Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

correct names and MILs

108 replies

lucyellensmum · 29/03/2007 15:30

I get very very angry btw when mother in law sends cards to dd with her dads surname, not married see. I woudlnt mind if she was doing it by mistake but is making a point - my point being if he wants his dd to have his name then he should bloody well marry her mother! So there's a can of worms, i should point out that my MIL is lovely though and i love her but you know how it is with us mums and our MIL, just let anyone q our parenting, go on just you try it! Oh god, do i go on too much. But what do you all think, should a child bear its fathers name, and where did that come from. I have a child from a previous relationship though and wanted both children to have same surname, have been with DP for 15 years and no intention on getting married - grrr.

OP posts:
BellaBear · 31/03/2007 12:39

I didn't change my name when I married as everything I've ever done I did with my name - I like having it on my exam certificates! When we have kids they can have his name, it is nicer than mine, he cares more about it and if we double-barreled it with make a rude word!

And surprisingly, the only post we have had addressed to Mr & Mrs Hisfirstname his last name has been from one of my friends, very odd.

mytwopenceworth · 31/03/2007 12:26

erm , that's 'XXX' in place of surname, obviously. I'm not Mrs XXX porn queen.

mytwopenceworth · 31/03/2007 12:25

i couldn't wait to ditch my surname. i love being Mrs XXX!

ginnedupmummy · 31/03/2007 12:15

Message withdrawn

thelady · 31/03/2007 12:02

Hmm. Well, I'm Dr myname, and it's taken nearly 10 years for my SIL to stop writing cheques to me as Mrs hisname.

My parents are the worst though! The only time I get really grumpy is if I'm addressed as Mrs Hisfirstname Hislastname - makes me feel totally invisible. Mrs Hislastname is just family being old-fashioned, though it's been the tradition in Scotland forever for women to stay with the name they were born to.

Elasticwoman · 30/03/2007 21:29

Lucyellensmum, why didn't you insist upon marriage before having a baby, if you are keen to be married? You have lost rather an important bargaining chip. 1950s cliches spring to mind re buying v borrowing books from libraries.

marylou23 · 30/03/2007 12:38

My DH regularly gets called 'Mr My surname' when we stay in hotels as I tend to book (and kept my own name). He just shrugs and accepts it...
He was actually keen for me to keep my own name - he said it was who I was, who he fell in love with. Very sweet. Although since getting pregnant I've partly changed my name (on NHS records) because I think baby will have DH's name (not from any patriachal reason, but more for praticality. You couldn't put our names together, they're too long, and if we're going to 'pick a side', I'm happy to go with his). So for school, hospital, etc I'll be 'Mrs DH's name' and the rest of hte time I'm Ms My name.
Am I rambling now? I do apologise...

idlemum · 30/03/2007 09:12

ProfYaffle - I do that too - I love to hear them get all confused and if they don't start to finish the call I say something like ''you are obviously a sexist cold-caller - goodbye'' !

ProfYaffle · 30/03/2007 07:25

I agree with idlemum as well. The name thing is useful with cold callers though, when they say 'Mrs X?' I can truthfully say 'There's no-one of that name here' and we never hear from them again!

teabags · 30/03/2007 01:21

I kept my name when we got married and most people would address post to me in my maiden name. But now we have children everyone has started calling me Mrs X, which I find a bit strange (other than MIL who knows better!)

chipmonkey · 30/03/2007 01:04

Agree with idlemum!

squeakybub · 29/03/2007 20:22

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Aquababe · 29/03/2007 20:12

we double barrelled ours surname but Dh's Aunt point blank refuses to acknowledge when she sends gifts (money) she insists on sending it to my husbands 'maiden' name. After dd was born and she does it with both their names despite very clear evidence to the contrary. So I wrote her letters on the subject and she still persists.
I now always spell her name wrong. Childish but if you can't beat them join them
His friends do it to be naughty as well.

idlemum · 29/03/2007 19:58

Sorry slight hijack - but I am truly fed up that in this day and age there is still the idea that women need to be designated a title according to their marital status but men can be 'Mr' regardless. I use 'Ms' whenever I can (but some forms still don't have this option) as it is no-one's damn business whether I am married or not.

ScottishMummy · 29/03/2007 16:59

Agree with ProfYaffle - my boyfriend contributes such a lot to baby he is a great father and fabby boyfriend...not just a surname

ScottishMummy · 29/03/2007 16:58

at uni i worked in a shop and had to phone a customer ket them know her order had arrived, so not knowing her status i asked for Ms Customer...Well she had a complete berky on the phone squawking at me I am married i am a MRS demanding an apology

i was mortified..she was shoting so loud it made my ears vibrate

i also find it funny women who wish to be addressed as Mrs John Bloggs - imo Odd

ProfYaffle · 29/03/2007 16:56

"all dp can give them is his name " blimey, I'll tell dh he's contributed nothing to our dc's then

Lovecat · 29/03/2007 16:54

lol min192 My own mum does that to me!!

My mate got married recently and was at great pains to let everyone know she would be taking her dp's surname (has always hated her own surname and doesn't get on with her family so was keen to disassociate).

For a wind up I addressed a card to her as Mrs 'DP's name' 'Dp's Surname' - she rang me up and said she really loved it...

ScottishMummy · 29/03/2007 16:51

i thought (good) fathers added love, stability, nurturing, compassion i think (good) dads do all we do except the obviouslybreastfeeding

so i think the name given does not necesarily need to be his

again its personal preference, whatever suits really

PinkTulips · 29/03/2007 16:47

because it's something that the dad can give them that will form a massive part of their identity.

we give birth to them, nurse them, make most of the day to day decisions and usually take the child if there's a split.... all dp can give them is his name

ScottishMummy · 29/03/2007 16:45

PinkTulips - why the father's name in preference to mums name, just wondering??

PinkTulips · 29/03/2007 16:43

i'm unmarried and both dc's have rtheir dad's surname... we plan on marrying so would be confusing for kids to have to change and i'm old fashioned anyway... think kids should have fathers' surnames anyway

ProfYaffle · 29/03/2007 16:41

I kept my name when i got married and the dc's have my surname (dh's decision) Pil have been really odd about it, sending mail addressed to the dc's first name only (ie, no surname at all). They have repeatedly claimed they didn't know what we'd done with the names, despite us explaining several times. fil said to us 'do I don't have any say on this at all then?' us: 'er, no'. We've more or less resolved it by dh having a word with them on his own. They still don't like it but at least they don't say anything any more.

ScottishMummy · 29/03/2007 16:41

chipmonkey *Sinking-maybe-Bloody-good-laugh-Definitely

sometimes it is kinda satisfying to stir it up a bit

chipmonkey · 29/03/2007 16:35

ScottishMummy, I think I may do that. I thought of it before but Dh said not to sink to her level! Sometimes a bit of sinking does you good though!