My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

and an old prude to be upset by dd13's pornified take on life?

146 replies

tantrumqueensmum · 27/11/2013 18:42

dd (13) thinks I am being totally unreasonable (so what's new) as I have taken her phone off her for the second time after she sent messages referencing anal sex and lube to a boy she barely knows (esp as one of the messages mentioned that said boy had asked my dd2 (only just turned 11) about lube - eurgghh. Angry

Apparently, this is classed as 'banter' - as was the previous set of messages to a different boy she barely knows about prostitution with reference to oral sex?! (Ironic and 'jokey', according to her.)

I do not think this kind of topic is appropriate for anyone of any age to text to someone they hardly know. There is also swearing too - I don't like to see this in texts either but am less bothered about this and am prepared to let this go.

Should add dd goes to an all girls' school so sees boys as rather more interesting than they actually are. Hmm She certainly has no actual sexual experience though reads EVERYTHING not nailed down eg newspapers, books etc, and though internet filters apply, I daresay the odd thing there may also have slipped through. Presumably teens talk about such matters as well, and she also presumably picks up the general porn-inspired culture around us, where women are supposedly expected to look and act like porn stars in all contexts, no matter how inappropriate.

I've tried talking to her but despair of making her understand - have told her that that kind of 'banter' in the workplace would lose you your job, that texting/messaging is not the same as chatting in the flesh, as stuff is recorded potentially forever; but though in the past she's claimed to understand my point, she is now just weeping that she neeeeds her phone back, I'm killing her social life without it, and that this kind of chat is actually not that bad and 'all teenagers do it'.

So, dear MN jury, is she right? Do 'all teens' 'banter' like this? Am I prude? Or , alternatively, is she way out of order/in need of help (what help???) and how do I get her to understand how normal adults (or even teens) interact with each other on phones (or off them)?

OP posts:
Report
digerd · 03/12/2013 12:56

I cringe at the things I said at 15. At 13 I wanted to go to an all night party and DM said NO. I told her she was jealous and didn't want me to enjoy myselfBlush. Everything was for show thinking I was such a woman of the worldHmm.

But it is right that the boys will believe the girls who say/text those things. It is leading them on and putting the girls in danger.

Report
Leonas · 03/12/2013 12:24

I hate to say it, but most teenagers do speak like this to each other. I am a secondary teacher and have overheard conversations/ comments about oral/ anal/ group sex from children of that age. It doesn't mean they are actually doing any of these things but it is part of the way the speak (this doesn't apply to every child, but I would say the majority).
I don't think you are unreasonable to take her phone away for this though - just because everyone does it, doesn't mean you should be happy about her doing it! Plus, it is great that you are trying to speak to her about why it isn't appropriate. I'm sure my mum would have been horrified at some of the things I did/ spoke about at that age and my mum is sure she horrified my gran in turn - I think this is a way of life for parents (I'm expecting my first baby girl and am already anticipating this kind of situation in the future!) but it doesn't mean you have to just let it go

Report
tantrumqueensmum · 02/12/2013 22:43

Thank you all - am wondering about whether to copy some of the messages from here to show dd (can't show the whole thread as some of it might give her ideas might be as inappropriate reading for a 13 year old as her own messages!

Though she might hate being talked about on mn - so maybe not such a good idea (she does know I go on here to let off steam incl about her - have nced for this thread btw).

Thanks for music suggestions, hooochycoo - some interesting ideas for me as well as her!

cjel and Woodlice - thanks for info on counselling - really helpful.

Elephants - sadly I don't think she thinks of me as a person, just as her mum - in about a year we've gone from being v close friends and allies to her being oppositional to all perceived authority figures (of which I am obviously one in her eyes despite feeling not remotely in control of my life let alone hers!) Don't know how to get her to see me as human. :(

OP posts:
Report
OldDaddy · 02/12/2013 16:21

If that's banter, then in another few years I'm sure when I show any of my DD boyfriends my shotgun and give them a stern warning that will be classed as banter as well. Well that's what I'll tell the police.

