My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Brexit

Article 50 will never be invoked now, will it?

129 replies

neverknowinglywrong · 24/06/2016 08:45

Talk about a poisoned chalice for the new leader.

I voted leave. I am very annoyed Cameron reneged on his promise to invoke it ASAP.

It's not going to happen.

OP posts:
Report
lljkk · 22/07/2016 19:09

regulations such as the ones on the power of vacuum cleaners and toasters

Those are the regulations that make a single market work.
They also happen to benefit the environment, you know, that big thing we Europeans all have in common.

Report
Kaija · 21/07/2016 20:20

"Flicking a v-sign at Bob Geldof"

So we've just made the entire country enormously poorer and more unstable for this? Well done.

Report
diamondlilly · 21/07/2016 15:14

exactly smallfox, people say they voted out because 'fed up of the lies' but they didn't vote for a socialist revolution, they voted based on the lies peddled by Murdoch and Harmsworth. Leaving the EU will not result in better public services or greater equality. If we want to continue trading with the EU we will have to abide by existing standards and regulations. 17 million people successfully gave 2 fingers up to the bank of england, OECD, IMF and said we don't believe you when you say it will be bad for the economy. Well congratulations you sure showed them. But I don't see how it will benefit anyone. Low economic growth = less tax being earned by government = less spending on schools, hospitals, social housing.

Yes there are alternatives to this - we could have voted for a different government last election, or the election before that, we didn't, we still aren't. If you don't want right-wing politics don't vote for right-wing politicians, but voting leave and saying its a revolution is fairly pointless.

Report
smallfox1980 · 25/06/2016 21:41

Rees-Mogg also backs zero hours contracts, doesn't believe in global warming or changing things to be better for the environment and didn't support gay marriage. He's a proper man of the people eh?

You really don't know anything do you?

Report
smallfox1980 · 25/06/2016 21:37

"There are lots of rich people and lots of people from Eton and Oxbridge, but they are not all part of the elite. The elite are the ones who wield power or serve power because at the end of the day it is power that counts."

Rees Mogg is an MP, and the son of a hereditary peer who was also an MP and editor of the times, he is as establisment as they come, basically he was allowed to be a candidate for the Tories till he got a seat, he's not there by his own abilities. When he canvassed in his first attempt at getting a seat ( at 28) he did so with his nanny.

Basically your theory of the establishment is anyone who is in power or has power who does things that you don't like or essentially as you keep citing the independent advice of the Bank of England as being "establishment" anyone whose analysis of brexit you want to disregard.

You don't think the owners of the newspapers that backed leaving are establishment either.

Essentially, you don't know what you are talking about, and you've voted for something that will make life far harder for "the people", you've been duped.

Report
claig · 25/06/2016 20:57

'Claig - harrumph, i live in Erewash, it's in Derbyshire.'

Hi, Puppy, that was Katie Hopkins who said that, not me Grin

I didn't know where it was but I love the name, a mixture of Ereward the Cake and Wash, great sound.

Report
Mistigri · 25/06/2016 20:19

What am I missing?

Nothing. Which is coincidentally what some people have between their ears.

Report
WhatsGoingOnEh · 25/06/2016 20:16

This "I think something is taking place" -type thinking is what got us into this mess! It's just another conspiracy theory, like the MI5 erasers, and the Remain camp spouting "lies" (which are in fact already coming true).

Nobody can believe that they'd be allowed by the Elite to make a mistake. They're waiting for The Elite to rescue them. Which is the OPPOSITE of what every Leaver said they wanted!

Leavers claimed to want independence, freedom, no more being bossed around by bureaucracy .... Well, you got it!

How do you like it so far?

Report
PuppyMonkey · 25/06/2016 20:06

Claig - harrumph, i live in Erewash, it's in Derbyshire.

Report
BlunderWomansCat · 25/06/2016 19:24

We shall see. I have an inkling something is taking place. I doubt very much that the elites and establishment will let this pass.

Report
claig · 25/06/2016 18:39

'What am I missing?'

There are lots of rich people and lots of people from Eton and Oxbridge, but they are not all part of the elite. The elite are the ones who wield power or serve power because at the end of the day it is power that counts.

