My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

School not re opening

313 replies

Onone · 27/05/2020 15:06

Just that really,just had an email from my daughter’s school to say that they won’t be opening on 1st June, don’t know when it will either,Thanks to the mayor of our town,I’m quite upset for my daughter,Hardly any cases in my town

OP posts:
Report
1forsorrow · 28/05/2020 22:35

I do know of a nurse who is not working in her hospital because her DD is shielded. I think that is right and proper. She is doing consultations online from home. I know one in the same position except she has a son.

Report
jackie2669 · 28/05/2020 23:19

Unfair to say if your child doesn't go back there is not enough teachers to do online but siblings in same school who aren't going back can still get on line .then the prospect of why do I have to go when they get to stay at home dilemma .

Report
TequilaMakesHerClothesFallOff · 28/05/2020 23:35

Our school sent out a letter last week asking parents of children in the specified year groups whether they wanted a place at school in June.
Across the board, less than 25% replied with a yes.
They have since decided not to open the nursery class as they don’t feel that 3 yr olds can effectively social distance and they anticipate some emotional distress as the classrooms are bare and unwelcoming, not at all a familiar sight for the children.
Due to classroom sizes (100yr old building) they will only be able to accommodate 6-8 children per classroom once distancing is taken into account. Pre March there were no ‘spare’ unused classrooms in the building.
Less than 25% expressed interest in attending from June 1st, and even with that low response they have stated that once key worker children are also factored in not everybody that has said ‘yes’ will actually be able to attend due to lack of both space and staff.

Report
user1468867871 · 28/05/2020 23:37

There are thousands of supply teachers who would be keen to work now!

Report
UndertheCedartree · 28/05/2020 23:56

Our principal has kept us very well informed. A survey was undertaken and it showed a 3rd of peoole would not send their DC in and a third would. The other third would need to have more information to decide. Currently plans are that the school will reopen to YR on 8th June. They will then review and risk assess before making any decisions on Y1. Y6 they are not sure they will be able to fit in. I'm not sure at this stage how many times the class will be split as they did say some rooms were not big enough for 15 socially distancing. Our school is a large 5 form entry. If they have to split 3 ways for all 3 year groups - it would need 45 classrooms - 10 more than the school has!

Report
Howaboutanewname · 29/05/2020 00:55

There are thousands of supply teachers who would be keen to work now!

I have done supply off and on for a number of years now. There is usually, at least where I am (not South East or London), a shortage of day to day supply teachers by Xmas as people take up longer term contracts. September to November is usually quiet. I suspect there will be an abundance of long term positions from September as schools are clearly not recruiting as normal. Brilliant.

However, I am not sure how schools are going to manage day to day with a potential shortage of supply available coupled with the issue of managing ‘bubbles’ with a supply teacher who has been in several other schools that weeks. It has disaster written all over it. 2 schools near me closed last week due to cases (plural) amongst staff and key workers children.

And then there’s the thorny issue of just where the money is going to come from.

It is really not as simple as it might seem.

Report
BarbedBloom · 29/05/2020 01:07

There is a massive shortage of supply teachers here and this was the case before all of this. Also a shortage of teachers

Report
GreenTulips · 29/05/2020 01:11

Supply can claim replacement salary and get paid over the summer holidays.

If they go back they’ll lose 6 weeks pay

Report
DomDoesWotHeWants · 29/05/2020 06:33

I don't understand the logic? Nurses & teachers are key workers and needed equally?

Nurses are saving lives, much more important, I'd say. Also they are wearing full PPE.

Guidance for teachers says no PPE. Some aren't happy about that.

Report
KnobChops · 29/05/2020 06:34

@Piggywaspushed health care staff were offered hotel accommodation in 2 circumstances. 1. to enable them to continue to work (avoiding need to self isolate for 14 days) if someone in the home fell ill. 2. If they were working at one of the Nightingale hospitals to save on lengthy journeys.
A few people opted to stay out of the home while working but they paid for their own accommodation. If we had a shielded relative at home we were expected to come into work and then follow distancing rules at home. I’m sure exceptions were made when that shielded relative was a child, rightly so, but those numbers would be tiny and unlikely to impact on staffing.

Report
KnobChops · 29/05/2020 06:37

@DomDoesWotHeWants nurses were only in full PPE on wards where there are covid patients having aerosol generating procedures (ie ITU and HDU). Elsewhere they were working in minimal PPE (loose surgical mask, gloves, plastic apron) while working with other covid patients inc those on oxygen and coughing non stop, and no PPE while working with other patients. Pupils are not covid patients.

