My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

Education

Is private tuition market growing?

40 replies

SRWalker · 27/06/2011 12:49

My name is Sam, and I am currently finishing my PhD in education. My dissertation is on the British Education system, specifically in London. Being American, I have been shocked by the amount of private tuition that occurs in the UK?there is nothing like this back home!

I recently read a study that claimed almost half of English students get tutored at some point in their school career! Is this the kind of mass market you all have seen as parents? Do your children receive private tutoring?

Do schools advertise private tuition companies? Or is private tuition seen a failing in a child?s intelligence?

I appreciate all of your responses in advance.

OP posts:
Report
sarahfreck · 29/06/2011 23:29

I am a tutor working in Greater Manchester. I'd say parents get a tutor for the following reasons.
1/ Students have a mild to moderate specific learning difficulty (eg dyslexia) This may not have been picked up on by the school, especially if the child is quite bright and has developed "coping" mechanisms. Parents sense that something is not right and the child is frustrated but school repeatedly says there isn't a problem, so they look for a tutor. (I think this is partly a consequence of the national curriculum as if the child is meeting targets for their age, a lot of teachers assume they are OK or even worse say the child is lazy or not concentrating - also a surprising number of teachers don't know much about special needs and so don't always pick up on things). On the other hand the school may be aware of the problems and they might have been formally diagnosed but parents feel that the child is not making any/enough progress and is getting discouraged. Or they may just want to supplement the work that the school is doing. This forms about half my workload at present.

2/ Students have needed longer than they have been given at school to really grasp particular ideas and concepts. Their understanding begins to slide and they feel they are beginning to fail. The child starts to believe they can't do the subject. They get unhappy and may start to give up. This particularly seems to be an issue with maths and can be the result of poor teaching in school or the teaching may be good but the child just doesn't have enough time to consolidate within NC constraints before they are on to the next topic. By the time they "spiral" onto the same topic again, they have forgotten the things they half-grasped before and have to start again. Forms about a third of my workload currently.

3/ Preparation for a particular exam. This may be because the school doesn't cover the areas needed (eg 11+/independent school entry) or because the student (suddenly) realises with a bit of extra support they could achieve a grade higher (GCSE) or where there has been a lot of supply/teacher illness and the syllabus hasn't been covered properly (GCSE). Only one student in this category currently. It is interesting though that some of these students turn out to have problems with things like dyslexia too, that have never been spotted.
(It sounds like I'm finding dyslexia at every corner, but it's not me diagnosing it, just knowing some of the key signs and recommending the parent get further assessment!)

4/ The student is actually quite good at a subject but gets anxious easily and starts getting upset/worrying they can't do it. This in turn can prevent them from learning as well as they might, so then they get a lose more confidence. Tutoring can provide extra support to help the student realise s/he is capable and can do it! One student in this category at present.

5/ Specific medical reason for lack of progress such as an acquired head injury. No students in this category at present.

In general I'd say parents often get a tutor because they sense/know their child is unhappy or stressed about an area of learning. They try and address this with the school with limited/no success. They don't want their child to be unhappy so seek help. A lot of my work is about being sensitive to the emotional needs of the children as well as the academic needs.

There is an element of wanting children to do the best they can/have the best educational experience they can which sometimes translates into wanting a child to get into a particular type of school, but I've not met any truly "hothousing" type parent yet!! If parents ask me to prepare a child for 11+ or suchlike and I think they are too far off from this I am upfront and say so. Most parents know their children pretty well in any case and truly have their best interests at heart.

Not all my student are from middle class backgrounds although the majority are (as you would expect from a financial point of view). Some parents aren't well off and only afford tutoring with the help of other family members!

Report
Bonsoir · 30/06/2011 07:50

sarahfreck - that was a very good post! Thank you for segmenting your customer base so succintly.

"Students have needed longer than they have been given at school to really grasp particular ideas and concepts. Their understanding begins to slide and they feel they are beginning to fail. The child starts to believe they can't do the subject. They get unhappy and may start to give up. This particularly seems to be an issue with maths and can be the result of poor teaching in school or the teaching may be good but the child just doesn't have enough time to consolidate within NC constraints before they are on to the next topic. By the time they "spiral" onto the same topic again, they have forgotten the things they half-grasped before and have to start again. Forms about a third of my workload currently."

