Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think buying furniture brand new is a waste of money?

136 replies

maklenehan · 01/08/2021 19:39

Sure some items are a lot better new than used, like sofas or mattresses.

But I don’t understand why people spend so much money on brand new furniture, when in 6 months time it’ll be worth about half what paid.

I went to a furniture shop recently and saw some MDF furniture that might last 10 years before looking scruffy/dated for over £1000 for a chest of drawers (West elm). When you can get a solid oak piece that looks timeless for £500. Looks a lot more solid and won’t break easily.

I also get that modern house owners want modern furniture, but there’s loaaads of 1960s furniture available cheap that is solid Teak, and the equivalent modern copies are vastly more expensive and worse quality.

OP posts:
LionSGuard · 01/08/2021 22:40

Most people don't go on to sell their furniture after 6 months though so why would they care if it depreciates?

Most of the things in my bedroom for example, drawers, wardrobe, bedside tables and so on, I've had for years.

justasking111 · 01/08/2021 22:39

A lot of modern furniture is designed for smaller rooms in modern homes. Buying second hand can be rewarding, upcycling can be fun. But it has to fill the space.

When we downsized a lot of stuff had to go. We did buy some furniture off our sellers because it worked in the room.

Panickingpavlova · 01/08/2021 22:39

I get all sorts but most of the most lovely antique pieces were free from free cycle!

HasaDigaEebowai · 01/08/2021 22:37

It dose depend on the style you’re going for. My house is modern farmhouse and so its easy to buy second hand, particularly since you can paint things or strip them to tie them in together. Loads of my furniture is second hand (not sofas or mattresses). If my look was ultra modern it would be more difficult to find suitable stuff.

I agree that the 60s teak us now ultra trendy. In the place I live there’s a whole shop dedicated to it at bonkers prices.

eBay delivery services are good and you can get most things shipped to you very cheaply.

MagratsDanglyCharms · 01/08/2021 22:29

ExH wrecked the last new sofa I bought. Instead of buying new again I ditched him :D Now I have an old family sofa and it's lasting well

JulesCobb · 01/08/2021 22:29

Certainly was a waste of money for me. Bought new sideboard. Three weeks later, the dog peed on it.

MirandaMarple · 01/08/2021 22:28

@sst1234 I certainty do not invest in furniture to replace it quickly, I'd rather sacrifice my time than my money.

sst1234 · 01/08/2021 22:25

@MirandaMarple

Because time is valuable. Also the idea that things were well made only in olden days is a false analogy. Finally, furniture is as much about aesthetics as it is about functionality and durability. No one would choose to buy ugly furniture just because it was old and supposedly of good quality. For a lot of items of furniture it makes sense to to buy new, but not particularly expensive or durable because you may want to replace it to update the look of a room.

FastFood · 01/08/2021 22:21

Honestly I couldn't care less about the re-sellable value of my furniture. Not everything needs to hold a return on investement potential.

Second hand furniture (like mid century) can be extremely expensive.

I've got a mix of new, second hand and home made.
My shelves are brand new, it's a designer's piece, that I can take with me when I leave. This model has been a design staple for 60 years, it's not the kind of stuff that can get outdated anytime soon.
I also bought a brand new armchair, because I fell in love with the design. Didn't want anything else.
I'm considering another side table, I'm looking at new designers on the scene. I also look at second hand, but I like the idea of contributing to emerging designers.
And the chase is so exciting. I may find perfect second hand, but I keep my options open.

This said, as a design fan, I'm also perfectly aware that furniture doesn't make everything in a place.

A friend of mine has a fantastic flat, its all ikea and it looks fab, she used the furniture as a generic canvas and put a lot of attention into lighting sources, wall decor, accessories, and the flat itself has a lot of character with exposed brick, metal beams etc...

Dreamstate · 01/08/2021 22:14

Unless the second hand furniture was sin pieces absolutely no way I could get it round the right turns upstairs.

I'm happy to buy ikea brand new ofs pretty cheap and so far in still new condition after 8yrs. I actually took down a pax wardrobe to move it to another room, carefully taking it apart. Unfortunately I made a lazy mistake when putting it together and if broke. Lucky replacing the wardrobe frame was only £60. If I had paid hundreds its hurt my pocket more.

