My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Find out all about large family cars, holidays and more right here.

Larger families

should i have a THIRD CHILD? Anyone rergret NOT having a third?

54 replies

noonar · 29/10/2009 17:09

i am 37 with dds aged 5 and 7. we have fun together. they are very independent and family life is good.

we have been badly hit by the recession but long term our financial circs will almost certainly improve. for now, however, my p/t job is our main, regular income.

there seem to be many very sensible reasons to 'stop at two', but i've been v broody for over a year now.

i'm worried about having a big age gap. i'm worried that the dds might feel neglected. i'm worried about returning to sleepless nights. but most of all i'm worried about getting into my forties when it really might be too late, and realising that i really shouldve had that third baby.

does anyone out there regret their decision not to have a third? ( sorry if its sensitive).i'm just not sure what to do.

OP posts:
Report
Martini1908 · 13/11/2023 16:19

Goodness! My mum had five and said stop at 2! Do you agree? Is the jump from 2-3 kids massive? I just feel like everything is geared towards families with 2 kids. The age gap would be 4yr, 3 yr and a newborn if we do it soon...just worried the age gap is also getting too big between the eldest and baby?any thoughts welcome

Report
oneinamillieon · 13/11/2023 13:15

not a very "large family," imo. i have seven children!

Report
NatJayne87 · 12/11/2023 10:55

I've just come across this thread, wondering whether I should go in for another baby, and I find myself wondering what you decided and whether goy did or didn't regret the choice made? I'd love to here your story now

Report
Martini1908 · 30/09/2023 22:45

Hi, wondering if you ever went ahead with having dc3? What was it like? How is it all now that they're older? What's been the most trying age so far? I'm trying to decide if e go for #3 or stick with 2...mine are 2 & 3 now so there'd be 4 years between 1 and 3...

Report
SallyWD · 31/10/2022 09:54

I had 2. I wanted 3 but I don't regret it. Life's much easier with 2 and more affordable. What I love most about having 2 is that I can give them both so much attention.

Report
MissIvy86 · 31/10/2022 09:41

i Know I’m very late to this conversation but I’m a mum of six, and I don’t regret having any of them. Don’t get me wrong, it’s difficult and it still is, and I haven’t ruling out having more, but each is a blessing. And financially I haven’t anything to my name really, and won’t do until who knows, if I ever do. But I went into each pregnancy thinking I can do it and I’ve tried to maintain that.

Report
MummyAilbeElijah · 29/10/2022 11:39

Hello I have just read your comment mummymoodie and I know it was a few years ago since you wrote this but your experience is very similar to the one I'm in now ! And I just wondered how it's been ? Did you get over your scary feelings and do you have any regrets ? Sorry to jump on your answer I'm just so confused right now on everything and trying to look for some reassurance I guess. Thanks

Report
Mother2princess · 03/11/2021 22:59

Old thread but here's my story
I have 4 children under 4
Now when I had my 3rd baby it really wasn't bad but ... it turns out my 3rd child went onto have disabilitys and now needs life long care lots of medical needs bearing in mind I didn't find this out until she was 7 months old
Anyway by this point I was pregnant with my 4th I found having the 4th a harder transition
Morol of the story is I don't regret my 4th even know I am a busy mum and now have 4 under 4 oldest is turning 4 March
I don't regret it but life is hectic

Report
CPHB2021 · 30/10/2021 09:53

@Josephschild2

I know this is an old thread bit I wanted to know how everyone is doing. *@redpramlady did you go ahead @noonar did you go ahead? @mummymoodie* how's life with 3 kids? Im in the trying to decide stage now and it's just so hard

Would love to know too. Totally on the heart v head fence!
Report
Josephschild2 · 10/09/2021 21:30

I know this is an old thread bit I wanted to know how everyone is doing. @redpramlady did you go ahead @noonar did you go ahead? @mummymoodie how's life with 3 kids? Im in the trying to decide stage now and it's just so hard

