- Which activities or products (if any) have you come across which are designed to boost your child's learning? And how effective (or otherwise) have you found them?
The Promethean Trust's Dancing Bears book and flashcards package really helped DSD with reading (age 6-7). We haven't even used it that consistently, and my DH prefers to do the flash cards his own way rather than the book's way, but despite that, this package really helped DSD to get back on track with reading and better understand phonetic rules. It worked far better for her than the Jolly Phonics sign language she did for a year in P1 - DSD had fun making the motions in class, but never made the connection between the sounds and the letter symbols.
DSD's mum and her DP have also done things with DSD. They've mentioned using grapes to help DSD get the hang of addition, and have had her find random words in her school books. I'm sure that has also helped (e.g. finding the word was a method DSD's teachers started to use in class).
- Have you tried anything yourself to improve or enhance your child's learning? If so, what have you tried? And what influenced your decision to try that activity/product? How effective (or otherwise) do you think it has been?
See above. Dancing Bears was purchased and used after mrz and a few others on the Primary Ed board recommended it. We also purchased several stages of ORT's Floppy's Phonics books, again based on recommendation here. When PBS America broadcast "Between the Lions", we recorded all of the episodes available and let DSD watch them. We rented Sesame Street DVDs. We bought a LeapPad and stocked it up with educational games. We've let her play educational computer games online. We've bought board games.
We've also done "for free" activities like reading to her every night, and counting out loud in the car in the morning, by ones, twos, and fives. We've done counting backwards. DSD's grandma has done simple sums with her using pennies. Last night, DSD wanted to try chimney sums, so DH did some with her using paper and different colored markers - I ended up drawing an actual chimney with a Santa in it, so she could get the hang of which way to add the numbers (she started by adding them side-to-side ... woops).
Hopefully, all of the above has helped a little. Dancing Bears has probably had the most obvious effect. "Between the Lions" got her excited about reading again, after her confidence was knocked in P1 and P2.
Reading and numbers not sinking in right away, and an intense fear that DSD will be left to flounder as the class dummy, and then eventually be told in secondary school that she's "not capable of work at a higher level" (so, no Highers, no chance to go to uni, etc), is the motivation for a lot of this, TBH. Neither DH nor I remember learning how to read, nor do we remember struggling with it, so watching DSD struggle is frustrating, because we don't know how best to help and are just guessing most of the time. Our moms, who had different lifestyles compared to our own 25-30 years ago, taught us reading, counting and basic addition before we entered primary school, so we started primary school prepared. Neither DH nor I started primary school until age 5, either.
- What aspect of your child's school experience (if any) do you think could most be improved by neuroscience? You might want to consider, for example, how the teacher talks to the children, the activities the children take part in, or the materials they study...
I have a hunch that if DSD had been made to start primary school later, and had not been allowed to spend 6 months in P1 before turning 5, that she may have struggled less with taking in the basics of reading and math and therefore struggle less today. She seemed much more able to retain information in P2, when she was 5.5 years old. But because she retained very little of what she learned in P1, she had to repeat a lot of that material all over again. While DSD is improving every day, she's still consistently about 6 months behind her peers when it comes to reading, math, etc.
I don't know how it would help DSD specificially, but it would be interesting to see if my hunch is at all right. I have seen a lot of reports stating that the youngest in the class tend to get the worst high school exam results. But is there any proof out there that there is a difference in how much information a child can retain at age 4 vs age 5, or age 5 vs age 6? If there is a difference, how big is that difference between each age group? Can it set them up for a lifetime of being behind their peers in the curriculum? I think if can be proven that the abilities of your average 4 year old are vastly different compared to your average 5 year-old, and can be proven that this does continue to affect them, maybe that might raise a lot of questions about our approach to early primary. E.g. - is a 12-month cohort (March-Feb birthdays, or September-August birthdays) really the best way to set up a P1/R classroom?