Brilliant post, cory. I agree with every word. :)
Ahhhh palika, now I understand the root of our problem! You say to me "Not everybody who has problems with their teens need to do what you have done, which I perceive as somehow giving up" . There are two fundamental misunderstandings here: one is that I don't give advice to everyone (usually I keep pretty quiet!) - but I'm likely to say something when I see a parent in distress, particularly if they seem to be struggling with 'control issues'. The other is that you judge me to be advocating 'giving up', which I am very definitely not doing.
I've seen my eldest son through 18 years - including two or three that were an utter nightmare, when many people here advised me I should give up on him and throw him out - through underachievement and bad behaviour and dangerous behaviour and drug use and even minor crime - to a point where he seems now to be back on track, and turning into a pleasant, responsible adult. Phew. :)
Like you, I've read a lot of books. Like cory, I've taken a lot of advice, and spoken to a lot of experienced people. I had a child psychiatrist tell me that my son and I have a 'strong and positive relationship'. A counsellor decided he didn't 'need' counseling. A police youth offending officer told me I was 'doing all the right things'. The educational psychologist said the same. So did the school and the GP. In total, 6 or 8 or perhaps 10 child behaviour 'experts' told me that my son and I didn't need their help, because I was managing fine.
But I wasn't. I was stressed and ill and struggling. I really could not understand how all these people could tell me we didn't need help, when my son was lying, stealing, truanting, under-achieving, taking drugs, getting violent with me and sometimes with others, not coming home at night, and doing other dangerous things...
Finally I got it. It took me about 5 years and a lot of stress and heartache. All these professionals were leaving me to 'cope' alone because they knew things I didn't know...
- 'Bad' behaviour is 'normal' for lots of teenagers, especially who are being made to do things they don't want to do.
- It usually passes, particularly if/when they find something they do want to do.
- They need to grow up a bit and realise they have responsibility for their own actions.
- If a parent is involved and doing anything about their child, that's good enough, because it's the kids no-one cares about who get into real trouble - and the ones who believe no-one cares about them...
The professionals - knowing all this - could step back. After all, there's no point spending money on a problem that's going to sort itself out, or be sorted out for free by mum, is there?
But that didn't help
me, and it doesn't help anyone
here who is looking for help.
If you've found parenting 'techniques' that work for you
pal, that's great. But I tried everything -
everything - and none of it worked for me and my DS1.
Now I
know you will be thinking that I can't have tried everything, or if I did, I must have done it wrong, or been inconsistent, or not done it long enough. And I understand that response, I really do, because I thought the same myself. (That is why my son once had no allowance at all for about a year... :( ) But because I sought all that help, and talked to so many 'experts', as well as to countless teachers and friends and other people here on MN, I am able to be more-or-less certain that I 'did everything right', even if
you doubt me. :)
So, if you've found techniques that work for you,
pal, then you don't need my advice. I'm not offering it to people who already know how to handle the problems they have. But I do, I think, have something useful to say to those who are at a loss, those who have tried everything, those who feel a bit desperate...
For
those parents, I believe there are some key bits of advice...
* Some kids just
are more challenging than others. If you're the parent of one of these, your priorities for them are (a) finding them something that they
want to do, and (b) helping them learn about self-control and personal responsibility.
* Look after yourself. It's not a luxury; it's a survival essential.
* If parenting advice is making you feel shit, don't try to follow it. If it doesn't work for you, that's because it is wrong for you and your DC, not because
you are wrong.
* If you've 'tried everything' and your DC is still resisting or fighting you, this is about
control rather than any specific behaviour.
* If you are in a 'battle for control' with your teen, you only have two real options: lose control, or work out how to
give them control. Any 'win' you have can only ever be temporary, and ultimately doesn't help, because the
whole aim of parenting is for your children to grow up and become independent.
* If you do lose control, you don't have to lose
influence. Keep on telling them about your beliefs and values, and what you think is right and wrong, because they absorb the 'moral messages' you give them, even while they appear to reject them.
* It's not personal, even if it feels it is. They don't hate you really. :)
... And be prepared to be misunderstood!