I'm not sure it matters which diet you use I followed a very prescribed diet! Literally every mouthful of every meal was dictated and you had to measure everything! It just worked for me because it suited my lifestyle rather surprisingly. There were no treats ever which for me is good as I had to learn to live without them, on a previous diet I was allowed one treat a day this was hopeless because I was just not weaning myself off them. Having not eaten any treats for months now for the first time in years I can go shopping and walk past bars of chocolates cakes biscuits without even being remotely tempted to by them. I can cook gorgeous cakes and biscuits for everyone else now and not eat them before I would have eaten 50%. In fact I was given a piece of cake at a birthday party (you know the sort of thing icing jam butter cream etc etc) the other week to be polite I tried to eat it but I just couldn't eat it; it was so sweet.
I think success or failure dieting might be all about where we are in our lives. My DH gave up smoking four years ago he's had quite a few attempts before but he said on all other occasions he hadn't really really wanted to do it, this time was different, it was affecting his health and he knew he had to stop. I felt the same about loosing weight on a previous attempts I wanted to loose weight but didn't have to loose weight it wasn't effecting me that much. This time was different like my DH my physical and mental well being were being effected I was heading for type 2 diabetes, I was getting out of breath when I walked the dogs and I was beginning to dislike myself because I felt that then real me and the clothes that the real me wears, that make me the person I am, was by stifled completely by 5 stone of pure fat, to hide being over weight I was buying clothes I wouldn't normally be seen dead in. It does help that this enormous weight gain is only fairly recently I am today the size I was when I was 40 (9 years ago) and I kept the clothes! The other thing that has surprised me is how many people don't like you to diet, most friends said I didn't need to loose weight which was clearly untrue, many when I was dieting would frequently offer my cakes biscuits ect even though they knew I didn't want them, some would even put a piece of cake on a plate and put the plate into your hand, people endlessly would say I think you've lost enough now, don't loose any more and you'll start to look scrawny even when I was still significantly over weight. I now sit exactly between the maximum and minimum weight for my height and I still don't look scrawny. Interestingly other friends who are a healthy weight never said don't loose any more or force cakes into my hand!
You've also got to like the person organisation you going to for help with weight lose. Last year I tried weight watchers, the women who ran it drove me up the wall and the timing was inconvenient. This time I paid to see a private consultant, she didn't tell me anything I couldn't have got from group classes or a website but I liked her and she bent over backwards to accommodate my odd working hours.
Success is the greatest incentive, I remember loosing the first stone, clothes we getting loose and being so excited, I dreamt of getting under 11 stone (4 stone off) and it seems to take for ever, and at times a I thought I would never make it, I'm now a lb under 10 stone I never ever thought Id make that weight but I'm over the moon and determined never to gain large amounts of weight again I physically feel so much better and I've got the clothes on that match my personality. The other positive in my favour is that I don't drink alcohol so many say a I want to loose weight but couldn't give up the wine.
I sorry I just don't know the answer to healthy snacks I cut all eating between meals out completely. Having studied slim people very close
Y and questioned them spit their rating habits and observed what they do I've discovered that most slim people on close rarely eat between meals.