My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

to think she should give her a lift her fucking self if it's such a wonderful idea?

62 replies

RedButtonhole · 10/02/2015 12:56

I recently started a night class which I attend once a week. The college I attend at is in a large town which is situated in a county mainly made up of rural towns and villages so many of the students commute up to 50 miles to attend here.

I travel 40 miles by car and another girl in the class travels from the same direction but is only 20 miles away.

On the first night one of the other students loudly suggested that I give public transport girl a lift home As she has to wait 40 minutes on a bus after the class. Put on the spot and not wanting to seem mean, I said I didn't mind taking her home that night, but she ended up leaving before me and never mentioned waiting for a lift.

This week, the student suggested it again, I overheard her saying loudly and pointedly that "it's a shame one of the other girls wont give you a lift to class and back to save you the hassle of getting a bus and waiting about". Public transport girl just shrugged it off.

The thing is, it is sort of on my road home, but it would add about half an hour onto an already long journey and as I live so out of the way I do like to get other things done when I'm in the town if I can make spare time before the class so wont always be travelling at set times.

The girl who takes the bus has never really mentioned wanting a lift herself and in any case she knew what the travel would be like when she signed up for the class.

AIBU to think the pushy one should just keep her nose out and stop trying to guilt trip me into offering this girl a lift?

OP posts:
Report
RedButtonhole · 10/02/2015 21:22

I would never dream of letting the girl stand in the pissing rain or freezing cold on a dark, miserable night. I like to think I am a kind person, though that may not be coming across here due to my annoyance at the pushy girl.

I only passed my test a couple of years ago and I do understand the misery of standing about getting soaked or cold, it's far from pleasant when you just want to be at home and winding down- If it was a horrid night or a night where we get off a bit earlier (meaning her wait would be even longer) I wouldn't hesitate to offer. But as you say it should be on my terms not forced upon me.

It's nice to help out but more.frequently I seem to do so whilst really putting myself out. I leave home at 8am (regular college course which is 20 miles in the other direction from my home), go straight from there to the one that holds my night class and don't get in till ten so the detour on top of running extra errands probably seems worse than it would on a Saturday afternoon when I've had the rest of the day free.

OP posts:
Report
CharityD · 10/02/2015 21:31

Worth bearing in mind too that most people probably have the same opinion of the pushy one, as you do.
Don't feel pressurised by her. I would enjoy ignoring the big hints, or failing that, smile fakely, and suggest that since she seems so helpful that she should be the one to give a lift... Wink, then look amazed when she tries to splutter out that it's not on her route.

Report
Only1scoop · 10/02/2015 21:34

Public transport girl is probably Confused every time pushy Fucker opens her mouth....

Yanbu but I'd probably offer anyway occasionally

Report
listsandbudgets · 10/02/2015 21:35

Sorry redbutton I didn't mean it to come across like that. It was more a gentle reminder that this was a kindness you could do if you had the time which would be deeply appreciated for a very long time (if PT girl is anything like me that is)

Nobody has a right to guilt trip you into doing something inconvenient and if my post came across taht way it really wasn't meant to.

Report
heartisaspade · 10/02/2015 21:43

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

RedButtonhole · 10/02/2015 21:52

lights no need to apologise, I didn't take your post in a bad way, I just wanted to re-affirm that I do usually like to help people where I can and usually don't mind if its a little inconvenient. Smile I just feel that maybe I have come across as a bit hard-faced because of my annoyance at the pushy one.

It's just that this is happening at the end of an already very long day, she'd need to tag along on errands (i prefer to shop etc. on my own) or I'd have to skip doing them altogether.

hearts I feel the same way, and before I could drive or if I don't have my car I prefer to make my own way on foot or by bus.

Without wanting to sound self-important, life is very very hectic for me at the minute and the time I spend travelling is really the only alone time that I get where I'm not really doing anything else.

OP posts:
Report
FightOrFlight · 10/02/2015 21:53

I'm another lift-avoider unless I know the person and get on well enough with them to fill the journey with either small talk or comfortable silence.

I have a friend who always wants me to take a taxi home from her house even though I tell her every time I'd rather walk. She refuses to accept it and then says "I'll pay for it" as if I'm too tight to spend money on a taxi which I am but that's not the point Its a 20 minute walk not a fucking marathon.

This went on for years until I completely lost my rag with her and shouted "WHEN WILL YOU GET IT INTO YOUR HEAD THAT I DON'T WANT A FUCKING TAXI" Blush

It did the trick though, she hasn't mentioned it again and I've been round quite a few times since then.

Report
AHatAHatMyKingdomForAHat · 10/02/2015 21:55

I wouldn't say anything at all to mouthy passive aggressive fucker.

She hasn't actually named you or directly asked you on behalf of bus woman (who is doubtless mortified).

You owe her no explanations.

Ignoring her is perfectly valid. You will look the better person.

Clearly she likes the attention. If you give her attention she'll pull more stuff like this.

Report
TondelayoSchwarzkopf · 10/02/2015 22:08

I feel mortified for the poor bus girl. I have travelled almost exclusively by public transport all my life and hate the passive aggressive Mrs. Doyle style lift offerers ("you will, you will, you will") who cannot countenance the idea that someone might prefer public transport.

I like having space to myself to stare out of the window or read my book or digest what has happened in the day. I like the feeling of being under my own steam. I really like a walk in the fresh air after being cooped up. I hate pressure to make chit chat and the onerous burden of having to be dependent or grateful and negotiate the excruciating social minefield of whether you offer petrol money or not. And how much. Oh and having to give directions, especially if you live in a labyrinthine and rough estate.

I'm pretty sure that Public Transport girl agrees - otherwise she would have pushed for a lift the first time.

Report
RedButtonhole · 10/02/2015 22:11

You could be right Hat. She is most definitely the loudest person in the class, I'm probably being bitchy now but I can't imagine someone with her personality doing the profession we are all working towards.

Maybe an element of it is attention seeking, she often interrupts the lecturers with silly comments about how hard the work is or whatever.

OP posts:
Report
AlpacaPicnic · 11/02/2015 00:06

PT girl really doesn't want a lift btw! I've just reread the op and it mentions how she left before Red. People who are hoping for a lift tend to hang on. People trying to avoid being forced to accept a lift make a quiet exit like I do all the time

Anyways, who's to say PTgirl (best superhero name ever btw) is going straight home? Maybe she's going to sneak in a quick visit to her boyfriend, maybe she's going to treat herself to some chips, or a quick drink before the bus comes...

The thing that really gets on my wick about lift-pushers is when they insist on giving you a lift so you don't have to 'suffer' waiting for a bus, but then spend twice as long fucking about before giving you the lift that you didn't want in the first place so that you actually get home later and more stressed. yes mil I'm looking right at you

Report
RedButtonhole · 11/02/2015 07:14

Yes Alpaca! I didn't even notice her leaving the first week when I had said I.could take her home. She had mentioned being.starving and wanting a chippy actually, not that I'd have minded stopping for that but she probably just wanted to go and have her wee treat in peace

OP posts:
Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.