Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To live without a dining table??

263 replies

inmyshoos · 05/12/2020 12:07

Can't fit in a dining table in our new house. We have a massive corner sofa and it barely fits in itself. Aibu to just sit there and eat? I really love a table, feels weird not having one. Have even considered weird coffee tables that convert to dining tables but they look weird as heck.

Will I desperately miss a table? Aibu to think we can live without one?

Our dining table is old and cost 50 quid second hand, our sofa was 3k.Confused

OP posts:
PattyPan · 07/12/2020 00:02

@Tw1nset I know, I just meant it’s not very practical to not have a table! Pizza/takeaway maybe, but I can’t imagine eating a proper meal on the sofa.

StoneofDestiny · 06/12/2020 21:21

It's grim eating meals on a sofa - it's important to teach children how to dine properly.
Sell the huge sofa and go for smaller one, then get a folding table.
I'd rather my kids sat on a cushion on the floor to watch tv than to eat at a sofa.

blowinahoolie · 06/12/2020 21:10

Have a kitchen table and dining table at home. Breakfast, lunch and supper eaten at kitchen table and dinner eaten at dining table with whole family. I enjoy hearing about DCs day when they get in from school. No one is allowed phones whilst eating together. It's precious time to catch up with each other and show an interest in how they are, how the day was, etc.

When not eating dinner, the table is used for arts and crafts, sewing (rarely!!), homework, boardgames (Bingo being the most recent) and putting washing basket on to fold up washing. All family life centres around this table whether I like it or not😂

I grew up eating round the table, as did DH with his family. We just don't know any different, really.

Nothing wrong at all with eating dinner in front of TV or at a coffee table either. Eating regularly at a restaurant or with relatives could easily teach children table manners, if you don't own a table at home. It's not a be all or end all situation!

Tw1nset · 06/12/2020 20:56

@PattyPan

I couldn’t be doing without a table to eat at. We have a living/dining room with 4 seater dining table and only a 2 seater sofa because of how the space worked out. I think eating on the sofa would be too messy plus what do you do with the other stuff on the table like condiments, gravy boat etc?
Will somebody think of the condiments? GrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrin
MustardMitt · 06/12/2020 20:49

@Runmybathforme

I think if you have children it’s essential. How do you teach them table manners otherwise ?
You don't eat from a trough just because you might have a tray on your lap, or from a coffee table or whatever.

Lots of people on this thread without the imagination to understand that not everyone has the space for a table.

Runmybathforme · 06/12/2020 19:38

I think if you have children it’s essential. How do you teach them table manners otherwise ?

MustardMitt · 06/12/2020 19:31

It reads like you chose a massive sofa over a dining table

Confused It reads like the sofa preceded the house.

kowari · 06/12/2020 18:48

[quote Sweetsforsweets]@kowari

Single dad with two secondary aged children in one bed flat.

Surely, surely you appreciate that this scenario must be very very rare.[/quote]
I don't think it is rare for families to live in overcrowded housing.

Sweetsforsweets · 06/12/2020 18:18

@kowari

Single dad with two secondary aged children in one bed flat.

Surely, surely you appreciate that this scenario must be very very rare.

NeonIcedcoffee · 06/12/2020 18:18

Lol at the idea eating on the sofa is grim. That's so mumsnet.

kowari · 06/12/2020 18:15

what do you do with the other stuff on the table like condiments, gravy boat etc? Use them in the kitchen. I've never owned a gravy boat nor made gravy in my life.

kowari · 06/12/2020 18:09

@KleinBlue

For me it’s far less about table manners, or dropping peas down between the sofa cushions, than not sitting face to face with the others in your household and talking without watching tv or other distractions.

I’m assuming that the people who always eat on the sofa also eat watching tv, as most sofas are positioned for that reason, and I think that’s likely to make you inattentive to your food, and lead to more mindless eating.

No, we don't have a licence, only Netflix, and that's only on when the washing up is done as I can't relax until then.
kowari · 06/12/2020 18:07

@Sweetsforsweets

And they’re not going to be in one room flats in central London
A single father and two secondary aged children I know are in a one bed flat, waiting to eventually be given a two bed. The father is sleeping in the living room.
PattyPan · 06/12/2020 17:52

I couldn’t be doing without a table to eat at. We have a living/dining room with 4 seater dining table and only a 2 seater sofa because of how the space worked out. I think eating on the sofa would be too messy plus what do you do with the other stuff on the table like condiments, gravy boat etc?