Rees-Mogg is Eton, Oxford and is a great, funny, independent guy, but it is precisely his independence that makes him not one of the elite and which means that he is not a big beast in politics, not a mover and shaker because he doesn't obey the power, he goes against what the power wants e.g. he was for Brexit and the power was all for Remain.

Report
WhatsGoingOnEh · 25/06/2016 18:34

And Katie Hopkins' piece is just idiotic. Each of the Leave voters was just voting to Leave human rights, Leave workers' rights, Leave EU subsidies, Leave being the financial capital of Europe, Leave environmental benefits, and in fact Leave themselves PURELY at the mercy of whichever government is in power at the time.

Report
WhatsGoingOnEh · 25/06/2016 18:31

But the "elite" argument doesn't stand up at ALL, seeing as how Gove, Johnson and Farage are all as Eton/Oxbridge/upper-middle as they come...

What am I missing?

Report
gunting · 25/06/2016 18:21

Claig some more utterly strange assumptions. I wouldn't trust Cameron and Osborne to look after my goldfish.

Report
IrenetheQuaint · 25/06/2016 18:17

Katie Hopkins, that famous defender of the people Hmm

Report
claig · 25/06/2016 18:13

' It just seems like tin foil hat nonsense.'

OK, you are entitled to your view but I think you, like Umunna and Blair, who says "I don't understand what is happening in the world", are missing what it is really all about and why we have just witnessed the greatest revolution of the past 40 years.

'The suggestion that remain voters are not 'the people' is just bizarre'

I never said that.

'Do you reckon I'm the elite?'

No, but I think that you believed Cameron and Osborne and the Bank of England and the IMF who are part of the elite, and the majority of the people didn't.

Report
claig · 25/06/2016 18:09

Powerful Katie Hopkins article that gives a Brexiteer perspective on why this was such a historic vote. It was not about pounds and pence or trade as the Labour politicians wanted us to believe. It was about democracy and liberty.

"Pinch me, I must be dreaming. It's the day Britain stood up proud and tall and reclaimed its birthright
...
Watching the results come in was a glorious thing. A moment in history. Hearing the heartlands of the nation jump to its feet, one by one, and shout 'leave'.

West Devon: Leave. Sheffield: Leave. Sunderland: Leave.

Each returning vote, flicking a v-sign right back at Bob Geldof, simpering liberals and the politics of fear.

Ashford. Leave. Erewash (I know, me neither). Leave. Eastbourne. Leave.

The authors of the Remain campaign, now conspicuous by their absence. Lying low; pondering their chances of clinging on to their selfish ambition.

Theresa May - happy to lecture our police. Too weak to fight for our country. Now wondering if she said sufficiently little to stay in post. Pathetic.

Osbourne - rowing back on every threat he ever made, watching power slip through his fingers as quickly as his receding hair.



Britain has finally stood behind our big hitter, Boris Johnson (pictured) who put it all on the line to be true to the vision for Britain he believes in

















Britain has finally stood behind our big hitter, Boris Johnson (pictured) who put it all on the line to be true to the vision for Britain he believes in

Philip Hammond, Jeremy Hunt, Justine Greening, and 18 other cabinet members, suddenly on the wrong side of history. Backing the wrong horse.

Coventry. Leave. Darlington. Leave. West Midlands. Leave.

All shouting right back at the liberal luvvies paraded before us as the definitive arbiters of right and wrong, what's socially acceptable and not.
...
And woe betide the martinets of Brussels if they even think about robbing us. Or making us keep voting until we get the right answer like they did the Irish.

We won fair and square against some of the most reprehensible campaigning I've ever seen.


www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3658316/Pinch-dreaming-s-day-Britain-stood-proud-tall-reclaimed-birthright.html

Report
gunting · 25/06/2016 18:07

Cleig to be honest, I can't read your comments through all of the 'elites' and 'people ' talk. It just seems like tin foil hat nonsense.

The suggestion that remain voters are not 'the people' is just bizarre. I'm a young mum who grew up on a council estate that can't afford a house or maternity leave. Do you reckon I'm the elite?

Report
smallfox1980 · 25/06/2016 18:03

Ha Claig, you do make me laugh.

Anyway I'm not going to bother you any longer.