Report
butterfly198615 · 01/05/2017 18:31

I have a ds 8 and dd 5 and even though the thought of having another child would be wonderful, me and my husband agree ,but we don't think it would be wise or fair on our two children. I go through fases where I would love to have one more or maybe even two, but since my two are now at that age where there independent and out of nappies and feeds, me and my husband have nearly got our life back and it's fun to go on family days out without having to stop and think of feeds and nappy changes etc and can concentrate on making happy memories with our two.I know it sounds selfish but this is how my husband and I feel also my children stay with my parents if we have a date night which we have only recently started to do as we felt the guilt of leaving our babies with our parents. If we were to have another child then we would have to stop nights out or it will mean our parents having to look after a baby as well as the other two which would make me feel really guilty ,even though they wouldn't mind.
I don't mean to put a downer on having a baby and being pregnant but all the way through my second pregnancy with dd I was thinking what would happen if something would happen to me during childbirth or even after the days after I've had my child something could go wrong and I would leave my children and husband with no mum or wife.
I suppose we would feel different and I may of felt different if I didn't have a boy and a girl. I would probably want to try for one or the other. But we have one of each so we can't really end up with anything else.
I often think but what would they look like, what would there personality be as they grew. But i have my two that I have that with so we don't think that we need another child to complete our family.

I see mum's that have 5 or 6 children that go to my ds and dd school and it looks like madness, one child is always being ignored, the others are arguing mums chatting to other mums and mid sentence blurt out some form of expletive to the ones who are arguing and the newest baby is just sat there ignored taking it all in, I'm not saying it's all mums that are like this who have lots of children but I wouldn't like to end up like that.

It's ok when there babies but how do there parents have time to listen to each child read every night and do there homework spellings etc. It's hard enough to fit it in with 2 let alone 6. Which makes me think how little time the parents get to spend with there children normally it's the older ones looking after the younger ones. Which I don't think it's right but that's there business.

Report
Redpramlady · 07/04/2017 11:49

Ditto... sat there reading the thread and thought ah I've read the before when I was googling three kids! Good to start it up again I would love to hear the stories
Exactly the same position here and edging on going for it. All reasons for not i.e. Financial tiredness sanity! The pang isn't going away for another child. I will survive but it's the older thing too for me... want them to have family around them as I am an only child myself and my mother is too. A support network if you like!

Report
Kkraaraa · 29/03/2017 16:56

I know this is an old thread, but thank you all for inputting onto it. Did any of you take the plunge of the 3rd??
I'm almost (almost) decided on going for it. We have bugger all money but that doesn't scare me, what scares me is the strain of yet more sleepless nights on my mind and marriage!!!!!! But it's a child I think I crave, not a 3rd baby. And babyhood is oh so brief really.
It was the comment about "how many do you want around you when you're old" that got me. I do, I really do want a rabble, not just a duo 😍😍
But please do fill me in, how has the 3rd child worked out for you all? Xxx

Report
ElanaH · 22/06/2011 11:55

WOW, this thread is full of everything I needed to know! I am 28, I have a 7 year old daughter, and a 5 year old son.....and for the last two years I have wanted a third child, but have tried everything to convince myself that I dont! After reading all your comments....I want one even more! We live in South Africa, and decent education is very expensive here, so the only thing stopping me from having my third child is that I would have to give up my salary. I know that we will make it on my Husbands salary alone, but we will have to be VERY cautious, and I dont want to take away from the two beautiful children that I have.

Report
sydenhamhiller · 12/05/2011 14:50

resurrecting this thread... what did you do in the end OP/ moosemama?

I am 38, have 7 yr old and 5 yr old, and had mmc in January... I was VERY tired and nauseous for the 3 months I was pregnant, and now I wonder if I can go through all of that again. So I am very interested in the 'regret not having a 3rd' idea... I change my mind daily. I am not a huge fan of being pregnant, or little babies, but LOVE toddlers (and childmind)... If only I was 25 and didn't have the clock ticking!

Report
MrsTittleMouse · 08/03/2011 16:24

Interesting that you posted this on the Larger Families board - is your subconcious trying to skew the results? :)

I will buck the trend - I am glad that we didn't have a third, even though I have been incredibly broody, and still have pangs now.

Perhaps we are "lucky" that we are 100% infertile, and so every child that we have has to be very planned. I think that it might be different if we could "forget" the contraception and get carried away in a romance of new baby smell and the downy fluff on their heads.

Pregnancy is pretty dire for me, and I know that it isn't just me who suffers. When I was pregnant with DD2, I couldn't look after DD1 properly and needed lots of help from family. Even though I had that help, I felt very guilty that I had withdrawn to a certain extent from DD1's life, because I had no choice. Then after pregnancy, I've had two babies who didn't sleep (and still don't need as much sleep as "normal" children Hmm) and fed like demons and I was exhausted. The thought of putting two children through that again just makes me too sad.

