FFS
Guardian aticle today from Ruth Hunt, chief executive of Stonewall.
Some believe that if people could self-declare their gender without the bureaucracy and paperwork, men will simply say “I am a woman” in order to access female-only spaces to abuse women. We all should be concerned about male violence, and we should all be concerned about preventing it and responding to it when it happens
But granting trans people equality will not make women any less safe. We live in a society where, unfortunately, women’s safety isn’t guaranteed. But trans people are not to blame for this, and often they are at risk themselves
So, basically she's saying women are silly to concern ourselves with an increased threat from male violence, as we're not safe anyway?
Domestic violence and rape crisis centres are concerned primarily with supporting the victims of male violence, and they will always find an appropriate service for anybody who arrives at their door, including trans men and women. They have been doing it for years without asking trans people to show their certificate. They know how to balance the complex needs with sensitivity and professionalism, although it’s clear that trans (and LGB) people require more direct services designed for them, such as the specialist LGBT service that sits alongside a women’s aid centre in Birmingham.
Oh and women and transwomen are not different. Except when they are because transwomen need special services. But not women.
No mention of issues like women not being able to object to a be-penised rape counsellor or an AGP in their group meeting.
Women and trans people both exist in a world where they are prevented from accessing true equality because of their gender. We must not be divided by arguments that undermine the equality we so desperately need and deserve.
And that's just minimising, patronising bullshit.
Stop whining, women, do as they say now.
AIBU or has she totally deliberately missed the point?
Please or to access all these features
Please
or
to access all these features
Feminism: Sex and gender discussions
Stonewall really are throwing women udner the bus aren't they [sad]
42 replies
tallstork · 24/10/2017 22:10
OP posts:
Please create an account
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.