Good luck when Christmas comes xx

Report
STIDW · 25/06/2016 18:01

I like democracy and not rule by people that we can't kick out of office who make rules about the vacuum cleaners I can buy.

Legally the EU status is an international institution & it has more democratic controls than any other international institution. It isn't ruled by people who can't be kicked out of office.

EU Council (democratically elected heads of EU states) sets the EU agenda & together with the EU Parliament adopt laws & endorse them.

The Commission is an executive body that advices, draft & propose the laws in much the same way as the law commission, civil servants & lawyers do in the UK. MEPs elected by EU citizens have the powers to appoint & dismiss the Commission.

Report
claig · 25/06/2016 17:52

This is what it was about and we the people won

In this Brexit vote, the poor turned on an elite who ignored them
...
“The sources of their dignity, the dignity of labour, have been eroded and mocked by … globalisation, the rise of finance, the attention that is lavished by parties across the political spectrum on economic and financial elites, [and] the technocratic emphasis of the established political parties.” A lot of the energy animating Brexit, said Sandel, had been “born of this failure of elites”.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/jun/25/brexit-vote-poor-elite

Everybody with an ounce of sense already knows this apart from the metropolitan elite and the BBC. We are run by an out of touch and somewhat stupid elite from Eton and Oxbridge.

As Trump says in America "we are sick of dumb decisions made by losers" and it is very similar here with "negotiations" with our partners that are trumpeted but deliver zilch.

The speeches Cameron makes are no different to the speeches Umunna or Blair makes, they are probably all written by the same Oxbridge graduate working at the Mnistry of Love. The facade is fading, the sham is apparent, the wreck and ruin of the working class's jobs is everywhere to be seen.

The people no longer listen to the speeches of Cameron and Umunna, we've heard it all before. This referendum was the last chabce for the people to get some change, the chance to "kick the establishment" and shake the bankers and the spinners and the courtiers who serve the lobbyists and not the people.

The British people took their chance against all the might of the media broadcasts and scares from the Establishment and the British people won. The whole world is stunned.

Report
WhatsGoingOnEh · 25/06/2016 17:45

OP, I've been reading up on this.

Only the member state that wants to leave the EU can invoke Article 50. But the EU does have the power to suspend any member state, under Article 7, if the state breaches any of the EU's principles.

Democracy is one of the principles.

So we might end up in a weird situation, where the EU invokes Article 7, because the UK didn't invoke Article 50 (and therefore didn't act upon a democratic referendum).

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

gunting · 25/06/2016 17:40

What is all of this nonsense from brexiters about vacuum cleaners? There was a reason for the restrictions that effected all of 4 models and it was to do with energy use. Oh wait, I forgot that brexiters are more likely to deny climate change too....

Report
claig · 25/06/2016 17:36

'you're not really a challenge are you?'

But I am not trying to be a "challenge". I am saying that I voted out because I want an independent country with a government that makes our laws and I think the EU Referendum was the people vs the elites, and we the people won and set off the biggest revolution of the last 40 years which is now shaking the entire world, has led to the resignation of Cameron, his friend in the EU, Lord Hill, and may lead to a complete realignment of our politics to make it more accountable to the people.

I didn't participate in that because of figures argued over by Full Fact, I did it as many others did because I wanted a self-governing country where the people choose and deselect their representatives.

Report
claig · 25/06/2016 17:31

'You are aware that we don't live in a fully democratic country here right? '

Yes, I am aware of the elite and the Establishment.

We all have confirmation bias. I tend to be more conservative than labour because I think conservative is more common sense. Of course, someone like Cameron sorely tests that assumption, so I am prepared to listen to Corbyn to see if he is more common sense, but since I already tend towards conservatism then Corbyn would have to offer something exceptionally good to make me change my mind and saying that "there is no upper limit to immigration" and his sidekick, John McDonnell saying that "every country will have open borders by the end of the century" doesn't sound like something a common sense person would say, it sounds more like something that Goldman Sachs would say.

It is similar for the EU. I like democracy and not rule by people that we can't kick out of office who make rules about the vacuum cleaners I can buy. So I listen to Cameron, but think he is incapable of offering anything to redress the democratic deficit of the EU.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.