The other thing is that pregnancy has done a real number on my body - I am still struggling to repair some of the damage more that two years after I was last pregnant and a third pregnancy would mean that there would be basically no hope for me.

So it's a very boring and logical conclusion that the best thing for our whole family is to stop now. It would be risking the family members that we have got, over the dreams of a third child, which as just that, dreams.

Report
FlouryBap · 08/03/2011 16:03

I will have a no 3 next year after having 17 months between dd1 and dd2. DD2 will be three if things go to plan. ideally i would like toh ave them closer but can't cope.

what made my mind up was that i met a series of older women (one in her 80s) who told me they regretted not having more children. The one in her 80s had had four and was still mourning that fifth!

I think in teh short term it will be hard work, but when they are older it will be lovely to have three (or more!)

Report
nicobean · 04/03/2011 20:09

I definitely wanted 3, but got pregnant with DS far earlier than I expected (previous fertility probs let me assume I didn't need contraception Blush). So now I have a 4 y/o, 2 y/o and 2 month old.

Now he's here he's an absolute joy, but it is hard. Expeditions out have to be planned like military operations, and I do envy friends who have finished the nappy stage with both DC's and have freedom to go out and about with ease.

I don't regret him, but I do regret the timing.

Report
mosaica · 03/03/2011 23:23

Interesting thread. We have two children and would like to have a third. We have space in the house but worry a third child would mean no time for each other as a couple. We hardly have any now as it is!

So a difficult question now... does any of you with three or more children regret having so many? Please be honest!

Report
threecurrantbuns · 02/03/2011 20:45

nico been i was the same there is a couple in our village with four and before i had children i was like, omg 4 Shock

I always wanted children but i always thought two, i liked the idea of a big family but never thought it would be me having one!! How things change i think if i could have stopped at two it would have been ideal in a way but now i dont like the no3 feel like i need an even number Hmm

But youve decribed it well moving to 3 have been intense, and it is alot harder to regain some me time and we have found we are starting to go out very occasionally now in the evening once they are all asleep in bed but cant imagine leaving the with anyone in the day if we needed to would need to maybe send the two eldest to someone and youngest to someone else, being as mil is about our only reluctant babysitter that makes things tricky.

I also find it hard asking for help as i feel like people may think you shouldnt of had three if you cant deal with it etc but thats prob just my prob im not great at asking for help!

Report
nicobean · 02/03/2011 20:00

threecurrantbuns I think that 3/4 transition slip means you are destined to have another Smile

My 3rd is 7 weeks and although things are settling down now, it's been intense. I think that if you have 3, you struggle to have any life outside of your kids while they are small. I can't imagine one right now...

I envy people who can feel complete at 2, I knew I wanted 3 straight after having dd2. This broodiness and longing for more babies knocked me sideways. I never imagined having lots of babies and thought my neighbour with 4 was crazy. And now I know I'll want 4 too (whether I will is something else).

Best of luck with whatever you choose.

Report
threecurrantbuns · 01/03/2011 11:31

Sorry jsut read that back and its awful was rishing and cant type well!!

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

threecurrantbuns · 01/03/2011 11:29

*transition to no.3 hard!!!

Report
threecurrantbuns · 01/03/2011 11:29

I found the transition to no4 HARD! But thats just me and i had 3 under 4 so bit different.

Although its getting easier, just not the youngest is 1next month i still look at them all together and feel so happy and know i could have never stopped with two, although had a couple of breif moment in the first couple of weeks thinking...what have i doneill never cope!

I am younger so had time on my side but agree it was more about age gaps and how that effected the sibling relationships etc for me!

Now i decided whether to have a fourth and final but not sure if i could cope or if im just completely mad and if me and dh would survice another newborn Wink so similar position but diff no.

Report
slipperandpjsmum · 28/02/2011 13:35

If you do not feel your family is 'complete' you may well regret not having a third. The majority of people on here with larger families will say go for it because we have larger families.

Prob for the majority of people the biggest change is from 2 to 3 in terms of day to day logistics and people's belief they then have a right to judge.

Small gaps are very hard work and the older they get the more they cost!

But I have 4 and I love it!!

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.