Hello, I'm back! Interesting to read your situations and feelings about surgery. I'm having a wobble about it because (and I know how silly this might sound at this stage, three days pre-op) I'm worried it's been diagnosed as the wrong thing. The thing is, when I had my first ultrasound, the sonographer immediately said, "Ah, the problem here is that you have a ruptured plantar plate" and when I came home and read about that it did seem to fit my symptoms. I saw that you mentioned a weird clunking toe, footle? That's my biggest problem. If I walk straight, my fourth toe does a kind of snapping/clunking/crunching thing which startles me and then goes as quickly as it came. Is that anything like yours is? However, when I've seen the podiatrists since, they've said that the tenderness underfoot is classic Morton's neuroma, and that with a plantar plate the toe would be up in the air more, not fixed down. When I went to the doctor first time around I said that I'd go as far as to have my toe removed, I was so sure that the problem was in the toe!
Interested to see what your gp says, jchocchip. Mine is in the area where there is bursitis too, although I'm a bit unsure about what that is.
Like you all say, having surgery is a massive thing, and it could either change life for the better (I've been going through this for nine years now, so I'm pretty desperate to be able to walk freely once again - something I thought I'd never do again only a year ago, before diagnosis) but there is a chance it will make things worse...