The Lacuna is great, as is Flight Behavior. She's a great story teller.
86. The Outsiders, SE Hinton
I hadn't read this before and wanted to read it before I gave it to my son. For anyone else like me who has been living under a rock since forever, it's a book written by a teenager in the 1960s, about a working class group of boys and their involvement with gang culture. It's hard to tell whether she was an extremely clever writer, or just understood her subject, or a bit of both - she writes so cleverly about the ideas of escape, of loving the places and people that belong to you but wanting to get away from them, of having choices or no choice. Really movingly universal.
87. The Travelling Horn Player, Barbara Trapido
The first Trapido I have read for years. I read another in this series ages ago (20 years maybe) and remembered it, maybe wrongly, as a bit clever-clever and populated by unlikeable characters. There were elements of that in this one - certainly few of the characters were particularly likeable and many of them had a prickly, superior, show-offy kind of cleverness (and were awful snobs - self-admittedly so). However, I found the writing witty and the story well told, and the characters were supposed to be rather awful so I warmed to it. I saw a review which said that it is reminiscent of a Shakespeare comedy where the characters keep bumping into one another in a magical forest, and it is a bit like that - plus they are all in love with the wrong people and not quite sure who is who.
88. Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother, Amy Chua
I'd been intrigued to read this since it was published and there was all the hoo-ha in the papers about her bullying the children into doing 7 hours of music practice a day etc etc. I believe that there have been some stories about her involvement in the Kavanaugh affair but I haven't really seen those so this review comes untainted by that.
I actually liked Amy a lot based on this book - yes, she is extremely driven but she's funny and ironic. I found her writing and her thinking thought-provoking - is it more loving to believe that your child can achieve anything they want to, or to let them give up if they are not making progress? Is it worth working hard at something which is not fun, to discover that wonderful moment when you finally "get it" and it becomes the most enjoyable thing you can imagine? Do American parenting techniques result in happier children/adults than Chinese ones?
I was a musician myself as a teenager and I know the experience of hours a week of practice, over years and years, feeling like drudgery and misery, and then the wonderful experience of actually being good at your instrument and the joy of being able to play. And, at the other end of the spectrum, I am now a very poor runner and I know that while I hate going out three times a week, and I especially hate doing speed drills and hills, I know that I enjoy running more when I am that bit fitter and more able than I do when I have been slacking off the training. So, while I am very much not a tiger mother, I am open to Amy's ideas about the need for un-enjoyable commitment and hard work to achieve something that makes it all worthwhile. Definitely a thought-provoking read for me.
I saw the Zadie Smith discussion come up on the last thread - I've just abandoned On Beauty finding the opening chapters almost unreadable, which is a shame as I really likedboth White Teeth and NW.
I' m now about half way through Alan Hollinghurst's The Sparsholt Affair and enjoying it very much.