Report
Piggywaspushed · 29/05/2020 08:07

And we have all seen that most NHS deaths have occurred outside those covid wards , including amongst non PPEd porters, so the lack of adequate PPE to NHS staff and careworkers is appalling, not a good thing . I know nursing unions have complained vociferously (it just isn't reported much) and that the unions have said they can say they won't work without adequate measures in place ( I am sure they haven't done this because of a sense of responsibility; teachers have also not said they won't work , even though there is a widespread lack of conviction that the 5 test have been met). the press just haven't launched on nursing unions in the same way. I do not understand why NHS staff are so keen for teachers to take a great deal of personal risk just because they do. They are different jobs : teaching is normally a pretty safe job (although not the safest by any means ) and now has become a high exposure job, asking primary school TAs and teachers to spend six hours in a room with 16 other people : unlike nurses and doctors , teachers and schools staff are not infection control specialists and medical experts. I would think people could try and understand a little bit why school staff are jittery.

Hopefully, this will prove unfounded . However, schools in S Korea shut down today after only a few days of being open.
Aside form anything else, if our government cares at all about infection control, I think parents need to prepare themselves for schools opening, closing, opening, closing for a while which will be very disruptive, more so than now. That said, I think Johnson is very bullish and will try to keep schools, and other workplaces, open despite spikes.

Of course the children aren't covid patients : I thought the idea was that we were trying to curtail the spread.

Report
Aragog · 29/05/2020 08:18

why are they not opening. Lockdown's virtually over

Firstly lockdown isn't over. It's easing gradually. At present social meet ups can only be outside and all work places need to follow strict guidelines before opening. Dh's form is working through this gradually and they hope that in about 3-4 weeks time they will be ready to allow employees work in the offices for part of the time - basically having two groups of staff : one group in whilst the others work from home and then swap over mid week after a clean down.

Second - schools have strict guidelines to follow and most schools cannot follow them fully and admit all 3-4 year groups back in, along with KW and vulnerable groups. There simply isn't the classroom space as they now need double the room (and double the staff) they had before March. Strangely enough not many schools can magic those up!

Report
DomDoesWotHeWants · 29/05/2020 08:19

I think teachers would be a lot less jittery if they could wear masks.

I wouldn't go into a classroom without one, I don't see how they can be told not to wear them. I'm sure they also have concerns about social distancing.

The unions are doing their job by insisting that it's as safe as possible for teachers. But the press love to have a go at teachers, as has been said. Not the nurses, though, never the nurses. (and quite right too)

Report
Aragog · 29/05/2020 08:21

To be fair, our experience of NHS staff - we have many amongst our school community and where I live there are many as we have a number of large teaching hospitals here - is that widening of the school intake right now isn't right and they don't support it, well they don't support the way our government has gone about it anyway. They are also concerned that key worker children's provision will be compromised by widening the other year groups, especially the way it means that some wrap around care will no longer be available in some places, etc.

Report
Ceit · 29/05/2020 08:46
Report
KnobChops · 29/05/2020 08:48

@Piggywaspushed

And we have all seen that most NHS deaths have occurred outside those covid wards , including amongst non PPEd porters, so the lack of adequate PPE to NHS staff and careworkers is appalling, not a good thing . I know nursing unions have complained vociferously (it just isn't reported much) and that the unions have said they can say they won't work without adequate measures in place ( I am sure they haven't done this because of a sense of responsibility; teachers have also not said they won't work , even though there is a widespread lack of conviction that the 5 test have been met). the press just haven't launched on nursing unions in the same way. I do not understand why NHS staff are so keen for teachers to take a great deal of personal risk just because they do. They are different jobs : teaching is normally a pretty safe job (although not the safest by any means ) and now has become a high exposure job, asking primary school TAs and teachers to spend six hours in a room with 16 other people : unlike nurses and doctors , teachers and schools staff are not infection control specialists and medical experts. I would think people could try and understand a little bit why school staff are jittery.

Hopefully, this will prove unfounded . However, schools in S Korea shut down today after only a few days of being open.
Aside form anything else, if our government cares at all about infection control, I think parents need to prepare themselves for schools opening, closing, opening, closing for a while which will be very disruptive, more so than now. That said, I think Johnson is very bullish and will try to keep schools, and other workplaces, open despite spikes.

