Advanced search

to think the idea of a mansion tax just penalises London and the south

(586 Posts)
Redpipe Sun 15-Sep-13 14:35:44

I will probably get flamed for saying this but I don't believe that owning a 2 million pound house automatically makes you rich. Certainly in London a 2 million will not buy you a mansion, more like a terraced family home.

AIBU to think that the idea just penalises people in the south?

HalooJones Sun 15-Sep-13 15:13:10

An OAP wouldn't have to move out anyway, they could just sign some kind of contingency agreement to give someone a % of their house when they die.

Alisvolatpropiis Sun 15-Sep-13 15:14:02

Most taxes unfairly penalise someone in one way or another.

If the wealth is in London/the south in general that's just the way it goes.

As far as I know, there are plenty of expensive homes up North.

Agree there are 2mil terraces in London, granted they're not exactly tiny. Saw one I liked for sale when visiting a whole back, checked it on right move and nearly choked. Identical houses go for 500k in Cardiff (and that's still too much!)

Redpipe Sun 15-Sep-13 15:14:37


So you do think the elderley neighbour should have to move?

BTW it's unlikely a nearby area will be much different in price either.

RedJeans Sun 15-Sep-13 15:14:40

nearly £15,000,000 for this shock

ihearsounds Sun 15-Sep-13 15:14:59

Just for Stubborn

Sorry not all houses. The last one is a flat. And yes there's even 2 bed flats for 2 mill

Binkybix Sun 15-Sep-13 15:15:13

Part of the property the deceased person owned will go straight to the inland revenue

I think the point is that the person who dies is not paying the tax - the person who inherited (not earned) a huge amount of money through luck - gentrification of an area - is paying it.

InMySpareTime Sun 15-Sep-13 15:15:26

I live in a nice area in NW England, you could get half a dozen houses for £2M round this way.
Who keeps buying these ludicrously expensive houses? Surely to keep prices rising it must be a seller's market.

Redpipe Sun 15-Sep-13 15:15:38


Yes sign away their asset to the tax man.

Redpipe Sun 15-Sep-13 15:17:22


I understand that but my point is the inland revenue will benefit from the increased value of the home anyhow.

HalooJones Sun 15-Sep-13 15:17:57

Redpipe. Not the tax man. A private investor that would get a % of the value of the house when it is sold after the owners death.

Nancy66 Sun 15-Sep-13 15:18:06

former council house - now worth nearly £2million

Redpipe Sun 15-Sep-13 15:18:15

Thank you for the links Ihearsounds smile

HalooJones Sun 15-Sep-13 15:19:04

InMySpareTime: Russian Oligarchs and Saudi Oil sheikhs are buying the property. Not British people. London has become a playground for the worlds rich.

TheCrackFox Sun 15-Sep-13 15:20:45

How much are the Lib Dems hoping to raise from this? How much will it cost to administer?

Redpipe Sun 15-Sep-13 15:20:53

Thanks for the link.

InMySpareTime Sun 15-Sep-13 15:21:17

Your neighbour could rent out a room in his 3-bedroom house if he's that hard up.
What's the point in living in an extremely valuable house as a pauper?
Personally, I think your neighbour would have a much better standard of life if he moved.
I'm not saying he "has" to move, but how does his situation benefit him, even now, without the tax?

ihearsounds Sun 15-Sep-13 15:21:46

Oh and here are a couple of one beds.

Havea0 Sun 15-Sep-13 15:23:22

Redpipe. The 2 million pound house you are talking baout. Is there a mortgage on it?

Redpipe Sun 15-Sep-13 15:23:36


I'd like to know the same answer

mrsjay Sun 15-Sep-13 15:23:40

IF you can afford to repay a mortgage on a 2 million pound house then pay the bloody tax or sell it and move somewhere within your means,

mrsjay Sun 15-Sep-13 15:24:40

I mean the General you

LittleWhiteWolf Sun 15-Sep-13 15:24:44

I think the issue is less with taxes and more with the ridiculous way property prices can fluctuate; I live over an hour outside of London yet cannot afford to buy here because of high property prices. So using your words another way, that penalises those of us north of the M25.

Maybe instead of there being an "us" and "them" argument as to who's worse off or who suffers more or is more penalised, there should be more of a focus on hour the nation can exist all together so that there are no more extremes of wealth and poverty?

Binkybix Sun 15-Sep-13 15:27:21


I see, sorry - misunderstood you. I don't think I agree with mansion tax as long as inheritance tax is a hell of a lot harder to avoid.

Nancy66 Sun 15-Sep-13 15:27:44

But Mrs Jay the owner of a house worth £2million may well have bought it when it was worth £300k

Redpipe Sun 15-Sep-13 15:28:26


He's not a pauper FFS he's just a normal guy on a pension who is just fine. He benefits from living here because he was born and bred here as were his parents, he knows many neighbours. Just because he could free up cash if he moved away doesn't mean that would work for him. However, he could not pay the £20 grand a year in tax! It'd be more than his total pension.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now