KleinBlue · 06/12/2020 17:19

For me it’s far less about table manners, or dropping peas down between the sofa cushions, than not sitting face to face with the others in your household and talking without watching tv or other distractions.

I’m assuming that the people who always eat on the sofa also eat watching tv, as most sofas are positioned for that reason, and I think that’s likely to make you inattentive to your food, and lead to more mindless eating.

Oblomov20 · 06/12/2020 17:13

I too would sell the sofa. We eat nearly every evening meal at the dining table. And breakfast, and lunch. At sit and chat. And work. It's very important family time to me.

PriceEmUp · 06/12/2020 17:13

I cannot fathom not having a table. But then we don’t eat on the sofa ever, other than maybe an occasional pizza but I think that’s happened about twice.

Can you get a folding bar table and some stools? They’re really good for space saving

Sweetsforsweets · 06/12/2020 17:11

@Roominmyhouse

I have a table but still eat my dinner sat on the sofa most nights! We have trays with bean bag bottoms so you can still eat properly with a knife and fork which apparently would shock lots of the posters here. Lots of people do this, it doesn’t mean they are incapable of table manners.
I have no doubt that you can teach children to eat properly and have manners whilst not at a dining table... although let’s be honest, not to same extent. A dining table IMO is not about manners. It’s about facing one another, no electronics, and enjoying dinner and chatting together
Sweetsforsweets · 06/12/2020 17:09

And they’re not going to be in one room flats in central London

Sweetsforsweets · 06/12/2020 17:09

[quote CakeRequired]@Hellotheresweet

You've chosen a cheaper area of the country to search in there. I've seen 'flats' in London that are one room, a separated tiny bathroom with the bedroom put above it in like a little loft. And people do rent them.

Lived in a 2 bedroom terraced house myself that didn't have room for a dining table even a fold out one without meaning you couldn't walk around properly and would be constantly bumping into it. It only had room for one 2 seater couch too because it was that small. Thankfully only rented that.

You can find small houses that you can fit a dining table in, but not all can. Ops house is one of them, and why should she get rid of an expensive sofa in replacement of a £50 table just because a bunch of people online tell her to? That will be fun, she gets rid of that and those old chairs are all she has to sit on. Very comfortable. Hmm

Maybe rather than people saying it's grim, disgusting etc you should appreciate what you have and stop looking down at others and maybe just be thankful that you can afford better. You might find at some point, your luck ends and that precious dining table will have to go. How will any of you cope then? Grin[/quote]
A one room flat is going to be lived in by one person.
In that scenario then a dining table would really be very difficult to squeeze in!

However we are talking about families here.

SecretSpAD · 06/12/2020 16:50

Well we have a large dining room and a large table in it. It is laid with the family silver every night and we think that people who don't do that or dress for dinner are grim and scummy.

Of course, in real life the dining room table is full of crap and we eat ok our laps whilst watching TV or reading through judgy threads on MN.

Roominmyhouse · 06/12/2020 15:19

I have a table but still eat my dinner sat on the sofa most nights! We have trays with bean bag bottoms so you can still eat properly with a knife and fork which apparently would shock lots of the posters here. Lots of people do this, it doesn’t mean they are incapable of table manners.

Ragwort · 06/12/2020 14:42

Is it 'snobbish' to say you don't like eating on the sofa because it's really uncomfortable - unless it's a very simple meal, a sandwich or slice of pizza for example (or a 'fork supper' - bet Mumsnetters hate that expression Grin) I just find it really awkward to eat on the sofa, do you put your plate on the coffee table and then sit hunched up over it Confused - especially something like the Christmas dinner when you clearly need a knife and fork, and room for you glass of wine etc.

IntermittentParps · 06/12/2020 14:37

I'm not remotely snobbish about it (as I said earlier, we often eat on the sofa watching telly), but eating at a low table gives me backache and indigestion. It's one or the other for me: sitting at a full-height table or slurping and shovelling food out of a bowl in front of Strictly.

userxx · 06/12/2020 14:33

I much prefer a table, I feel quite sick eating hunched up on the sofa and I really don't like the smell of food lingering around. My kitchen is tiny and I dream of a huge kitchen/diner extension.

Swipe left for the next trending thread