Do these boots look any better than my witchy ones? (Pics)

[Marthame]

Do these look any better to wear with a skirt? Both will be going back if not!

[HolgerDanske]

No link or pic 🙂

[Marthame]

Whoops, here they are, 2 different boots

[Teacakequeen]

I can't see very well but I know I prefer the ones on the left

[321zerobaby]

I prefer the ones on the left (so your right foot).

[lizabes]

I agree the shorter one on the left is much nicer

[MikeUniformMike]

The ones on the left. The others are for under (bootleg) trousers.

[Marthame]

This is telling, I clearly have zero idea as I thought you'd say the higher one. Good job I asked!

[ScreamingValenta]

The shorter ones look best.

[MikeUniformMike]

The higher ones have a block heel which is more fashionable.

[Marthame]

Does this picture help?
Both are dune, Olga & pascalle

[MikeUniformMike]

It's still a bit dark, but I prefer the shorter one.

[ChishandFips33]

Our left, your right - much better

[ScreamingValenta]

As a boot, I prefer the taller one but with tights, the other one looks better.

[verite]

Lower one with a skirt.

[ILostItInTheEarlyNineties]

I like the shorter ones. Not seeing any resemblance to witch at all You have great ankles, May as well show them off!

[Shadow1986]

Definitely shorter ones - they’re nice.

[Deux]

You have a nicely turned ankle, as they say.

The shorter ones look better and make your legs look longer than the other ones.

[baublesnbubbles]

Shorter ones

[RavenWings]

Shorter ones for sure.

[Bluntness100]

I lightened the pics as they were too hard to see.

[Marthame]

Thank god for you lot! I'm keeping the shorter ones in that case

[ILostItInTheEarlyNineties]

Great choice Martha. I quite fancy them myself.