Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give bj to dh when I don't feel like sex?

162 replies

bushymcbush · 30/06/2012 22:11

Let me make it clear now, my DH doesn't expect or even ask me to do this. I am asking this because I have noticed on a couple of relationships threads that some women 'service' their DPs in this way when they don't want sex themselves.

I have a real problem with this concept. Oral sex is as much a sex act as intercourse is to me. If I perform oral on my DH, it is part of a mutually satisfying experience - I do it to him because I am horny and it gives me pleasure to give him pleasure, iyswim. And I will get my just desserts too Wink

The idea of all these women giving cold bj's to their partners, not for their mutual enjoyment but just to stop him pestering them, fills me with horror tbh.

Is it just me?

OP posts:
yellowraincoat · 03/07/2012 00:04

Krumbum, if you don't want to answer my q, that's fine but I'm genuinely interested because I don't really know what people mean by degrading.

If a woman swallows semen, not because she's pressured but because she wants to AND she doesn't feel degraded by it, is it still degrading?

For me, it's can be quite an intimate thing to do.

Obviously it CAN be degrading. Not disputing that at all. But most everything is degrading if you're pressured into it.

CogPsych · 02/07/2012 23:59

Krumbum...

Sure, that's how you feel. But you're not a man are you?

Don't try to link a discussion on the physical sensation with women being sexual toys for men, i don't think women are sexual toys either and my position does not imply that. It is clear that you have some issues with men, it is easy to see why you are so negative about this issue.

Jiggleballs123 · 02/07/2012 22:37

Totally agree Local

bushymcbush · 02/07/2012 22:23

X post local

OP posts:
bushymcbush · 02/07/2012 22:22

Nelly I think what local means is that some men might think that sex is all about their own pleasure and not have much consideriation for their partner's needs when they are having sex. This sense of entitlement could be reinforced by their partners giving bj's when they're not in the mood.

As for my not wanting a discussion - of course I did - although of course I also wanted to express an opinion. My opinion has not been changed by anything anyone has posted on this thread. Does that mean I wasn't open to discussion?

Look if you genuinely enjoy giving a bj when you are not turned on, then fine. All power to you. I find it hard to imagine but I will take your word for it, and reserve my discomfort for those women who do it to keep their man happy.

OP posts:
localcrackpot · 02/07/2012 22:17

Nelly, I think you've extrapolated what I've said into something completely different. If you want to do anything for your partner (not necessarily because you're ready for sex, but perhaps because you like him!) then you want to do it. Totally different to men who try to push themselves on their wives in the circumstances of marriage breakdown, for example. I know of this happening to women and them thinking it'd be easier to get it over than fight him off.

No word missing. "Think of you" in this context means "consider your needs". If you think it's easier to just let him get on with it and look away when you are totally not in the mood, it dehumanises you and, should you be happily in bed together at another point, that dehumanisation means there's no reason why your needs or desires should be considered.

It's hard to explain this without giving extreme examples. I think if a generally happy couple has a number of instances where the man gets to have sex without the woman's active interest and participation, the relationship is on a steep decline.

Krumbum · 02/07/2012 22:02

What literally as your coming? No, I think the feeling of orgasm takes over. I've had an orgasm and the stimulation becomes irrelevant because your body just starts to do it.
I don't think women are just sexual toys for men.

CogPsych · 02/07/2012 21:49

I can easily imagine how a tongue and lips feels better than fingers though, can't you? They just have a different texture. Plus the mouth is warm and wet. Likewise i'm sure for a better it feels physically better to climax during penetration than it does by masterbation.

Why do you doubt men so much?

(No doubt there is a psychological component to various sex acts too, but different sex acts do have different sensations).

Krumbum · 02/07/2012 20:40

Cogpsych, I dispute that it feels better physically, I think it is mental thing. If your still masterbating them then the stimulation doesn't stop.
To end a relationship over something so tiny would mean you have no real interest in that relationship anyway.
Some women squirt, it's not expected that men take this fluid in their mouths and swallow it. I think the expectation that women must love jizz all over them is from porn and the intent is to degrade even if that isn't how the woman takes it.

SandyBottoms · 02/07/2012 20:11

I remember my friend used to call the week of her period 'bj week' made me Angry to think she should be getting some tlc instead of servicing her fella.

Jiggleballs123 · 02/07/2012 19:54

YANBU

I love giving blowjobs but only when I'm in the mood, which isn't that often, when I'm not in the mood it hurts my jaw. Probably in the same way that having sex would hurt my fanny if I was not in the mood.

