Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be angry when a staff. bull dog wanders into my garden with my DS playing

62 replies

daisycat01 · 03/04/2007 16:57

I am quite angry, but also shocked at how unconcerned the owner was. We live about 2 fields away from a farm. My boys were playing in our garden, at the end of the garden is a hedge and behind are fields. I had just finished hanging out the washing and was inside when I noticed a white staffordshire dog wandering in the garden. I got my 1.5yr old and 4 yr old inside and shut the back door as the dog started running up to us. I had no idea where it came from or what it would do if I tried to touch it. I am not a doggy person, I dont mind them but dont know how to deal with them. I went to get my neighbour and when we came back it wandered into the field. I went onto the field to see a lady calling it (the dog just ignored her) I went up to her and asked her if it was her dog, yes she said, I said that it was in my garden and she just said "oh she is always wandering off!" I was really annoyed by that, especially given the breed. I said "can you make sure it doesnt again as it was in my garden with my 2 ds who are very small" she said "oh she wont do any harm, she loves children", How am I suppossed to know that. If I see it again I am reporting it to the police!!! Is that unreasonable??

OP posts:
KathyMCMLXXII · 03/04/2007 19:49

Eh? If a toddler teases a dog it has a right to bite her nose off?

hippipotami · 03/04/2007 19:48

Not that it should matter? Of course it matters, IF a child (or anyone) teases a dog, the dog has a right to defend itself!

But as that was not the case here, it is a moot point.

SofiaAmes · 03/04/2007 19:39

YES, my stepdaughter was supervised. My dh had arrived at at his friend's house, entered the house, saw the dog and said, "is that dog ok with children?" They said yes, and 2 minutes later dsd toddled towards the dog, tripped and the dog leaped and bit her. There was no teasing going on (not that that should matter). It was a small dog. Turns out that they had only had the dog a short while and had gotten it at the pound and really knew nothing about it at all, despite having said that they did.

hippipotami · 03/04/2007 19:23

SofiaAmes - was your stepdaughter being supervised with this dog?? How do you know that she didn't (in a toddlerish inquisative way) poke the dog in the eye and the dog reacted??

As for dogs escaping - they do. By all means call the police, they will laugh at you. Cows escape from fields, horses bolt from stables, cats crap everywhere, and any dog, will occasionally wander away from home. It is the nature of the beast. And no, it is not always possible to tie the dog up/lock it away. Accidents happen!

hippipotami · 03/04/2007 19:19

Don't be too quick to assume you can cuddle a lab or retriever. They are being overbread nowadays and some nasty personality traits (sp) are emerging.

Chances are, if this dog is a farm dog, who is allowed to wander the farm freely (and unfortunately escape) then it is a good-natured dog.
So-called fighting dogs are only aggressive because they are made aggressive by bad owners - ie kept on a chain, beaten, taunted, and used for fighting.
This dog sounds more like a farm dog. Dopey but harmless.

So yes, you are over reacting by calling the police. The owner however, could have been more apologetic. But on the other hand, perhaps she was a bit bemused by your over-reaction, and was too embarrased to apologize.

SofiaAmes · 03/04/2007 18:17

Dogs can be dangerous and you certainly can't tell either by looking at them (or often by asking their owners) whether or not they are dangerous. My eldest stepdaughter had her nose ripped off when she was a toddler by a dog that was small, no particular breed and whom the owners had vouched for as being good with children a few minutes earlier than the attack.
I personally do not think that you shouldn't wait until you see the dog again to report it to the police. Dog owners are responsible for keeping their dogs on a leash at all times when they are in public. They can still take their dog for a walk....just on a leash!!!! I would either write a polite, but firm letter to your neighbors expressing your concern and asking that they keep their dog leashed in public at all times, or at a minimum fence in any space that the dog is going to be unleashed in. I don't think that it matters what breed the dog is. And if they ignore you or are unhelpful in their response, then I would report it to the police.
Wannabe, if your dog bolted out your door and was running around unleashed for 5 minutes it is YOUR FAULT for not making sure that your dog was somewhere tied up before you opened your door. Hardly a difficult task for a human. If I had come across your dog, I would have reported it to the police. And you should have been mortified for being so irresponsible as to have let it out, not just because you got caught.
It isn't daisycat01's responsibility to fence in her yard....it should be the dog owner's responsibility to fence/tie in their dog.

