My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Relationships

Is it quite normal not to have contact with siblings?

89 replies

Boomerwang · 11/10/2016 12:17

I have one brother who is five years older than me. He is married and has two boys. I have not spoken to him or seen him in years. He's uninterested in me or my daughter.

As far as I know we haven't had a fight or pissed each other off previously, but him ignoring me has kind of made me do the same, rather like 'if he won't then I won't either'.

Growing up with such an age gap meant we never were particularly close, but we both lived with our parents into our twenties (who could afford to live alone in Birmingham?) so it's not like life took us in different directions early on.

I just want to know if it's kind of normal to lose touch completely with your own brothers or sisters.

If it matters I know his wife has cut me and my parents out of her life completely. Perhaps he's just supporting his wife? Even before that though he didn't seem to care.

I'm a bit scared, to be honest, which is why I'm bringing this up now, because my parents aren't getting younger and I don't have any other family in my life.

OP posts:
Report
52andblue · 21/10/2020 17:10

I have 1 half brother, 4 years older. Not seen since Wedding in 2001.
A 'Mother', seen twice in last 10 years - she's 'busy'. Father is dead.
All other family estranged since I went to Police about CSA (family member). Other side of family (Father) located after 'Long Lost Family' type scenario. Ok but they were not esp bothered so tailed off.

exH family: all v 'normal / lovely'. VERY pleased with themselves.
But ... no- one bothers to speak to each other unless it is to complain about another member / to show off so fake as anything imo.

You can choose your friends ...

Report
Otterhound · 21/10/2020 16:52

I am youngest of 5. Eldest sis is 8 years older so didn't see much of her once she left home. Add to the mix loads of horses and other animals so she doesn't visit much, lives 200 miles away, doesn't have or like kids meant I didn’t see her for 6-7 years when our kids were young.
We get on fine but have totally different lives. I’ve not seen her for 18 months and probably call couple if times a year.

I see my others siblings maybe 4 times a year. Geographically none of us are ‘just pop in for a coffee’ distance but we all get on well when we meet and we haven’t all been together at Christmas (including mum) since about 2005!

Report
messy123 · 21/10/2020 16:04

I wasn't close to my brother at all in our 20s and early 30s, despite being very close as children. He was with a woman for 11 years who didn't engage much with our family and was all for hers. When they split we gradually got more in touch and are now very close and speak at least weekly and see each other much more. It's great.

Reach out OP, you will be glad you did, at the very least you will know where you stand.

Report
Sssloou · 21/10/2020 14:51

I also think a lot has to do with upbringing. Did your parents pro actively support your relationship - to encourage your differences (non competitively) but also ensure kindness and respect was the core way all 4 of you behaved towards each other at home. Also how valued were your DPs relationships with their adult siblings modelled to you when growing up.

Report
Sssloou · 21/10/2020 14:46

Did your SIL just unfriend you and your DPs for your public FB stuff - or did they block and ignore you on everything else as well. I have “hidden” a few people on FB whose posting I find irritating - but still have a RS with them in RL. What was the advice your DM gave in a public forum to someone she maybe doesn’t know that well? Was the advice sought? Did it cause an issue with the recipient or did your SIL/DB deem it unboundaried or socially clumsy?

Report
workhomesleeprepeat · 21/10/2020 13:21

My brother is the person I trust most in the world. We tell each other everything.

My partner is not particularly close to his sister, but they do keep in touch. My old boss (now friend) literally hates her brother, he smokes to much weed for her liking and they are vastly different people.

What I’m saying is everyone is different OP. If you want to reach out, do! But equally you don’t have to. Sounds like he is v tied in with his wife anyway

Report
widespreadpanic · 21/10/2020 13:00

I don’t think 5 years age gap makes a difference. My sister and I are 7 years apart and we’re really close growing up. I think it’s more about the dynamics in the family and about parenting.

My sister and I haven’t seen each other in 12 years and maybe talk in the phone once a year. We do text a bit in spurts. We both struggle with MH issues and since our DM has passed we have both become a little avoidant but we are like that with everyone not just each other.