I think a lot of the market for tutors here in France addresses this issue. I have been surprised at how some topics are taught very densely over a short period of time - my gut feeling, as a mere mother, would be that children would find it much easier if those topics were taught over a longer time frame (without necessarily allocating many more more school hours overall to them).

Report
Bunbaker · 30/06/2011 13:29

My auntie (now retired) used to tutor A level chemistry - usually to girls from the local extremely high acheiving girls high school. Her tutoring was mainly to ensure that the students acheived an A grade in chemistry.

Report
imcassie · 30/06/2011 13:36

My friend has a sister in the States and she said it is the norm over there to tutor and they are in private schools so effectively paying twice.

I live in an area where people pay for lots of extra curricula stuff but very few use a tutor. Might be different in a grammar school county.

Report
Cortina · 30/06/2011 15:16

Bonsoir, I tend to agree with you.

Out of interest what would you add in to the curriculum given the choice?

Also some I know vaguely talk about the traditional aspects of the French curriculum that are so fantastic. What are these? I think there is an emphasis on testing, correct spelling etc?

Report
mrz · 30/06/2011 15:37

agree with cory and others I don't know any children in my area who have tutors so I'm not sure where your figures came from.

Report
mnistooaddictive · 30/06/2011 18:40

I tutor students and I am expensive! It is not an option for a lot of people. I tutor at GCSe and Alevel. The majority of my students have tutoring because their parents want them to acgieve higher than they currently are. Most ofthem are not falling behind but parental aspirations are very high! Sometimes it is lazy students but sometimes they just want to do better. I think it comes about because parets have so much information from schools thesedays. When I was at school, you got very little in terms of realistic exam prediction until just before the exams when it was too late.

Report
Bonsoir · 30/06/2011 18:44

Cortina - I am very happy with the rigorous approach to instilling basics of the French curriculum. My DD (6.8) has really lovely, fluid, cursive handwriting and is very good at arithmetic (paper and mental). However, if I want her to express herself in any way I need to find outlets outside the curriculum (some of which are offered by her - atypical - school) and I wish that all the art/singing/theatre/sport came as part of the package.

Report
mnistooaddictive · 30/06/2011 18:45

BTW tortu I do know what I am doing, one of my first questions is which syllabus are you doing?
When I was teaching I would always give advice to those with tutors such as suggesting they took mock exqm analysis to share with their tutor as I believe that working with a tutor was in my best interests too! I hope the teachers of my tutees feel that way too although many do not feel confident to share with their teacher they are having tuition.

Report
forehead · 30/06/2011 21:49

I had a tutor for maths when i was 14 years of age. It was the best thing my mother could have done for me.

Report
SofaQueen · 01/07/2011 12:25

Well, I am in West London and tutoring is rampant - even in the private sector. Competition is fierce, and parents are extremely ambitious and competitive (for their children and with other parents). I don't consider private lessons in tennis/swimming to be tutoring, but Kumon and one-on-one academic tuition are. Some people do both.

Reasons:

  1. Child is not academically where parents wish them to be
  2. Parent wants to give child an edge over peers
  3. Child is taking 7+/8+/11+ to one of the highly selective prep school
  4. Child was tutored to get in to said highly selective prep school and needs to keep up with the pace of said school
Report
AlsoAvailableSober · 01/07/2011 12:31

I had A level maths tutoring as the 'Pure' bit of maths flummoxed me and i needed 1 on 1 help to get my head around the concepts (never did fully lol). It was a joint decision with my parents not imposed on me due to their expectations.

I also had some extra coaching for Economics A level as we had a change of teacher and he was dire. A group of students got together and had some extra lessons from our old teacher just to keep us on track. Poor teacher was sacked and we stopped tutoring once the new teacher was on board.

This was in the 70's BTW

Report
forehead · 03/07/2011 20:22

I paid my way through university by tutoring.
Tutoring is rampant in the Kent area, because of the competition to get into the grammar schools. Tutors charge as much as £30 an hour and the good tutors even have waiting lists.

Report
Elibean · 03/07/2011 21:03

I believe its fairly rampant here in SW London, too.

Thankfully, not amongst dd's immediate peers.

Report
VanessA001 · 16/12/2012 18:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by Mumsnet for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.