My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

Not to be doing any extra cuticular classes with my children

62 replies

CantGetUp · 29/08/2015 13:20

I don't bring my children to any classes - they are 6 and 4.

I'm so busy working during the week and we normally do something at the weekend or just be lazy

A friend of my has her children signed up for every class going and I'm wondering if I should make more of an effort with mine.

friend's DCs are doing swimming, football, drama etc.

Does it really matter at this stage? I'm worried that by the time my children suggest a hobby they want to do that all the other children will be years ahead of them.

My elder DC has problems with coordination so he doesn't really like sports. He's happy playing lego, going to the playground etc

OP posts:
Report
BoboChic · 29/08/2015 20:07

Swimming (essential), gymnastics and art/painting/drawing are good for 4 and 6 year olds.

Report
trilbydoll · 29/08/2015 20:12

Some stuff might be difficult if you work f/t though. Our local Beavers starts at 4.45 - I appreciate that it's got to fit in before tea for that age group but a lot of people would struggle to leave work in time for that.

DD is only a toddler so I find having a weekly class gives the week some much needed structure! We're doing something new in Sept, as she seemed to be bored last term.

Report
SteadyHand · 29/08/2015 20:16

My dd2 started gymnastics for 1 hour a week at age 4, now she's 8 and trains for 23 hours a week- so be prepared that this particular sport can escalate in terms of commitment!

Dd1 has tried various things but hasn't really found anything she 'loves' and she's now 10. She currently does Brownies (about to move to Guides) and gymnastics. But she's tried swimming (both girls had swimming lessons from around age 4 but stopped for one reason or another), ballet, double bass, football and basketball. Not all at the same time!

My ds is only 1, and he goes to baby gymnastics and has had swimming lessons which I now can't afford, so I plan on taking him swimming myself when school term starts again.

Report
JemimaMuddledUp · 29/08/2015 20:29

Don't worry too much about them not being able to join an activity as they get older. DS1 is almost 13 and plays both football and rugby. He started playing football aged (I think) 5 but didn't take up rugby until he started secondary school aged 11. He now plays both for local teams and you wouldn't know that he didn't start playing rugby years ago.

Report
Minicaters · 29/08/2015 20:35

I do feel we've missed the boat with DS and football, and he's only 6! Some of his friends have been having lessons for years and practising endlessly in the garden. That said, there is no point forcing them so we don't.

Swimming is worthwhile if you can stretch to it, but I do think we tend to start them a bit young these days. At 6 or 7 they are stonger and more co-ordinated, and they often progress much faster than at 3/4/5, which saves parents hundreds of pounds.

I also think something to improve their control of their bodies is a good thing. DD was very uncoordinated at 5 and I'm sure her gym has helped with that. Some children are naturally inclined to climb trees etc and might develop just through free play, but DD is naturally more inclined to slouch about read Improving Books, so she needs the push of a class to get some exercise and improve her balance etc. Gym is a good general background - she went very easily from gym to ballet, and I suspect it would also help with other sports.

Report
Cherryblossomsinspring · 29/08/2015 20:51

I think swimming is essential. I do want to foster a love of sport so will send the kids to maybe gymnastics and definitely boxing from about 4. Hubby is a boxing coach and I think the strength, agility and discipline is excellent. Gymnastics is a great foundation for a lot of other sports. I guess the kids will ride too if they are interested but that will be something we do at home. Music is a tough one as it's something I regret not doing properly as a child so I really understand the value of it but how easily you could hate the lessons. I just want them to have skills and friendships (sport is a great way to meet good friends) they will cherish and draw on when older. I don't want to waste money on this, that and the other class for the sake of it. I guess we will play it by ear but in answer to OP, I think as a child there are opportunities to learn key skills that will be useful in the future when they travel, work, socialise so it is good to let them try many things and/or fcous on a few things. But I don't think it's essential. I learned to ski and sail as an adult but it would have been easier and I would have discovered how wonderful they are much sooner if I had done them as a child.

Report
waitaminutenow · 29/08/2015 21:09

Every child is different really, im a sahm so my DD goes to a few classes a week. She has done swimming lessons since 5months and tumble tots (gymnastics) for a year now. She adores both classes! Im thinking of starting her in a kiddies drama class in sept.

Report
AugustDay · 29/08/2015 21:32

Agree that swimming is essential but other than that I wouldn't worry about it.

My 4 DC are close in age so it was a bit of a nuisance for them to do non school extra curricular activities so, mostly, we didn't. I'd get the to do a sport each and I'd let them do things if they asked but we were relaxed about it.

If asked what extra curricular activities they were doing I just said they were doing playing. Hmm

My kids are adults now and three of them do 'extra curricular' stuff at uni (sports mostly but other things too) and the other one just socialises a lot Confused so I don't think their lack of extra curricular activities has put them off.

Report
imip · 29/08/2015 21:44

Along with all the others, swimming is just essential. My older 3 also do gymnastics, I started when dd2 was 3 as I was very worried about how 'awkward' she looked. Turns out she is probably autistic (waiting for diagnosis). So I'm glad I encouraged her to do this and to get her out and social.

Two of my former neighbours and strikingly beautiful, clever women. They could have really run amok in their teenage years, but both were in an orchestra and every weekend they lived for band. I've also started with music in the past year Wink here's hoping!

Report
AsTimeGoesBy · 29/08/2015 21:58

There are very few things I wish my parents had done differently bringing me up, but I really wish they had encouraged more sports and other activities. I did Brownies which was ok and piano lessons which I hated, that was it, I only really realised when I was in my teens that a lot of my friends had lots of skills and hobbies that I had missed out on.

My two have done loads over the years, Scouting/Guiding plus lots of sports and performing arts, it has done them both such a lot of good, DD for confidence and DS in all sorts of ways (he has autism and dyspraxia), it's hard work for me organising it all but so worth it. I never make them try or continue with anything they don't want to do, but I an always on the lookout for new things they can try, or as they get older we could do together. At any given time they do up to 4 things a week (including weekends). Some of their friends do more, some less or none, it really is different for every child.

Report
clary · 01/09/2015 15:07

"I do feel we've missed the boat with DS and football, and he's only 6! Some of his friends have been having lessons for years"

You haven't missed the boat. I struggle to think how a 3yo could be having any meaningful football lessons. 6yo is plenty old enough - the best way to get on in footy is to join a local club and you can't do that until u7 usually - ie start playing matches sept of yr 2

Report
JemimaMuddledUp · 01/09/2015 18:53

I really wouldn't worry about missing the boat with football Mini. As I said upthread, DS1 didn't start rugby until he was 11 and he picked it up really quickly. He plays just as well as the kids who started with Tag Rugby when they were 5. Similarly with football, DD did Tiny Tots football for a year when she was 4 but then stopped as it clashed with another activity. She has now started playing again aged 9. You really don't have to start everything at 4 or 5!

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.