Report
CoronaIsShit · 21/10/2020 12:03

I have 4 sisters and 3 brothers. I haven’t spoken to any of them for almost 10 years. We had a very dysfunctional upbringing due to my mother’s MH issues and basically we were not brought up to care about each other and rather saw each other as competitors for my mother’s affection which was scarce.

I have tried to bring my own DC up very differently.

It is a source great upset for me, as well as shame and embarrassment, and it is weirdly heartening to know I’m not alone so thanks for this thread OP!

Report
Rightgirlwrongplanet1 · 21/10/2020 10:00

My brother left for uni at aged 18 and reduced ties ever since. My parents tolerate it even though they get little contact with their grandchildren. They just don't want to rock the boat. Calls to his mobile are left in a voicemail and responded to months later because he's "busy". He's a doc with three kids and wife.

I don't tolerate this type of relationship so we effectively haven't spoken to each other for 25 years. Our lives get on fine without each other.

My parents are devastated that we don't get on. They coerce me to see him at Christmas time when I conveniently travel to their neck of the woods. I felt awkward being in my bro's home with my parents. I was never officially invited, just tagged along with my parents. They never saw it from my perspective that I felt cheap.

My brother NEVER makes an effort to call me or visit me even though he might be in my neck of the woods. He travels to London and literally waves out of the train window as he travels past my home, if at all.

I finally convinced my parents to leave me out of forced Christmas reunions at my brothers in 2019; I pointed to all the times he visited London and never popped in. He would fly down on his way to some attraction with or without the kids and said he couldn't get time off to visit.

His wife makes no effort at all. She makes effort with her family only. She didn't even invite me to her hen night. Their wedding day, we were cast offs and knew our place.

I doubt we would even be informed if their kids were getting married.

My daughter has no cousin relationships at all. She has no siblings either. That is the bit which makes me sad

Report
stitchglitched · 17/10/2016 08:43

I hardly have any contact with my brother and haven't seen him for over a year. I am very close to my sister though, we speak everyday and see each other at least weekly. I think it boils down to whether you would be friends with an adult sibling if you weren't related.

Report
Everytimeref · 17/10/2016 08:30

I can go months without speaking to my sister, we both have busy lives and my mum let's me know what's going on in her life. However if she needed me I would be there in an instant.

Report
Imbroglio · 17/10/2016 08:07

Sometimes it comes down to the parenting.

Even in later life I never once heard my mum express the wish that she should see us both at the same time or 'be together as a family'. She definitely preferred to be with her friends.

Report
Richtea83 · 17/10/2016 07:59

I rarely see my two sisters, I guess we talk every few months. No falling out just very different people and we are spread out geographically. I don't really know that many people who are close to their adult siblings come to think of it.

Report
Graceflorrick · 17/10/2016 07:46

I have an only DC & on threads on here, I sometimes read that she'll miss out due to not having siblings. This thread has solidified to me that she won't miss out and I can stop worrying Grin

I don't have a great relationship with my siblings. we see each other a few times a year and occasionally speak on the phone. They're nice but we're very different.

I have a large circle of friends, many of whom I've been friends with for more than 20 years. I like my SIL and work friends - I'm happy to keep sibling relationships on casual terms.

Report
ChunkyMcBitch · 17/10/2016 07:17

I haven't spoken to one sister for 3 years and have no particular desire to do so either.

I speak to my brother only when necessary after he all but ignored me and mine for 15 years while he was married.

DM likes to pretend to everyone that we're all one big happy family but my sister and brother are cunts so I shan't be breaking my neck to see or speak to them any time soon

Report
Boomerwang · 17/10/2016 06:52

What would it take for families to reunite, and not just for one day? Death? I think it's so sad.

But not uncommon, apparently. I skype my parents every week (the're in the UK, I'm in Sweden) and they come over for a week a couple of times a year. There won't even be cards exchanged with my brother.