talcyone · 03/04/2007 18:15

This has happened to us before,Daisy,
nearly poohed my pants....but that's because i'm scared of dogs.
I,m desperate not to inflict this fear onto my dd's, so i 'played it down'.
Have never called the police, but i think you have every right to be shaken, esp if you don't know the dog.
I would do as others have suggested and make your property harder to get into, also i would expect the dog owner to offer an apology, esp since it frightened you.

daisycat01 · 03/04/2007 18:05

I generalise that those breed are fighting dog as I dont know an awful lot about them as I have never chosen to have one I am sure that they can be affectionate and that the recent media have given them a bad name. However they can do a lot of damage if they want to, especially to children. I always thought they were bred to fight or for security like rottwielers, or collies for rounding up sheep.
I wouldnt expect a dog to be tied up if I visited it at its home, I am entering its territory. I am not afraid of dogs, just wary of unknown dogs. I wouldnt start stroking a dog unless the owner had said I could. I think that is sensible. If it had been a lab or another similar breed then I may not have been as annoyed.
The lady wasnt walking her dog, she wasnt with her dog. She told me that the dog is allowed to wander the farm and often gets out and wanders off. The dog had wandered 2 fields and along the back of 4 gardens before pushing under our hedge and into our garden. I then went to get the neighbour and returned. When I went out the back the lady was 1 field away. She had not been watching the dog, if they know it has a tendancy to wander then it should be always supervised or kept fenced in. My children could wiggle under the hedge if they put their mind to it, but, I know that they have a tendancy to wander so I watch them. I would have had them under my arm and back in the garden before they had traveled 10 meters let alone a farm, 2 fields and 4 gardens.

OP posts:
SparklyGothKat · 03/04/2007 17:55

at my old house, the fence was not very secure, but my kids couldn't get out. One morning I looked out and saw a strange dog wandering around my garden, I went out and called the dog, who came trotting up to me. He was a beautiful dog, but I didn't know if he was nasty, luckily he wasn't. He had a phone number on his collar so I phoned his owner. He had been missing for days.
It shocked me that a dog could get in, which meant my dog could get out, so I secured the fencing.
I would secure your fencing and ask the farmer to make sure that their dog is kept in a secure place.

KathyMCMLXXII · 03/04/2007 17:52

Where do foxes poo anyway? do you think some of the "dogs" that poo in the street are actually foxes?

DeviousDaffodil · 03/04/2007 17:39

Couldn't agree with you more Daisy!

daisycat01 · 03/04/2007 17:38

yeah, but if your dog got out and it ended up in the garden with young children I am sure you would have appolgised. This lady was quite arrogant. She said that they wander the farm and sometimes wander off. It would have had to been gone a while to get across the fields and then into my garden.

If a fox came into the garden there is nothing really I could do about it as no-one is resposible for it, also, generally they are wary of humans and arent domesticated. Yeah it could poo in the garden but thats part of being in the countryside I suppose. Dogs however, generally, are domesticated, and will happily wander up to people. I dont expect to see a dog sniffing around my garden and my children, especially one that looks quite tough and like it could do harm. You dont read about kids being attacked and killed by labradors, or foxes (apart from that freak fox a while ago!)
My garden has a hedge at the bottom and proper fences to the sides, its rented, so really I would have to get onto the landlord for him to put in a fence. I would only report the dog if it happened again, as I feel that my children should be able to play in the garden without the threat of a dog like that coming in.

OP posts:
KathyMCMLXXII · 03/04/2007 17:35

True about farms, Wannabe.

