Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think its wrong that a father had his daughter dressed ONLY in a pair of shorts!!!

40 replies

prawnsmum · 02/04/2007 10:57

when having a walk in the paking with my ds yesterday i spotted a father playing with a ball with his daughter (who was around 3). As I got closer I could see that she was only wearing a pair of shorts!! no vest/t-shirt just shorts! I know the sun is out but it's nowhere near hot enough for that imo. I pointed this out to my dh who said there was probably a good reason- she might have got her top wet or something??? Is it just me or does anyone else find this wrong!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mytwopenceworth · 03/04/2007 10:27

i remember my mum always used to say things like "put a jumper on, i'm cold" and it used to drive me mental because i was warm!

Now there's a girl who is walking to the bus stop along our route to the boys school who always drags her coat along behind her, never wears it, no matter if its blowing a gale or pouring with rain. i always want to stop and tell her to put it on! and i wonder if she left the house like that, or took off the coat around the corner. am i judging the mother for not stapling a coat to her child's shoulders?

so i know it's common to look at folks and think they must be cold/hot because you are, but the kid was probably boiling hot from all the running around.

NotQuiteCockney · 03/04/2007 09:17
prawnsmum · 03/04/2007 09:15

tiredeasterbunny I have plenty going on in my life the only reason i noticed the child is because she stood out in a park of fully dressed kids! I totally understand that children strip off as soon as the sun is out I have neices and nephews and a son of my own so plenty of expeience of this but my point was that it was COLD. we had to scrape ice from our car on sunday, monday and this morning-even though the sun is out!!

OP posts:
chipmonkey · 02/04/2007 23:23

My dsis and her friend stripped naked and ran out into the snow once when my dad was supposed to be looking after them!

charlottegeorgiaolivermums · 02/04/2007 22:49

prawnsmum

Sorry haven't read the whole thread but my dd1 & dd2 keep taking clothes off to play in garden. Don't have a clue why end up with dd1 just in pants and socks and dd2 just in her socks and nappy. They look a right picture jumping up and down on trampoline but when I argue they say their too hot so I leave them until they want to get re-dressed.

lisad123 · 02/04/2007 22:32

Sorry but maybe she had a temp but was well enough to play out. If she seemed fine she properly was. My DH always struggles to know what to put on DD.
I would worry about your own kids and stop worrying about others that are ok.
L

Tiredeasterbunny · 02/04/2007 22:18

Oh FFS, do you really have so little going on in your life that you notice and judge someone because the child in their care only had a pair of shorts on?! Was the child being beaten? Was she crying? Was she blue with cold and begging for clothes? Why as parents do we spend so much time bitching about the way other people live their lives and look after their children?!!

Harryjake · 02/04/2007 21:52

My ds refuses point blank to have the raincover on his pushchair even in a torrential downpour and people give me looks like I'm a terrible mum for letting him get wet. She probably wanted her t-shirt off because she was hot. Children do seem to be hotter than adults at that age.

giraffeski · 02/04/2007 20:04

Message withdrawn

prawnsmum · 02/04/2007 15:58

lol frumpygrumpy

OP posts:
prawnsmum · 02/04/2007 15:57

leiselventouse think you have my point it's only April not the middle of July-its still cold even though the sun's out!!

OP posts:
frumpygrumpy · 02/04/2007 15:55

maybe he was letting her experience the word consequence, its an important lesson and they're never too young

prawnsmum · 02/04/2007 15:51

nothing to do with it being the father!!!! That was the only person with the girl might have been uncle or friend whatever my point was how cold it was not the gender of the person who was with her. as i've said my point was the weather i know kids have minds of their own- my son refuses to wear socks!! but imo yesterday was too cold for a child of around 3 to ONLY be wearing a pair of shorts and nothing else.

OP posts:
twobabies · 02/04/2007 13:55

I think its fine, she would have said if she was cold and you didn't mention her looking upset at all. I took my dd out yesterday in a tennis dress, poncho, socks and shoes and had a lady actually come up to me and say "gosh look at her bare legs, she must be freezing you should have wrapped her up more!!" I then spent the rest of the day paranoid that everyone was thinking I hadn't clothed her properly...

So I'm glad to hear about all these other lo's playing in pools and running round with no clothes on!!

LieselVentouse · 02/04/2007 13:48

I was actually going to start a thread on this cause when I was out for lunch there I saw a woman in M&S wearing a strapless sun dress and flip flops

scatterbrain · 02/04/2007 12:28

I agree YABU - it might have been UNWISE given that it wan't very warm - but no definitely not WRONG - that implies something else entirely !

mateychops · 02/04/2007 12:26

prawnsmum, my kids were running around in their swimming cossies, and that's in Scotland too. It was a lovely day, I was in a t-shirt, so don't want to offend but don't see what the issue is???

bloss · 02/04/2007 12:26

Message withdrawn

ernest · 02/04/2007 11:59

why does the title say That at FATHER had hid daughter only in a apir of shorts? Do you really see the gender of the parent as being an issue?

You really seem to be suggesting something there?

TBH I don't see a 3 year old running around playing without a t shirt as being anything noteworthy at all.

Wags · 02/04/2007 11:48

In theory...... but wish someone would tell my DD that. She if almost 4, if she is hot then layers come off never mind what the weather is like. She is happy, I think its funny!

prawnsmum · 02/04/2007 11:39

agree wags but you can sitll run around no problem with a top on!

OP posts:
Wags · 02/04/2007 11:35

My DD would wear as little as possible and as she is nearly 4 I pretty much let her get on with it. She is a hot body like me, I can picture her a while back in the park, no coat with her friend who also insisted no coat, swear the pair of them were going slightly blue round the lips but they said they were both hot!! Tend not to worry about it really, so if the little girl looked OK then fine. Certainly nothing wrong about it, never have been one to wrap up a child of that age - they can tell you how they feel. I would rather see a kid like that having fun than one all wrapped up hardly moving!

prufrock · 02/04/2007 11:34

Well I had 4 naked children running in and out of the water jets in my garden yesterday and they all refused to get dressed or even take advantage of the warmed towels I had ready for them - I do think that it is rare that a semi naked toddler hasn't insisted on being that way themsleves

thePA · 02/04/2007 11:33

my ds is only 3.5 and he drives me bonkers when we go out, he just doesn't feel the cold. I can be in the house wearing a jumper and he's prancing round with no clothes on then thinks nothing of stripping as many layers as possible off while we're out shopping.
i'm sure people look at me and think exactly what you were yesterday!

prawnsmum · 02/04/2007 11:32

can i just add that i live in Scotland so even though the sun was out yesterday it was still about -3!!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread