Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask what's the beef with benefits?

638 replies

mytartanscarf · 04/01/2015 14:33

Do people think they are too little? That they should be more?

There's always a lot of upset on here about them - about how wrong the government are and how awful life is on benefits. I've never been on benefits so obviously can't judge. But what are the solutions?

I suppose I am asking what should the government do?

OP posts:
LeftyLoony · 04/01/2015 22:42

Still no plans to means test DLA or PIP, though.
Obviously you forget those who claim DLA/PIP and work.

Jealousy is a very ugly thing.

SoonToBeSix · 04/01/2015 22:42

Wherethere it's not a FREE CAR!!!!

Wheretheresawill1 · 04/01/2015 22:41

Oh and left looney I bet you can fit 2 wheelchairs in a z4

LeftyLoony · 04/01/2015 22:40

Completely agree, Ashes. Communal Garden of ours had broken glass in too so was unusable.

I had the 'covering shit brown' issue too. Takes some doing!

Wheretheresawill1 · 04/01/2015 22:40

Left looney. All I can say is I'm glad it's changing. And it will continue to change. When my neighbour(the arthritic one who wanted cash in hand for cleaning my house) moaned about bedroom tax I felt ZERO sympathy. Bring on the changes.

lavendersgreen · 04/01/2015 22:40

Donna, I still don't understand why you asked which specific points (of D&H) I agree with...let's say all of them for ease if that helps.

LeftyLoony · 04/01/2015 22:39

So you'd know that the lease on that was the same as the lease on your fiesta, then?

The down payment would be far bigger but as DLA isn't means tested then that shouldn't be an issue. You'd not get the grant for a z4,there's very specific qualifying criteria.

So what exactly is the problem?

AshesOfRoses · 04/01/2015 22:37

LeftyLooney the 1-bed flat I moved into with my toddler DD had bare tiles all over the floor, no white goods, the remains of the torn-out bathroom / woodwork / nails thrown into the front (only) garden for which I got threatening letters from the council.

The flat was painted in gloss in dark bottle green and shit brown all over. It took years to get into order but then it was years before DD and I were able to move. She had to have her "starting school" interview with her future HT sitting on the lower bunk of her bed which was in the sitting room.

I had been a colleague of this lady a few years before. It was a bit humiliating.

Wheretheresawill1 · 04/01/2015 22:37

Left loony it wasn't I was denied. It was more that I wanted the self respect of working. I think I'm right to question it when I see people blatantly ripping off the system aka sitting on their arse. I may as well hand my tax over each month

handcream · 04/01/2015 22:36

Sorry, I thought I had made it clear, I didn't come from a well off household at all, Mum worked but we didn't have much money because my father paid the minimum he could get away with, it was the time when men were the head of the household and filled in the tax returns on behalf of their wives. Shocking now to think this was the norm!

I didn't want any of this for myself, I think that we are losing sight of personal responsibility tbh. I drum it in to both my DS's - if you make that decision just think through the ins and outs. Take the consequences good or bad and learn from it and move on.

Wheretheresawill1 · 04/01/2015 22:36

Actually my fiesta was also on notability. Sometimes the truth is unpalatable. The z4 was my wake up call.,I'm telling the truth - I realise there are plenty who will not like this

LeftyLoony · 04/01/2015 22:35

Oh and Where - the system failed you therefore it's too easy? There's some magic formula?

Nope. MH is known to be one of the hardest areas to get help. It's wrong but don't think others shouldn't get something you've been wrongly denied.

Too many genuine cases get denied.

Dawndonnaagain · 04/01/2015 22:33

Wheretheres.
No free cars. It's taken off the DLA.
Other than that what is the breakdown you have provided, sorry I don't understand it.

LeftyLoony · 04/01/2015 22:32

Well my milkman's great aunt's gardener's illegitimate frog's next door neighbour's stoat has a gulfstream, a Bugatti veyron and Hors to Australia every month on benefits. So nyer.

Oh and shite like the stuff about z4s on Motability have made my family's situation really difficult, so thanks.

More expensive cars always attracted a higher down payment before the lease started. Prestige vehicles come into that category but so do most people carriers. Because of the Daily Mail campaign no vehicle with a down payment of more than£2k can be leased.

Which means Galaxy/Sharan etc are out. I'd like to see any of you put 2 wheelchairs in the boot of a Fiesta. I tried. You can't.

whitesandstorm · 04/01/2015 22:30

handcream surely when you pay in national insurance throughout your working life you're entitled to rely on the state to look after you should you need it. Isn't that what the money's for?

AshesOfRoses · 04/01/2015 22:29

copy and paste is a terrible double-edged sword Blush

I didn't mean to post all that, but a ranting "bingo" system with points awarded for "smoker" "plasma" "pets" etc might be worth it.

Eltonjohnsflorist · 04/01/2015 22:28

Neither council nor HA supply white goods in social housing. Hell, they don't even supply flooring

Dawndonnaagain · 04/01/2015 22:26

Lavender, I asked because you gave the impression that you wished to join the discussion.

Magrettes bloody nonsense, even those on benefits have to provide their own white goods, unless of course the person concerned was in furnished accommodation.

Hand cream. I am lucky, I have no mortgage, but many, many years ago I made what I thought was the right choice and had an endowment mortgage. Fortunately I am in a position in which I have had easy access to a good education and am therefore able to interpret what newspapers etc, are saying. I changed my mortgage. It was down to luck, luck that I had a father who was intelligent and could see the advantage of educating his children, luck that I inherited his genes and therefore an enquiring mind able to interpret facts etc. Opportunity, free education etc. All these things add up to make our ability to make choices apt or otherwise. Sometimes bad choices are bad luck, sometimes they are bad decisions, but those making the bad decisions do not always have the ability to see how to make better decisions. There are also those who are coerced, have ended up on benefits via refuge and the like, where benefits are literally a safety net. Perhaps a little more thought around the subject before judging those less fortunate would be kind.

LeftyLoony · 04/01/2015 22:25

Anyone else heard of council/HA supplying White goods? Damn sure I haven't, and all 3 of the places I've had were empty of EVERYTHING including floor coverings and in one toilet seats and light fittings were absent. Not shades, actual fittings.

ghostspirit · 04/01/2015 22:23

ashes i spell shit and i dont even know how to use grammar

Wheretheresawill1 · 04/01/2015 22:21

And before anybody has a go about disability I have had bipolar disorder for 20yrs. I work full time plus extra just to survive. I either don't know the system as well as my arthritic neighbour or I have more self worth. Either way I'm not sure it's helping me.

AshesOfRoses · 04/01/2015 22:20

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Wheretheresawill1 · 04/01/2015 22:18

I think generally the public are in denial or are just unaware of what's happening. My fathers z4 BMW convertible was an ex motability
car. Wake up people

ghostspirit · 04/01/2015 22:16

maybe she gets help from else where family or something? hard to beleive someone with 3 kids on benefits could afford all of that.

im nto sure its fair to shout get a bloody job if you dont work yourself

Wheretheresawill1 · 04/01/2015 22:16

Oh and the dentist