged someone to kill themselves. It sounds like a PRU would be better for her with the small classes

Johnnysgirl · 28/05/2022 00:03

She's used to looking out at green fields, ancient woodland and wildlife and having fantastic facilities . The staff where she is are excellent. They genuinely care and are so approachable and nurturing
I'm sorry, but what's the relevance of this?
She barely shows up and when she does she makes other people's lives a misery.

The rolling hills are not working for her, and she's taking the piss out of the nurturing staff as well.

Alwaystoblame · 27/05/2022 23:56

My friend used to work in the PRU nearest to me. She says it is like a prison where the doors are kept locked and break time is spent in a yard with 8ft high spiked fencing. The gates are opened for drop off and pick up but otherwise locked as are the doors. It's a small school. It used to be a small primary school and is surrounded by fields. The other PRU is in a deprived area, again in a previous primary school, and is very urban with no green spaces nearby. She's used to looking out at green fields, ancient woodland and wildlife and having fantastic facilities . The staff where she is are excellent. They genuinely care and are so approachable and nurturing. My own experience of several high schools involved no nurturing at all. My emotions are fluctuating on this and I feel quite angry now that she has thrown away such a fantastic place for the sake of a toxic friendship. Dd is as equally to blame as the awful girl she is partner in crime with and school agree that Dd has no hope of improving if she stays in the same school as her friend. She's such a fool. She's not really talking to me at the moment but I hope she will as I'd like to know how she's feeling and to tell her face to face that I'm always there for her. 15 is still so young and she has lost her way badly.

OP posts:
Lickerz · 27/05/2022 23:36

Violent attack on another girl?! That poor girl. This isn't just abit of truanting she's an actual danger to others. Sounds likely to be sent to a PRU, my DH works in one. She's lucky it's not prison school (dh has worked in one of those too and they are seriously awful).

PRU is very different to mainstream. Shorter days, less kids per class. Obviously all the kids are very naughty! Less academic in terms of usually the kids are put in for the lower equivalent exams rather than GCSE (not sure what they are called sorry) but he does put the brighter ones in for gcse if thinks they'll get it. Although bright ones are rare by the sounds of things tbh (he gets very excited when he does get one)

Hopefully it will be a wake up call for her. As others have said tho I don't think there's much you can do, she needs to learn actions have consequences. You can't go around battering people and expect to just carry on your life

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 27/05/2022 23:14

Alwaystoblame · 27/05/2022 21:28

I agree that she should be excluded. I just feel extremely sad for her. She wants to go to uni and could do so easily if she behaved. She's a very talented artist with a particular personal style and produces stunning artwork; very talented at English and a natural at History, science and maths. She already has a modern language GCSE at a good grade. This is what makes it so frustrating.

She maybe, but unless her bullying and verbal and physical attacks on other pupils is brought under control, nothing will change.

No one should go to school worried they are going to be bullied.

itsgettingweird · 27/05/2022 21:35

Alwaystoblame · 27/05/2022 16:26

She has the right to a place the HT has said so a school will have to take her. Goodness knows which one though. Online learning isn't a good idea for Dd. She needs a teacher present to keep her engaged. Left to her own devices she'll be gaming instead of in online lessons. She's not supervised at her dad's and no one would be there to make sure she's working when she should be because he's either at work or asleep.
I'm tempted to leave her dad to it and let him come to the realisation that there is no way out of this situation. He can't charm anyone because her record speaks for itself as much as he denies the problems.

I do think this is a good idea.

Her dad has allowed it to get to this point and needs to to face the consequences of his actions as much as your dd.

I'd say your job is to let dd know you love her, will support her and always have a home for her if she wants it.

Johnnysgirl · 27/05/2022 21:31

Alwaystoblame · 27/05/2022 21:28

I agree that she should be excluded. I just feel extremely sad for her. She wants to go to uni and could do so easily if she behaved. She's a very talented artist with a particular personal style and produces stunning artwork; very talented at English and a natural at History, science and maths. She already has a modern language GCSE at a good grade. This is what makes it so frustrating.

God, not to stick the boot in, op, but she's also on the way to becoming a violent thug.
This needs to be addressed before anything else. Literally before anything else.

Alwaystoblame · 27/05/2022 21:28

I agree that she should be excluded. I just feel extremely sad for her. She wants to go to uni and could do so easily if she behaved. She's a very talented artist with a particular personal style and produces stunning artwork; very talented at English and a natural at History, science and maths. She already has a modern language GCSE at a good grade. This is what makes it so frustrating.

OP posts:
Sortilege · 27/05/2022 21:18

A PRU might be really good for her, in terms of a tailored programme and good staff ratios. It could be her best chance of a handful of GCSEs.

Johnnysgirl · 27/05/2022 21:18

Alwaystoblame · 27/05/2022 21:16

They don't want to permanently exclude her but her behaviour leaves them with no choice. She was very lucky to get a final warning after the extremely violent attack on another girl in her year. Now she's bullying those in younger years and threatening them with violence. Violence that they know she is capable of. She's making life at school impossible for one particular girl to the point the police are involved.

Then she really should be excluded, sorry.
Multiple children shouldn't have to put up with that nonsense just to keep her in a school she likes so much she only shows up 60% of the time.

Alwaystoblame · 27/05/2022 21:16

They don't want to permanently exclude her but her behaviour leaves them with no choice. She was very lucky to get a final warning after the extremely violent attack on another girl in her year. Now she's bullying those in younger years and threatening them with violence. Violence that they know she is capable of. She's making life at school impossible for one particular girl to the point the police are involved.

OP posts:
OnceuponaRainbow18 · 27/05/2022 20:44

The school won’t want to permanently exclude your DD, will be a last resort, as it costs so much money! I would start getting her name on waiting lists for local schools and try and make an arrangement with her current one!

illbeinthegarden · 27/05/2022 20:38

Can she start a college in September early? Our sixth form offers GCSEs and we sometimes have year 11s start with us early?

Swipe left for the next trending thread