My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Join our Primary Education forum to discuss starting school and helping your child get the most out of it.

Primary education

Those workbooks you can buy in shops...

4 replies

Butterpiecrimearea · 09/05/2011 15:28

They overstate the age groups, don't they?

DD1 is fairly bright, but I would say she isn't any kind of genius - she is 4.2, meant to be starting school in september, just starting to sound out simple words, do basic sums, talk about simple concepts in other areas, etc.

I bought her some new puzzle books the other day (she loves doing "work" - she begs me to print things off for her etc) and they were really basic - eg I bought the 3-5 year old maths book and it was basically counting to ten, and the 5-7 science book was only just starting to challenge her, and we did each sheet a few times, talked and played games etc so I could be sure she was actually understanding.

like I say, she really isn't academically amazing - she goes to nursery and no-one has ever remarked on anything besides her being quite well spoken (she's a first child - bound to be more used to talking to adults). Of course, i love her to bits, and think she is hilarious and amazing, but objectively she is maybe slightly ahead, nothing to be excited about.

So, could it be that the mn stereotype of people thinking thier child is utterly amazing is down to home workbook publishers putting an older age on the book cover?

(sorry for being controversial, but I am genuinely wondering - is it a marketing ploy?)

Or should I sign her up for uni now? Wink

OP posts:
Report
Insomnia11 · 09/05/2011 16:14

3 - 5 is EYFS so counting to ten, recognising shapes, being able to write numbers and so on is pretty much it I think.

DD1 is in Key Stage 1 (year 1) and they do 34 + 19, 25 - 9 type sums at the moment. The 5 - 7 books we have go beyond this to times tables and division, which they do in year 2.

Report
diabolo · 09/05/2011 16:31

Try Bond Assessment papers instead, they start at Age 5-6 and are mostly used to work towards the 11+ and 13+ so are more challenging.

Report
kimlek · 09/05/2011 17:11

Some books are very young for the age they advertise, whilst Letts and Bond seem about right. I've used Bond with my kids for holiday homework and they're certainly not too easy but about right for my 'average' children! Hope this helps!

Report
lovecheese · 09/05/2011 17:41

I suppose they are aimed at the "Average" child in that age group, and yes, maybe, they can seem to be a bit easy - but surely that's good for boosting a childs confidence? BTW WHSmith do a good range, I'm always recommending them Smile including a red-coloured "Challenge" range which, it claims, "Stretches the more able child" - I use these with DD, may be worth a look.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.