I am too old to 'fake it' or give sexual favours.

Clawdy · 02/07/2012 19:23

Someone leaves you because you won't give 'em a blowjob?? the words "Good " and "Riddance" spring to mind CogSych ........

CogPsych · 02/07/2012 18:40

Lots of men think it feels better (physically) to climax whilst still inside the mouth, i don't think many of them would say that all orgasms are equal. I've heard men complain that their other halves have started to stop the BJ just as they climax and say it's lessened the experience for them.

Every woman has the right to do what they want to do sexually, but every man has a right to leave you for someone who will do it, too. There's give and take. I'm sure many of us would have ended a relationship if it didn't meet our sexual needs, and if the relationship is important to you then sometimes compromise is necessary.

NellyBluth · 02/07/2012 16:59

OP, were you ever actually interested in a discussion? No problems if not, just a little confused as to why you posted in a discussion thread.

Sexual vending machine and negative reinforcement are pretty strong terms to use. So all of the posters on here who have said that they give their DPs bjs, without having sex, as part of their general sex life are nothing more than vending machines? Are we all automatically in sexually abusive relationships, merrily ignoring the red flags or something?

local, I'm not sure I understand your last sentence - is there a word missing, or are you saying that giving your DP bjs means he is not going to be thinking/fantasising about you when you are in bed together?

Clawdy · 02/07/2012 16:59

I read that most women don't particularly like giving head. My aunt who was an ardent sixties women's libber said she can't believe after so many years of feminism,girls are now expected to do things men used to have to pay for!

bushymcbush · 02/07/2012 16:17

Good point local. sexual vending machine -

OP posts:
localcrackpot · 02/07/2012 03:46

I can't help thinking that going along with such a demand from a H when you're not in the mood would be negative reinforcement in a way - he doesn't have to get you in the mood, you're just a marriage-bought sexual vending machine. He wouldn't be more inclined to think of you when you're in bed together another time.

Serendipity30 · 01/07/2012 16:29

I told my P that when he is willing to do the same for me I will gladly return the favor, that shut him up

Birdsgottafly · 01/07/2012 15:55

"How many here have a guy who will happily give them a hand/lickjob and then just go to sleep, no getting an orgasm himself"

I don't like oral sex, but he will accomodate me, in other ways, usually when we've had a night out and he has had to much to drink.

The situation hasn't ever occured without drink, except for after sex when i still want to carry on having orgasms, i demand a least a few.

NellyBluth · 01/07/2012 15:46

Rightbugger - I can and do take DP up on an offer like that!

Apologies if I read your post wrong, that was just an impression I was left with. What I was trying to get at was that just because you and your OH are not comfortable with this scenario doesn't mean that it is completely degrading for anyone who does. As you say, "it's never nice or ok to involve someone in sex unless they feel like being involved" - but lots of women 'feel like being involved' via giving their OH some form of sexual pleasure even when they don't want to receive similar pleasure themselves at that particular moment in time.

I'm with yellow: what is and isn't "degrading" for an individual varies completely for each couple.

Angelico · 01/07/2012 15:38

OP of course YANBU declining to perform any kind of sex act if you don't feel like it. But it does shock me that I know women who 'have to' do this. One in particular is married to a total cock who used to insist that he got a BJ if she wanted to go out with the girls for the night :( To me it was totally abusive but she (intelligent, educated, professional) never seemed to see it that way Confused

Krumbum I do think it's an interesting point you raise about changing expectations because of a generation of guys with porn on tap. I'm mid-thirties but for a teen guy to get porn he still had to buy it from the top shelf when I was at school. Read a very interesting news article a while back about clinical psychologists seeing more and more young guys (early twenties) who are having real problems with relationships and sex because they are too familiar with porn images and have no concept of what 'real' women and 'real' sex are like. They expect every woman to have pneumatic, baseball shaped bosoms, no pubes and streams of 'cum' trickling down them Confused It would be funny if it wasn't so sad - it was destroying their ability to have real relationships. A lot of them found they only got aroused by porn.

RubyFakeNails · 01/07/2012 15:31

Cardgames my dh does this.

DamselInTornDress · 01/07/2012 15:31

Cards, my man does. He calls it edging himself.

And that's enough discussion about my sex life from me for one day. I'm off to cook a roast for my gang.

CardgamesFTW · 01/07/2012 15:27

How many here have a guy who will happily give them a hand/lickjob and then just go to sleep, no getting an orgasm himself?

Empusa · 01/07/2012 15:26

Damsel I'm sure that's on the list of things never to google Grin