Boffin,
I didn't think your point was snobby. We have stayed at two Pierre et Vacances places in France, one with less to do than CP, one with about the same but different, and the service was excellent. Food ok, but it was assumed that either you were cooking for yourself or you would find a local estaminet.
My husband had a bad accident when we were at one, and the management was outstanding, let me stay on and were just wonderful.
We've also done Eurocamp, v successfully, in a much more down market environment, admittedly before the main English holidays began so only Dutch and a few English there. Unpretentious, not pricey,.and if you complain it is acted upon. It did exactly what it said on the tin. The boys adored it, go karting around, buying their own pretty manky pizzas in their pretty manky French, going into the several pools.
I find CP gloomy, claustrophobic and expensive. But it gave us time with my DM, when she wouldn't have been up to coming to France with us anymore.
Ds, a teen doesn't want to go anymore. He wants city breaks with WiFi, pref a beach or swimming pool, failing which s gym, and a football stadium if poss. So much easier. Or a gite with pool and excellent local food. He now finds CP too organised.