Advanced search

Exam grade guidance finally released

(106 Posts)
noblegiraffe Fri 03-Apr-20 11:35:48

Looks sensible. A rank order required within grades so that the can moderate up or down as required.

OP’s posts: |
Piggywaspushed Fri 03-Apr-20 11:45:06

It does look sensible.

As I have mentioned to you before rank ordering students within grades in English and English literature in schools with mega huge year groups (can anyone beat my 420!) will not be fun...

Kazzyhoward Fri 03-Apr-20 11:49:09

Unless I've missed it, I can't see anything where they take into account the GCSE results for students taking A levels - surely that's pretty important?

Piggywaspushed Fri 03-Apr-20 11:54:21

I guess that comes under prior attainment?

Some A Level subjects don't have a GCSE which happens before it.

noblegiraffe Fri 03-Apr-20 12:15:25

They tend to use GCSE point score over 8 subjects, not the grade in that particular subject. Just like at KS2 the English result affects GCSE maths predictions.

OP’s posts: |
hamstersarse Fri 03-Apr-20 12:18:30

It's really hard for A Level students to know which Uni offer to accept

My DS was going to go for a A*AA course and he is a 'pull it out of the bag for exams' type, always has been. But it does mean his classwork is not A*AA, so is there any point in him accepting the offer he was going to go for and should he just go for a lower offer somewhere?

FlowerAndBloom Fri 03-Apr-20 12:40:19

Teachers know which kids have the potential to 'pull it out of the bag' so don't worry about that. All students will have improved in this final run up with help and guidance from their teachers. This is taken into account. Students who have never 'pulled it out of the bag' over 7 years of learning however, are unlikely to get the benefit of the doubt

StationView Fri 03-Apr-20 12:44:16

Does anyone else find this situation deeply, deeply ironic given that Gove removed coursework from most subjects as teacher assessment couldn't be trusted grin ?

Piggywaspushed Fri 03-Apr-20 12:46:06

That would be to produce a target grade, though noble : of course, prior GCSE attainment ina relevant subject affects performance. My entire A Level class (year 12) has target grade of A* - A (and one B!). The ones who got grade 8 or 9 in English Lit and/or film, are far more likely to actually get the A* at A Level so I would definitely take that sort of thing into account.

Kazzyhoward Fri 03-Apr-20 12:47:46

Does anyone else find this situation deeply, deeply ironic given that Gove removed coursework from most subjects as teacher assessment couldn't be trusted

How is it different from hospital consultants insisting on dragging you in and making you wait for little more than "hand shake introductory sessions" and then after tests etc., another session just to tell you a simple result. When it could all have been done by letter or phone.

Or how our local GP surgery used to insist on me having regular blood tests before giving me repeat prescriptions and now they don't care anymore and issue them anyway. Or the way GPs can suddenly deal with everything by a phone call when for decades they've been saying that having face to face consultations was essential!

Different times, different conditions. None of it is ideal, but needs must. When there is no alternative, compromises have to be made.

Piggywaspushed Fri 03-Apr-20 12:50:36

station all I can say is that if Gove were still education secretary I think different processes would be applied. He did not trust us even one little bit.

noblegiraffe Fri 03-Apr-20 12:53:05

Piggy I don’t think the DfE will be looking at individual gcse grades for individual students. They’ll be using them to judge the relative strength of a cohort.

Small sample sizes will be really dodgy here.

OP’s posts: |
noblegiraffe Fri 03-Apr-20 12:53:29

Gove was right about coursework, tbf.

OP’s posts: |
Piggywaspushed Fri 03-Apr-20 12:54:23

I don't think so either but I think it is evidence that we as teachers could consider as prior attainment, is what I mean.

StationView Fri 03-Apr-20 12:58:00

Kazzy, I don't understand what your point is. Mine was that the Conservatives, who decided they didn't trust teachers at all (see Piggy's message) now have to rely almost completely on teacher judgement.

Piggy I had to turn the press briefing off the other day when Gove headed it up. I had a almost uncontrollable urge to punch the radio angry

Shadowboy Fri 03-Apr-20 13:12:59

I mentioned the rank order when they first cancelled the exams and I was well and truly poo-pooed. Well I was right.

Kazzyhoward Fri 03-Apr-20 13:43:17

Mine was that the Conservatives, who decided they didn't trust teachers at all (see Piggy's message) now have to rely almost completely on teacher judgement.

What choice do they have? In a perfect world, not sensible, but compromises have to be made and there is nothing else to base results on other than teacher assessment etc. Needs must and all that.

Piggywaspushed Fri 03-Apr-20 13:43:41

As someone who still teaches coursework, I really don't think Gove was right!!

Standrewsschool Fri 03-Apr-20 13:49:19

@kazzyhoward - why would they use gCSE results for a-levels?

My DS (a-level) noticed that coursework will not have the same stays as before, and will only be used as guidance. Eg. History, was worth 25% (?) of the Marks. Now, it will only be used as an indicator of general ability.

He also said that he’s curious as to what the exam questions would have been, and how he would have done, although also relieved at not doing exams!

Standrewsschool Fri 03-Apr-20 13:49:38

Status, not stays.

noblegiraffe Fri 03-Apr-20 13:52:23

Piggy Maths coursework was a farce. Such a farce that Labour got rid of it before Gove even got in!

OP’s posts: |
Piggywaspushed Fri 03-Apr-20 13:55:32

I know it was : but Gove then applied an anti coursework diktat to subjects that positively were enhanced by it.

Sunnyhopefulness Fri 03-Apr-20 14:00:09

I’m curious about a level resits and how that’s going to pan out ... sisters son got a D First time round , but was predicted an A previously ( and for this year ) and needs an A ... family view was that getting the A was going to be a stretch ...

bojo7 Fri 03-Apr-20 14:00:33

I was surprised to see that for students who choose to sit an exam in the future:
"If they choose to do this, both grades will stand."

Really? Currently if you have a remark, you have to accept that grades can go down as well as up.

noblegiraffe Fri 03-Apr-20 14:01:38

It’s not a remark, Bojo. Currently if you sit a qualification again and get a lower mark, you can use the previous higher grade.

OP’s posts: |

Join the discussion

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

Join Mumsnet

Already have a Mumsnet account? Log in