WARNING - LONG POST ALERT!!! I am very glad actually I didn't see this thread before we did make our decision. I saw some of the posts regarding DCPS which have now been removed and was quite frankly very shocked - had I not already seen it with my own eyes, I would have thought what an awful terrible school it was which would have been a real shame because it's not.
We sent ours to DCPS in the end. We loved MHS and I am sure we would have been very happy there and it certainly felt more "us" and understated than DCPS - although a little smug it has to be said and for all it's cosiness - it is still definitely a business first! But for various reasons, DCPS is where they are.
I have one in Little Stream and one in Upper School and certainly the experience is very different. Little Stream feels very cuddly and friendly and my child absolutely loves it and is very happy. Not the most sporty person in the world- there have been matches every week home and away and my child is included in teams and given as much opportunity as everyone else. It is not too pushy in terms of academics and achievement, but they are gently encouraged and well motivated. They are well taught but they are not heavy handed with the academics at this stage.
My other child is in Upper School. Quite different from Little Stream. Again my child is very happy and doing well. There is plenty of homework that is challenging but not so challenging that they are put off. The progress appears to be good for the level that my child is, which is probably average for the school. I do hear criticisms of progress at the ends of the academic spectrum - but for us it has not been a problem so far. Sports wise, again my child is not particularly sporty and certainly in Upper School it does seem that they concentrate predominantly on the A & B teams and my child has not had the match opportunities or away games that my other child in Little Stream has, which has been a bit disappointing. I think this is largely because DCPS is a big school and is often playing smaller schools. However, despite that, we have been very pleased with how things have gone and the opportunites provided. The teaching seems to be sound and whilst there are definitely some teachers I prefer to others, there are some really excellent enthusiastic teachers.
As a parent I have found it a very friendly school. It is quite big and therefore it is not as easy to infiltrate groups and I might have found it easier at a smaller school - but there are plenty of opporutnities to get involved. Having had first hand experience now, it has not been that expressed in the earlier, now deleted posts, which I find unrecognisable. It's a really good school and I would have no reason not to recommend someone sending their children here. I think all 3 of the schools round here are great and suit different personalities of children. If you pick one and can't in, you're still going to end up with a great school whichever one you go to.
Quite simply, I don't have especially outgoing, talented, very clever children who excel in various areas. However, they are happy, they are getting attention and given opportunities that they may not have had elsewhere. I've not been paid, bribed or anything to write this - I just felt that given the earlier posts, I should probably a give a more balanced and objective view based on my experiences so far and whilst I'm young enough in my experience not to be jaded through longevity!
WIth regard to the other two schools when scouting around for opinions, I only heard one negative comment regarding MHS - all others have been very positive as have all the comments about St Ronan's. However they are much smaller schools and as such have less people to please. The problem with a bigger school is that inevitably there will be a more diverse range of opinion.
The school does present itself as quite slick and on the surface and can appear a bit flash - but once you're there it's not like that at all. I feel quite comfortable there and I don't drive a 4 x 4 or wear Boden or come from TW! There is a HUGE mix of people from all sorts of backgrounds and it amuses me that people categorise mums and the "type" of people they are according to what school their children go to. Some people end up at one school because the other doesn't have spaces, some because it suits their child better - some because of location - some because one partner prefers the other - others because of fees. And what of those that send their children to different schools. I know of those that have them at MHS and Dulwich, Dulwich and St Ronans and MHS and St Ronans - what camp are they in? Having now met mums from all 3 of those schools - there is very little to choose between any of them. You find your niche. I think I've said enough now!!