Of course the children aren't covid patients : I thought the idea was that we were trying to curtail the spread.

The spread is curtailed, hospitals are emptying out. I work in London, our ITU is now below it’s normal capacity, with very few covid patients and none are new.

When we health workers caught covid in large numbers we couldn’t test any patients or staff, we were commuting in on packed public transport and the community spread was at its highest. Those things are now much better.

So I don’t believe schools going back will lead to ‘high exposure’. Community transmission is at its lowest since many weeks prior to the schools shutting, and by September it will be minimal. Children are not covid patients, teachers can socially distance from other teachers and pupils (to an extent), and there is no evidence that children are spreaders in the same way adults are. Teachers will need to take some precautions in the way health staff would. So you should have the option of a visor (we didn’t!), gloves and apron if you need to work within a metre or so of a child, or clean a primary child up if they have an accident.

Nursing unions did fuck all to be honest, and no nurse that I heard of refused to go into work. We were told by our employer that if we refused to work with covid (and many staff were redeployed to areas they had no experience of working in, with a 2 hour ‘update’ of skills) that we’d have to resign.
Report
Loki1983 · 29/05/2020 09:28

Here come the teacher bashers. It’s unbelievable that the profession is now being criticised for those members who need to shield! It’s not the armed forces, you don’t need to pass a bloody fitness test to teach!

Report
Howaboutanewname · 29/05/2020 09:41

The spread is curtailed, hospitals are emptying out. I work in London, our ITU is now below it’s normal capacity, with very few covid patients and none are new

My local hospital has many new cases and is putting out regular news messages to keep distancing because our R rate is above 1 here. We don’t all live in London.

Report
KnobChops · 29/05/2020 09:54

@Howaboutanewname

The spread is curtailed, hospitals are emptying out. I work in London, our ITU is now below it’s normal capacity, with very few covid patients and none are new

My local hospital has many new cases and is putting out regular news messages to keep distancing because our R rate is above 1 here. We don’t all live in London.

No but most of the country is well past the peak. How long do you suggest we keep children off school for?
Report
KnobChops · 29/05/2020 09:55

@Loki1983

Here come the teacher bashers. It’s unbelievable that the profession is now being criticised for those members who need to shield! It’s not the armed forces, you don’t need to pass a bloody fitness test to teach!

The number of teachers who need to shield will be small. Also shielding is due to end soon. It sounds from many of these threads that you all want to stay home until a vaccine is found!
Report
Iwalkinmyclothing · 29/05/2020 09:58

Most of us at work throughout this do not wear PPE unless in a setting that indicates it.

You cannot compare the job of a teacher to the job of an NHS porter (who should have had PPE, of course, no question). NHS porters are working in close contact with ill people. Teachers will be in a similar position to me (inpatient mental health unit)- working in close proximity to and sometimes in physical contact with people not known to be physically ill. Knowing that some may be ill and taking precautions accordingly. I am not teacher bashing to say that I believe the risk to teachers is more or less equivalent to the risk to me and my colleagues and that I think current plans are unrealistic in terms of perceived risk and how to manage it.

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

KnobChops · 29/05/2020 10:10

@Iwalkinmyclothing

Most of us at work throughout this do not wear PPE unless in a setting that indicates it.

You cannot compare the job of a teacher to the job of an NHS porter (who should have had PPE, of course, no question). NHS porters are working in close contact with ill people. Teachers will be in a similar position to me (inpatient mental health unit)- working in close proximity to and sometimes in physical contact with people not known to be physically ill. Knowing that some may be ill and taking precautions accordingly. I am not teacher bashing to say that I believe the risk to teachers is more or less equivalent to the risk to me and my colleagues and that I think current plans are unrealistic in terms of perceived risk and how to manage it.

100% in agreement with this.
Report
Howaboutanewname · 29/05/2020 10:11

I can’t imagine that teaching has people with underlying health issues like asthma or diabetes or cancer at rates higher than the generalmpopulation but a missing teacher isn’t easy to replace. As a profession there is a shortage of teachers and in recent years, the profession has got a lot younger as a whole. Given that in primary, the workforce is largely female, there is probably an above average incidence of pregnancy than in the general population. A small percentage will be off with any other illness at a given time - the usual flu, stomach bugs etc. Others will be currently dealing with bereavements or have to manage teaching around caring responsibilities with elderly parents or sick partners.

Report
Howaboutanewname · 29/05/2020 10:12

shielding is due to end soon

Says who?

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.