Report
thegreylady · 02/12/2013 09:04

I have 2 dgds aged 14 and one aged 13 and none of them would text like this (or so they tell grandma) but the thirteen year old was actually shocked and didn't understand. Tbh I wished I hadn't asked her. One of the 14 yr olds said she might talk about such things with her girl friends though never with boys. The other felt that your dd must be 'showing off' and would get a name for herself among the lads.

Report
TalkingToTheWoodlice · 02/12/2013 00:47
Report
ElephantsAndMiasmas · 02/12/2013 00:07

I think there's a big difference between " family time" (especially if labelled that, my own mother would throw up at the thought Grin) and nice times just the two of you. She's growing up, ask her what she thinks of stuff, talk to her about your life and make her realise you are fundamentally a person who happens to also be her mum, laugh about things you both find funny (taking the mick out of her dad for instance, not in a mean way but you must know his habits pretty well).

Report
cjel · 01/12/2013 22:15

Please don't give up trying to spend time with her, she will appreciate all your efforts even if she doesn't tell youSmile
Also our schools have counsellors the students can access, it won't cost anything.
If not go to BACP website. they will have lists for your area, Some are charities and you pay as you can afford.

It is not a stigma any more to have counselling - you would be surprised at how many of us have it!! The school now has 2 full time counsellors for its students as well and there doesn't seem to be a problem seeing them.Keep telling her you love her and will always be there for her, but step back a bit from the lectures and leave that to an 'outsider'!!!
I used to buy my dd those cards with long lovely daughter verses in. and send love you texts. We didn't have to talk to each other and she told me she used to sleep with them and read them over and over(not till years later she admitted that though!!)

Report
hooochycoo · 01/12/2013 21:28

no bother OP, how about Babes in Toyland, Bikini Kill, Casey Scott, Cat Power, Exene Cervenka, Helium, Hole, Kathy Acker, L7, Liz Phair, Maggie Estep, Pat Benatar, PJ Harvey, Pretenders or Sleater-Kinney? An anonymous Christmas gift perhaps?

Report
GimmeDaBoobehz · 01/12/2013 20:52

You aren't a prude. It's ironic as now I'm 23 I find this kind of thing purely vile and the thought of it makes me want to be sick, to be perfectly honest with you.

But yes I had done similar at that age ten years ago. Not proud of it. I would talk about it though but not about doing it to them, iyswim.

Except my boyfriend but even then it was when I was around 15.

I really don't think it's nice to see/hear and it's up to you how you handle it (remove phone for example) but I just hope my DD who is so small now doesn't lower herself like this; I want her to do better than I have done.

Report
tantrumqueensmum · 01/12/2013 20:01

@ nooka - I think you're also right re counselling/underlying issues. Her behaviour has definitely changed this year and some of that is hormones but there are other issues too, I think - as said in OP, have had a hard couple of years and I think she's found it hard to deal with things especially as self-knowledge is not her strong point!

But not sure how to access counselling and don't want her to feel 'labelled in any way. Just it might be helpful for her to talk to someone who wasn't me.

Anyone know how to go about getting this kind of counselling? State or private? Expensive (gulp)?

OP posts:
Report
tantrumqueensmum · 01/12/2013 19:56

And ElephantsandMiasmas - yes, I think she does feel like the 'Horrid Henry' to dd2's 'Perfect Peter' (hate those books for that reason!). You're right that teens are under lots of pressures, not all of which we faced, and I should try to be more sympathetic.

OP posts:
Report
tantrumqueensmum · 01/12/2013 19:53

Sadly, what some of you suggested re 'bonding' time with my dd wouldn't work, I don't think, as she has v little interest in hanging out with me or any member of her family. :( She moans bitterly at having to go on any family holidays, have any family time :( - it is hard when we remember how desperate she used to be to go on family trips, play games etc but now she just rolls her eyes.

I don't think she's putting it on or sulking - I think she genuinely desperately wants her own space and finds spending time with younger siblings 'childish' and 'boring'. I did try mother-daughter bonding on holiday this summer and she was uncommunicative and hostile. But maybe I'll give it another go and see if any more success...

OP posts:
Report
tantrumqueensmum · 01/12/2013 19:42

OhMerGerd, hoochycoo and ElephantsAndMiasmas - thank you for such great posts and interesting to see different perspectives.