Also with ikea so easy to change things like doors, internal storage/shelving etc. It's an affordable way of updating and they have marching sets not something you often find with second hand furniture

Kitkat151 · 01/08/2021 22:14

I have a mixture...
My old ektorp ikea sofa is 20 years old....we got a new loose cover for £95 and it’s as good as new....latest bedroom furniture for spare room is ikea but in lounge and family room I have g plan, ercol and Nathan....all picked up from eBay.... I love 60s/70s elm.... the grain is beautiful...
that was in the days before Dutch elm disease... we will never see it again unfortunately in new furniture

MirandaMarple · 01/08/2021 22:13

@sst1234

There is nothing about your argument. If you make the same point about cars, it makes sense. For furniture no. If you want a white Audi A3, sure it makes to wait 4 weeks and buy a used car with hardly any mileage that will have dropped upto 30% in value. Because there are limited number of car makes and models. For someone wanting to buy a piece of furniture to fit their style of decor, in their style of house, in the right colour, who has time to and find something so specific that is used.
Why are people in such a rush? If you want something specific, well made and second hand why haven't people got the time to wait?
sst1234 · 01/08/2021 21:43

There is nothing about your argument. If you make the same point about cars, it makes sense. For furniture no. If you want a white Audi A3, sure it makes to wait 4 weeks and buy a used car with hardly any mileage that will have dropped upto 30% in value. Because there are limited number of car makes and models. For someone wanting to buy a piece of furniture to fit their style of decor, in their style of house, in the right colour, who has time to and find something so specific that is used.

MirandaMarple · 01/08/2021 21:37

Disagree about new sofas being better than new ones.

I think in the past twenty years I've bought 2 mattresses, one sofa and a kid's bunk bed, new.

Every single thing in my house is second hand (lots of mid century furniture, sofas, fireside chairs, lamps, fabrics etc)

Anything that's worth buying new is far too expensive , for me.

pinkcircustop · 01/08/2021 21:34

YABU. I want all my furniture brand new and I want it all to match.

You couldn’t pay me to take second hand furniture.

SarahAndQuack · 01/08/2021 21:32

@maklenehan

Sure some items are a lot better new than used, like sofas or mattresses.

But I don’t understand why people spend so much money on brand new furniture, when in 6 months time it’ll be worth about half what paid.

I went to a furniture shop recently and saw some MDF furniture that might last 10 years before looking scruffy/dated for over £1000 for a chest of drawers (West elm). When you can get a solid oak piece that looks timeless for £500. Looks a lot more solid and won’t break easily.

I also get that modern house owners want modern furniture, but there’s loaaads of 1960s furniture available cheap that is solid Teak, and the equivalent modern copies are vastly more expensive and worse quality.

Surely there's pros and cons to both?

Some brand new furniture will hold its value well; some second hand furniture is sold for far more than it's worth.

I don't think it has anything to do with how modern your house is, does it?

IMO a chest of drawers is something you need to look at carefully. A lovely old piece might be fine, but if the wood has warped it's horrible. I wouldn't buy something like that without seeing. But I could buy an IKEA equivalent sight unseen, because if it doesn't open smoothly, I can return it. That's been a big consideration during the pandemic.

SarahAndQuack · 01/08/2021 21:28

*live

SarahAndQuack · 01/08/2021 21:28

@ThisIsStartingToBoreMe

I brought my furniture new because the price includes delivery. If I buy second hand I have to pick up the furniture myself and i'm not physically capable of doing that.
Where do you like? In the UK/US and most of Europe you can get second-hand furniture with delivery included.
Ilikeknitting · 01/08/2021 21:26

But surely my furniture choices have zero impact on your life?

Find something worthy to worry about. I’ll carry on loving my gorgeous Cotswold solid wood furniture.

Datingandnoideahowto · 01/08/2021 21:20

How do I get second hand furniture picked up and delivered?

It probably wouldn’t fit through my doors either my hall is very narrow and weirdly shaped.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 01/08/2021 21:19

I googled teak furniture 😂
My granfma had it. Nope. I stick with Ikea.
I think lots of people still have ikea in their heads as £5 and big wardrobes, but they really wxpanded into different budgets.
I have kitchen from them and love it too

Mummyoflittledragon · 01/08/2021 21:17

I like quality furniture. We bought new bedroom furniture for all the bedrooms, coffee table, dining table / chairs apart from dd’s room and other bits and bobs. All are now around 2 decades old so we’ve got our use out of them. They are still in great shape and I have no intention of changing them.

We also have a few antique pieces, certain bits from IKEA and the office furniture is from the 1970’s. Dd’s bedroom furniture is the only new purchase and a couple of years old.

Why the hell would I buy damaged cast offs?

Freddiefox · 01/08/2021 21:16

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

Second hand sofas are often vile.
Some of the stuff on Facebook is in really good condition
Blippibloppi · 01/08/2021 21:16

I don't change my furniture every 6 months though so I'm not bothered about resale. We've got a mix - found the odd vintage piece (1960s) but it's few and far between unless you're willing to travel and have a big enough car/van, everything else was bought new. We've got some IKEA stuff that's 15 years old now and still looks in good condition.

Blossomtoes · 01/08/2021 21:14

I think sixties teak is an acquired taste

On the whole it’s millennials and younger who like it. It’s huge in
London and will undoubtedly ripple out. You can see its influence on new furniture already with all the tapered and hairpin legs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread