My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Parenting teenagers has its ups and downs. Get advice from Mumsnetters here.

Teenagers

Ungrateful, unpleasant thirteen year old daughter

63 replies

Dolorosa · 02/02/2016 13:32

I've been provoked to join Mumsnet just to ask for help and advice about my thirteen year old daughter. To be honest, she has always been a little stubborn and stroppy - from a toddler - it's just her personality. She's the third of four, and pretty different temperamentally from the others.

She started turning into a teenager, I swear, at age eleven. Over the last few months, however, she has become completely unbearable. She verbally bullies her brother, who has mild autism and is getting agitated and tongue-tied around her, she is violently rude and abusive to us her parents when the fit takes her, and virtually no gathering of the family in the same room passes without some kind of nasty tantrum from her. She has also started making huge difficulties about getting out of bed in the morning to go to school (she claims nothing is wrong at school), and either refuses to go altogether (we've had the school intervene as best they can), or makes me waste half my morning running her about the place. I have to take the other two children separately then come back for her, as it's not fair to make them late because of her.

She has a snide, snarling, nasty tone of voice and will say spiteful things just to hurt us - all of us, my husband and me, her brother and sometimes even her little sister. And it's never provoked, she just seems to want to be vile. She also swears, repeatedly and unrepentantly – including in front of her much younger sister – even though I have made it very clear that this is totally unacceptable. My husband and I never use bad language, so it’s certainly not something she learned at home!

What really gets to me, however, is that she complains all the time about the house we 'force' her to live in. It's a minor manor house, set in grounds and woodland, a little under a mile from a decent village with a shop and no distance at all (a short bus or car ride) from the city where she goes to high school. She has her own, very large bedroom with her own en suite bathroom. But because we 'live in the country' we're depriving her of being able to visit her friends (I never make any fuss about driving her all about town to see her friends when she asks me to), and because our house is so big it's difficult and expensive to heat (we do our best) so it's a 'piece of crap' and the reason why she can't get up in the morning. There are reasons why we have no choice but to live here at the moment, and we also have severe financial and other anxieties as a family which I won't go into but make me hope desperately that we can continue to put this 'crap' roof over her head. All she wants, however, is that we go and live in what she calls an 'ordinary house' and she practically accuses us of child abuse by making her live where we do.

She complained this morning - as I drove her to school an hour late - that she couldn't get up this morning because of the house, and I ended up telling her that it was upsetting to me to work and worry to provide her with things, only to have her throw it back in my face. Her parting shot was, "That's because you don't provide me with much."

To be clear. She has, as I've said, her own bedroom suite. A laptop. Internet connection. iphone on unlimited contract. New clothes emblazoned with gloomy band motifs. Cash whenever she wants it to buy drinks and crisps. A home cooked meal on the table every night, not that she eats it half the time. A taxi service by me for her social life. Am I missing something?

As for spending time as a family, when she and her nearest brother were small I was forever taking them on day trips and suchlike. I did my very best. Nowadays, I couldn't contemplate organising a family outing, because my daughter would ruin it.

Obviously I do a lot of hand-wringing about what I've done wrong (other than living where we do of course). My husband and I spend pointless hours discussing her - pointless, because nothing changes, and no conversations we try to have with her amount to anything positive. It's draining, and emotionally exhausting, and I'm beginning to feel I've completely failed in the most important job of my life - to bring up a happy, pleasant human being.

I know a certain amount of teenage bad attitude is fairly common, although her older brothers were/are nothing approaching this. But has anyone else dealt with continual complaining from their children about their basic life circumstances? I feel sometimes as if I’m going mad.

OP posts:
Report
stablemabel · 11/02/2016 18:31

Hi Dolorosa, sorry to hear of your problem, I'm not surprised you feel your going bonkers. Please listen to BrianCox as she says some wise words

However being calm, praising her and sticking to threats is the only way forward.

It may be that she does need some sort of professional assessment if there does not seem to be any justifiable cause for the bullying, swearing and nastiness, that said, it could be just the sort of teen she is and hopefully it will pass............(.and I totally agree with you when you say she would find something else to complain about if you moved into a different house. )

That said, you and your family are living a life of misery and there really are ways you could lessen it. I know how tough it is having a stroppy daughter so I don't say this lightly but she really does need some ground rules re swearing, bullying and being downright nasty ( some of the constant whinging you're going to have to let go and ignore as much as humanly possible). I don't know if she or any of the men in the house are into football but you could have a bit of a red card system so to speak. She needs to learn that there WILL be consequences because from reading your post it seems to be a case of she say 'jump mum' and you reply 'how high?'

Before you shake up the discipline though I would have another chat to her and try to understand if there are any issues with where you live or anything else, ask her plainly when there is a calm quiet moment rather than when it is all kicking off, 'what is making you cross and unhappy'? But do say that she must realise that you do your best and she needs to know that the 'red card' behaviour is just not on. I really do wish you well with it all.

Report
goodnightdarthvader1 · 14/02/2016 18:29

You need to curb this behaviour now. I would be asking her to present me with a list of everything that's "wrong" with her life. Then I would be administering appropriate sanctions to show her how bad it can get. Examples:

  • have to get up at 8am = get up at 7am, with cold water dumped over her if she doesn't get up when called.
  • have to be driven everywhere because you live rurally = no more taxi rides. If she has bus money, she uses it. Otherwise, any allowance stopped.
  • can only communicate with friends by phone between certain hours = phone taken away completely
  • hates her room with ensuite - ensuite locked or move her totally to a small bedroom if possible
  • hates being around her family = eats in her room, not allowed leisure time with family


etc etc

She's a spoiled madam who needs a wake up call. You don't want to come down hard on her - well, enjoy watching it get progressively worse. She needs to realise how lucky she is. You'll have a hard fight for a few weeks / months, but the alternative is a hard fight for the rest of her life.

I'm sure I'll get accused of a cruel attitude by posters, but I wouldn't be putting up with this nonsense for one minute longer.
Report
Atenco · 15/02/2016 02:21

No advice, OP, but I just wanted to counter what Bobo said. I have never claimed to be the perfect parent, but, like most people I tried my best, and my dd was absolutely horrible from the age of 12 to 14. In our case, it was a bit of serendipity that worked. It wouldn't help you, so no point in detailing it.

Report
wotoodoo · 15/02/2016 03:30

She sounds very frustrated as well as utterly spoilt, your parenting doesn't sound very discipline or consequence orientated and she sounds as if she is on the autistic spectrum herself so the end result for you as a family is pretty much a nightmare situation for everyone involved.

You sound as if you are a truly lovely person who has got the parenting right for the others but you are being taken advantage of badly by your daughter.

Could I ask what sort of responsibilities you expect from your daughter and your other dc? Do they help out around the home? Do they have jobs?

Frustration can occur when dc just expect everything to be done for them and are used to having it easy and as a result take everything for granted.

If they are so used to getting their own way and not having to work for anything then they don't learn that putting effort in equals the feeling of achievement and achievement(however small) equals happiness.

She is running rings around you if you do 2 separate school runs!

There needs to be a complete overhaul in what you expect from her and how she treats you otherwise it's only going to get worse the older and bigger she gets.

I think you need family counselling and parenting help unless you put firmer boundaries in place.

You are all beholden to her meltdowns and tantrums and that is not healthy.

I would start of by having a family meeting around the kitchen table with pens and paper and start by saying no one is happy and we as a family want to change that.

Write down everything that needs doing around the house and behaviour that you want to see.

Get them all to do the same.

Pass the papers around and so everyone can see what everyone has written.

Next ask each person to write down what they can do to change things for the better.

Write down what the person themselves can do to improve things..So basically you have a list of requirements that you expect from others and then you get to see what others expect of you and you tick off what you can do to improve things.

So everyone has it written down in black and white what others expect of them and what they can do to improve.

This way your daughter (and everyone else) can clearly see the impact they have on others and crucially, what they need to improve on.

You can discuss as a family what the consequences should be if one person does not want to change for the better? Get them to come up with ideas. Then you should ask if someone does everything to improve, what should the reward be? Get them to give you ideas.

Then you could ask her to write it out neatly as a family document. As she has helped to formulate and so is part of the process of trying to make things better she will be far more likely to go along with it.

You could pin it on the fridge door.

Eveything you do for her: take her to visit her friends, play on the internet, watch tv, special food as a treat should be a reward for good behaviour.

So if you don't want her swearing or making the others late for school then that would have to be part of the plan of what you expect of her and your consequences need to be firm.

You need to be united with your dh for this to work and also don't carry out threats unless you mean them or else she will have zero respect for you.

As your dd might have undiagnosed SN this might be a difficult challenge for you but tbh I don't think you have anything to lose by putting firm boundaries in place and beng clear about what your expectations are.

Good luck Flowers

Report
Smidge001 · 15/02/2016 03:45

atenco now I'm intrigued! Grin and v nosy

Report
gymboywalton · 15/02/2016 10:21

seriously, i would remove her bedroom door and take everything out of her room bar the bed. i would especially remove the laptop and the phone.

I would get super tough and tell her she needs to earn her stuff back.

it sounds like you give in when she throws a strop-i know it's REALLY hard not to when they are so vile but you HAVE to.

Report
amarmai · 15/02/2016 10:59

a bicycle wd solve her problem re how to get around. I wd not be taxiing her when there are buses and she is soo unpleasant. Nor wd i spend money on her as she does not appreciate. Maybe a visit to a homeless shelter wd help her get things into perspective.

Report
Atenco · 15/02/2016 14:07

Oh Smidge, I should have known. Grin Really it was just that she decided she wanted to move back to the country of her birth, to be near her grandparents, and I suggested she could go and live with her grandparents and come back for holidays. I found out later that that made her think that she was at risk of losing me and that she did not want to lose me (after two years of telling me that she hated me and I had ruined her life).

So we both moved back here and then she ended up at a school where all the kids loved their parents (different culture) and we all lived much happier ever after.

Nothing I could have planned, really.

Report
kaz831 · 15/02/2016 18:59

This is my first time on here and I seem to be having the same issues with my 13 year old. From reading the posts I think I am just going to get tougher with her. She is also rude, ill mannered etc but I think losing phone/ipad etc is the way forward. It is going to be a tough few weeks but I'm guessing it will be like when they were babies and not wanting to sleep. That was hell at the time but got easier. Wish me luck

Report
karaline · 15/02/2016 20:32

I'm no expert on raising teens, and of course although the post is very detailed none of us really know whats going on in your home, or with any teens, least of all their own parents(!) but when i read this original post two possibilities jump out at me first of all its possible your daughter is not very happy and she's looking for a thing to blame. its easy to blame things we cannot change, because then we don't have to be responsible for changing them, and often we feel safest taking our frustrations out on those closest to us and before we're grown up enough to form close relationships with significant others the closest people to us are our parents (everything being normal). Perhaps she's lonely? whats her social life like? has something changed recently?

The other thing that occurs to me on reading is that people and families get stuck in ruts, we take on roles within families, and find it hard to break out of them -it can be hard to change behavior, to break habits once their formed.

So these are possible explanations, that might be right, or might be way of the mark. As for solutions i'm not sure. You have to walk the line between upholding boundaries (its obviously not okay for your daughter to continue behaving like this) and finding causes and solutions. I think communication is the key. Tell her what you want her to stop doing, tell her what you will do if she doesn't stop and then if she persists do it.

At the same time could you make time spend doing something different with just your daughter? giving both of you a chance to 'change the record' and possibly opening up the lines of communication? I appreciate this might be tricky, with four children and one with learning difficulties, you must be run off your feet.

Or is their another adult she finds it easier talk to? I love my own daughter and we are close but she often chooses to confide in my mother, luckily she lives near by.

I hope this is helpful

Report
AKinkAdmirer · 26/02/2016 20:31

Hello Dolorosa,

I am a 16 year old who went through a simiar phase of aggressiveness when I was aged 13-14 so I hope I can be of assistance, through offering a teen's perspective if nothing else. The suggestions I'll make are what I feel would have been most beneficial for me and many of my peers. I hope this doesn't come across as an arrogant youth trying to usurp the advice of adults because that is honestly not how I mean it.

I got the impression from your message that you have been trying to appease your daughter through offering her the privileges she feels she is denied, for example by offering her lifts into town to enable her to see her friends. However it's possible you are -unwittingly - contributing to the problem. Teenagers that age crave independence above all else and aggressive behaviour towards parents often arises from resentment that they are dependent on their families. What's important is that this isn't a personal attack on you, it's a negative side effect of a very healthy desire to grow. Nonetheless, being in your debt for lifts may well increase this resentment. My suggestion would be to give her a secondhand bicycle and tell her that she is free to go out as often as she wants but under her own steam. You can probably find one cheaply and if it gives her increased independence it will be a worthwhile investment. If she refuses this arrangement, that's her responsibility but she has the option open to her. When teenagers are reliant on others in one area of life it is easy to mentally extend that reliance to other areas of life and blame others for anything that goes wrong, whether justified or not. Fortunately the reverse is also true.

As for lifts to school, I would stop that alltogether except in exceptional circumstances. She can get up on time or cycle in. If she asks you for a lift then the conditions of taking other children to school first should still be used, and specify that you will not put yourself out to get her there on time. It sounds like you already do this so props to you. I didn't attend school although I have attended college part-time for two years and full-time since September so I don't know how the school will behave, but as long as you don't have cause to suspect she has serious problems at school don't get involved at all. It is her responsibility as a student to attend, not your responsibility as a parent to make her.

As to the issue of her refusing to get up because the house is cold, you said she had an electric heater she could use without restriction. I live in an extremely cold damp house and also procrastinate on getting up for as long as possible but it's just something you have to put up with. Since she is clearly not putting up with it, consider giving her a timer switch so her heater will come on automatically for a short period when she has to get up. Sometimes even getting out of bed for long enough to turn a heater on can feel like a polar exploration but this will give her no excuse. (I have this option available but tend not to use it for the sake of saving electricity.)

The way in which you present her with these options is also important. Rather than saying "I refuse to give you any more lifts because I'm done with your behaviour" it will be more beneficial to say "I'm giving you a bike because I know you're old enough to make your own social arrangements and this will enable you to have more time available without having to ask for lifts." Then she will (hopefully!) realise that you do not want to restrict her freedom and you trust her. Ultimately trust and independence are the two greatest gifts you can give a teenager and I can safely say this based on personal experience and observing my peers. Trust that she will come out of this period even if you spend the next year living as virtual strangers. Trust that she will eventually begin to repay you out of her own free will. Trust that she will survive the hardship of having an unique house that will one day be the envy of her friends. Trust that her good qualities will one day resurface.

All the best,
Marni

Report
AKinkAdmirer · 26/02/2016 21:08

Oh, and a postscript as this is my first time posting and I can't see how to edit previous ones. I didn't mean to suggest total leniency in my previous post. By all means crack down on swearing and bullying as you seem to feel strongly about them. I'd suggest telling her that you and the rest of the family (or at least you and your partner and preferably your son who she is abusing) that if she can't speak in a more moderated tone you will withdraw from communication with her. Then don't hold grudges - if she returns to behave in an acceptable way then a mention of her earlier behaviour will undermine the effort she is making.

Not sure what your personal stance was on withdrawing posessions such as her phone, but I don't agree with it. Not because I'm a phone-addicted teenager myself; in fact I've never had a phone. The reason I think you should let her keep it is because to withdraw it would display a lack of trust. Refusing to allow her to use it at meal times and certain other times? Fine as long as it applies to everyone. But while phones are hardly necessary, taking hers off her isn't going to make her feelings towards you improve. It might be a good idea to make her pay for her own contract once her current one has expired though. If there is any scope for her getting a part-time job I'd discuss that with her. I got my first job at 14, still have it at nearly 17 (it is working in a riding school) and it has taught me an incredible amount of social skills, responsibility and confidence. It also enables me to be self-sufficient on transport, college supplies and luxuries such as snacks and clothes. If she could find one then it would be a big boost to her independence and getting your first job is really a rite of passage! It feels almost euphoric. If there are no suiable jobs available for her age group then possibly give her an allowance for household jobs and again, discuss it with her first. It seems unfair that you should have to pay for her luxuries.

In short, give her increased independence and responsibility whilst simulatneously doing less for her yourself. Give yourself a break from her behaviour. I hope all goes well for you, her and your family. Additionally I apologise if this post seems too judgemental or if I am self-importantly prescribing fake miracle cures. This is all opinion and it's highly possible I have misinterpreted your situation in places.

Good luck!

Report
gleekster · 26/02/2016 23:07

OP I have had five years of this now - DD started behaving like your Dd aged 13 and is now 18 and still not quite on the other side.

I am not blaming you at all - believe me I now how awful it all is, how it affects your self confidence and your faith in your own ability to parent.

However, the phrase that jumped out at me was "Trouble is, taking away her privileges (phone, cash, internet etc) means an ALMIGHTY, toxic row until they're restored."

So what?

Seriously, this is your problem, I promise you. Let her storm and complain. You have to stand your ground.

You are in control and actually he needs you to be in control.

Good luck.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.