I suppose I'm trying to strike a balance between both approaches, control and freedom/encouraging her to find her path. But safety has to come first for me. I've been talking to her about trying to find a win-win solution, where she gets her freedom and I get a knowledge she is safe - not quite sure what form that will take, but today let her message friends about homework in front of me and she was able to look at messages as her phone downloaded them which worked quite well as a teeny first step towards re-introducing phone use - think part of the issue is she wants her phone access because of fear of missing out on what her friends are up to as much as to message others - I'm happy for her to read (as what her friends write is fine!) just not post except monitored, until I've learnt to trust her a bit more.

hoooochycoo - LOVED your idea of getting her to read/write about feminist tracts in exchange for phone time. Grin Absolutely wicked. But achieves beautifully a link between use of phone and understanding of why one shouldn't sext. She currently rolls her eyes when I mention feminism (As she does when I mention MN Grin .) Also interesting suggestions of female artists to listen to - she claims to only like male indie stars eg Arctic Monkeys etc (yawn) so a bit of feminist attitude would make a nice change.

OP posts:
Report
hooochycoo · 30/11/2013 15:07

I know I've seen news reports like that over the years and have felt like someone walked over my grave. I wonder if he knew she was fourteen or if she told him she was older? It's hard for me to say I think it's not the bloke's fault as I don't make a habit of judging everything by my own experience, and maybe as said up thread I'm unusual. But personally I could have been that girl and would have been screaming at everyone that it had been my choice!

Report
SirChenjin · 30/11/2013 14:18

I have a 16 year old and a 14 year old. Nope, text convos about anal lube at 13 and 11 is not appropriate - it really, really isn't.

YANBU.

Report
ThanSheSaid · 30/11/2013 14:15
Report
cjel · 30/11/2013 12:14

x

Report
hooochycoo · 30/11/2013 11:55

Because they were good! :-) honestly one of my favourite times of my life! The only thing bad about them was having to fight my mother for the freedom and respect I wanted! The only thing I regret was hurting her! Honestly. And I'm feeling passionate about it as this thread has got me thinking about it again! Anyway, have some flowers too! Thanks

Report
cjel · 30/11/2013 11:49

I too apologise, I don't think you are sad, only that its sad if 'a 13 year old' misses out on that stage of her life!!(still think you could look at why you are so' passionate' about being patronised and your teens being good!!!!)Grin OK OK I'm going now Flowers hooochy

Report
hooochycoo · 30/11/2013 11:44

Fair enough, apologies if you find I've been defensive! I didn't mean you to think that, the same way you didn't mean for me to find you patronising. I guess I didn't like you calling my life experience "sad" and got a bit passionate! Anyway, hopefully all these perspectives are useful for the OP. no sense in arguing! Cheers

Report
hooochycoo · 30/11/2013 11:40

I have no "residual issues" and also no need to argue with you about it as I still find you patronising) You maybe right about me not being the majority, and personally i take that as a compliment. Everyone is different!

Good luck OP! X

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

cjel · 30/11/2013 11:35

I never disrespected it you are the one getting defensive!

Report
hooochycoo · 30/11/2013 11:33

And yes, I've said the OP should respect and inspire her daughter, which could be construed as guiding. I haven't told her to abandon her to anal sex hell!

What ohmawged described might have been appropriate for her and her daughter, but going to my mum's work and having pamper sessions would have utterly killed me. Everyone is different. Just giving some different perspective. I'm not saying anyone else's experience isn't valid. So please have respect for mine!

Report
cjel · 30/11/2013 11:29

I am not close minded and you clearly still have some touchy feelings about your childhood. I have enormous experience with 13 year olds and assure you that the vast majority prefer to be parented differently to you. Your last post confirms to me that there some residual issues for you if you read my post as patronising. My post started with the enquiry 'surely' and was merely asking a question. I then went on to say that you missed out on age appropriate activities as a 13 year old , which you did. It wasn't patronising or a criticism but as you say a perspective. Not all 13 year olds are the same but nor are all babies and they have milk and nappies. There are certain things for certain times of life and 13 is not a time for anal sex and lube.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.