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 03/04/2007 17:32

Kathy yes of course I would be apologetic, is it possible though that as this dog lives on a farm the owners are more relaxed about it - farms generally aren't that close to other properties, and often the farm dogs wander wherever they want. It's not necessarily right but people with dogs in the country do seem to act differently to those of us who live in more built-up areas.

DeviousDaffodil · 03/04/2007 17:32

I meant to say there is an offence of a dog being out of control in a private place, which covers the scenario of a dog going into someone else'd garden.
Regardless of how good their fencing is.

JolieGirl · 03/04/2007 17:28

This is so hard - it's not about the specific breed of dog per se it is about something that raises every maternal hackle you have and which presents a possible threat to your children - not helped by all the media attention this has received recently. This particular dog may not be on the dangerous dogs act but neither are rottweilers, alsations etc and as a mother I would do my utmost to keep any child away from them. How could any of us live with ourselves if something did happen and we had not taken action. I would consider having a formal conversation/writing a letter to the owner expressing your concerns and then if you get no positive response then perhaps have a chat with the police or get advice from your local council, they all have specialist dog wardens.

Hilllary · 03/04/2007 17:28

No not at all, a strange dog on its own in a your garden, private property with your dc's, you dont know if this dog is dangerous, bites or what, any animal is unpredictable, just because it has never bitten anyone it doesn't mean he wont.

I would expect any dog to be acounted for not to be wandering on its own.

We have a jack russell, he has his own pen in the garden, does not come into childrens garden. I would complain to the farm, you cannot be responsible for an animal if you dont know where it is.

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 03/04/2007 17:27

"it just looked like a "fighting dog"". what a generalization.

I don't like staffies, but I certainly wouldn't be running to the police if one entered my garden, I'd be securing my garden to ensure it didn't get in again. I expect burglers to not break into my house, but that doesn't mean I leave the door open anyway - I take steps to ensure that my house is secure.

tbh I imagine the police will pay no attention - especially if the dog hasn't bitten anyone.

It does sound as if the owner needs to secure her property to ensure the dog can't get out, but in her defence at least she appeared to be out looking for it when it wandered off.

MellowMa · 03/04/2007 17:27

Message withdrawn

lucyellensmum · 03/04/2007 17:26

i am surprised though that living in the country you are nervous about dogs. I have a friend who wouldnt come to my house unless i promised her that my boy was locked away, petrified she was - she would have been the same if it were a chihuahua.

KathyMCMLXXII · 03/04/2007 17:25

But Wannabe, I'm guessing that if your dog got into someone's garden you'd be at least a bit apologetic?
What bothers me about the woman in the OP is not that the thing happened in the first place (like you say, we're all human and he's only a dog) but that she didn't seem to have any sense that she shouldn't be allowing her dog to do this willy nilly.

After all, it's not just whether the dog might attack children, it's also whether it might knock something over, break a plant etc.

DeviousDaffodil · 03/04/2007 17:25

There is an offence of a dog being out of control in a public place/ and a public place.
So she was in the wrong.
It is her responsibilty to stop her dog going into your garden.
Not yours to build a proper fence( like DUH?).
You can report it to Police but if you don't know the owner they won't do much.
You could report it to the local dog warden they were really good when I complained about a neighbours dog that was always wandering in our street/coming into our garden.

lucyellensmum · 03/04/2007 17:23

this is a difficult one, I think that dogs should be under control at all times. No matter what the breed. However, i can imagine in a farm situation the dog wandering off might be less easy to control. I would have been horrified were it me though and i love dogs and have always had rotties, another dog much aligned because it is often owned by idiots. I have to say that staffs are lovely dogs who do tend to love children, its other dogs they have issues with. Saying that, i would have been unhappy were it to wander onto my property - not knowing its nature etc. I do think its the owners responsibility to make sure the dog cannot get out, it may be a lovely cutesy fluffly bum of a dog who just loves children but your children might be terrified or it may wander onto a road and cause and accident.

MellowMa · 03/04/2007 17:23

Message withdrawn

SparklyGothKat · 03/04/2007 17:22

look at my profile, I have a pic of our staffy on there