OP posts:
Report
Myusernameismyusername · 12/10/2016 09:52

I was very close to my sister until she met her DP and we now become further away as time goes on. Him and I do not seem to like one another anymore and I am not sure it can be fixed as neither of us like each other enough to make more of an effort than to be civil. I won't make my sister choose and I am sad about it. I have tried with him but get nothing back

Report
plumstone · 12/10/2016 09:10

One brother here - had our ups and downs over the years, not close and only really speak and see him when DF arranges a family meal/get together - however he is my brother and he and my SIL are great people - we would do whatever was necessary as and when required. If he needed a kidney, money or even a cup of tea - if I could help I would and would like to think it would be reciprocated. We don't have much in common, but when I needed help redecorating a few years ago - bless him, he was there and stripped wallpaper all day for me. We barely spoke for 9 hours, but there was a hug and a smile at the end of it when leaving - its just the way we are!! - no need for regular communication at all!

Report
Imbroglio · 12/10/2016 08:55

I think it's far from unusual. People are different and often siblings have different perspectives and experiences of family life growing up. Some are happy to leave their family behind when they grow up and have families of their own, while others like to stay involved.

I would be really sad if my children stopped having contact with me or each other when they are older.

Report
yomellamoHelly · 12/10/2016 06:56

I don't see my 3 brothers. Were never close growing up / always pitted against each other to point out some failing in ourselves. So not a surprise really. My dh speaks to his brother a lot when they're together (Christmas, Easter, holiday) but never in between.

Report
exLtEveDallas · 12/10/2016 06:35

I have 2 brothers 2 sisters. I see/speak to one sister every month or so, another sister & brother every 2 months or so, and final bro maybe yearly. Don't have a problem with any of them, just don't have a reason to speak or see them more often.

Went to a family wedding this summer and got on great with them, had a fab time, but haven't spoken to any of them since.

These days I only speak to my parents monthly as well. I do feel guilty about that, but in the evenings by the time I remember to phone it's 'soaps' time and woe betide the person that interrupts mum's soaps!

I'm not worried that we aren't closer. We've all got our own lives to lead.

Report
cathaka15 · 12/10/2016 05:24

I used to deliver medication to the house bound a few years back. I was stunned as to how many lonely people there are who had absolutely no contact with their family members. Especially the elderly. They would have lots of children but would have NC with them.
I used to speak to them and they would feel so lonely and isolated. Only in home carers coming to help them and using only one small room in their huge houses. My visits were short but would talk to them for a while and they would tell me their stores. Mostly the same. Kids grew up and never came to see them again. Or had no dc but siblings all disappeared and never spoke to each other so lost contact.
Other cultures are different when family is concerned imo.
Firstly they have more children to begin with.
Most of the time living together soon as couples marry. Families being vey involved with dc when marriage is concerned. Picking rings having ALL the family involved in the celebrations. Visiting unannounced (not one of my favourite) for a cup of tea and a chat. So constantly being around each other. Also Believing blood is thicker than water really.
Not saying this way of living is any better but just different I guess.

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

AppleMagic · 12/10/2016 04:32

My sibling is a dick and we have no contact. They're not a terrible person, just an irritating idiot and because we have little in common and don't get on, we aren't in touch. Genuinely doesn't bother me at all - just a relief. I no longer dread Christmas.

This for me and my brother too. By avoiding contact we don't fall out and it saves the rest of the family any awkwardness.
I have cousins I am very close to though who I have a more sibling-like relationship with.

Report
Landoni112 · 12/10/2016 04:20

Some sad stories here, ironic that a lot of people I know with 1 child usually say the reason they want to have another is so the first child will have a sibling to be there for them.

Report
pontificationcentral · 12/10/2016 03:31

Saw dsis in 2014 for fifteen minutes. Previously a few years before that, but can't remember. We chat a couple of times a year on fb. We get on fine. There's no drama or animosity at all - just busy lives doing different things. We usually talk on the phone at Christmas. If we remember. Grin We could pick up again very easily if it was important, but on a day to day (year to year lol) basis, it... Isn't.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.