Talk

Advanced search

How expensive was underfloor heating compared to radiators...

(20 Posts)
TDiddy Sun 02-Aug-09 08:59:08

Planning wooden floors and decided to replace pipes whilst we are down there. Planning to replace radiators with old style radiators but wondering about underfloor central heating. Has anyone done this? Was it expensive and are you happy with it?

thanks

Katymac Sun 02-Aug-09 09:35:09

Are you talking wet or dry?

Dry is expensive to fit & fairly expensive to run

Wet is more expensive to fit & fairly cheap to run

Although tbh when I did my research (a while ago) neither were recommended with wooden floors as wood is not a good conductor of heat

TDiddy Sun 02-Aug-09 09:50:29

*Katymac- I am going for wet. I did dry electric in previous house and it was very expensive to run and i regretted it.

Just found this debate about pros and cons.

Katymac Sun 02-Aug-09 10:08:09

Have a look on the Greenbuilding forum - I think there is lots of stuff on there about it

It's the efficiency that would worry me - combined with the thinness of wood needed t make it efficient iyswim

TDiddy Sun 02-Aug-09 11:20:56

thanks Katymac will do so. I have the same worry and now tending to radiators with radiator covers which look nice and help heating efficiency, apparently. Was thinking of Period radiators but I think that I might tire of them and that they might be too fussy?

TDiddy Sun 02-Aug-09 14:26:53

Another good critique

Pannacotta Sun 02-Aug-09 22:36:41

My plumber recommended cast iron radiators (we have a big, cold house with tall ceilings) but they are very ££ to buy, even reclaimed ones.

I dont understand how rad covers can help with efficiency though, surely they block the heat from getting into the room?

Cataline Sun 02-Aug-09 22:39:17

Glad you are aware of the running cost of dry UFH grin - we weren't - used it for 2 months solid then got electricity bill and have never used it since!!! blush grin

TDiddy Sun 02-Aug-09 22:42:53

I am guessing that the impact isn't that big but...you know that radiators are most efficient if located at coldest part of the room, usually external wall/under window. Well here is the blurb........ cold air is drawn into the base of the cover at floor level. Natural convection then forces the air through the cover exiting through the grilles. The top shelf of the Radiator Cover helps redirect the heated air back into the room at the correct height level......

hmmm

TDiddy Sun 02-Aug-09 22:47:47

this one has impressive diagrams explaining

We will go for radiator covers with big long radiators especially under big bay windows though.

TDiddy Sun 02-Aug-09 22:50:01

Cataline- some happened here. It was the loviest, warmest three months spent in our kitchen. It was really really high bill. Wouldn't have felt so bad if we had made more use of that warm floor smile wink

Pannacotta Mon 03-Aug-09 09:03:04

WOuldnt it be easier to simply put a shelf above the radiator?
Am not that convinced about the efficiency of rad covers.

TDiddy Mon 03-Aug-09 19:38:02

Panna- plumber today was saying that the same about not being convinced about radiator covers' efficiency. Shelves above the radiator would probably not help with sucking with the ideal convection flow as described but could serve useful ornamental purpose. Where did you get your period radiators if you don't mind me asking?

thx

Pannacotta Tue 04-Aug-09 09:29:31

TDiddy I bought them off our old plumber (he was moving abroad) but he got them from reclamation yeards.
They are cast iron, really heavy and look great - sitting in our garage until we get round to replumbing the house!

Re the shelf above the radiator I was thinking that this would help push heat into the room rather than up into the ceiling which is was usually happens I think.

missingtheaction Tue 04-Aug-09 09:53:24

TDiddy, if I had the chance to install wet underfloor heating instead of radiators I would jump at it. IME it was so much cheaper to run than radiators, and much nicer heat.

You can get new 'old' radiators from places like Bisque - i would imagine they are more efficient than reclaimed ones but 1000 x the price!

TDiddy Tue 04-Aug-09 11:13:52

Thanks. But we are being told that wood is such a good insulator that we are going against the grain if we did underfloor heating? Have you "experienced it" with wood or know anyone who has undefloor heating and wood? The carpets in our house have to go!

fanjolina Tue 04-Aug-09 11:15:19

I bhave used this site before fir purchasing radiators. They were very good. I bught modern ones, but the page I have linked you to is cast iron old sty;e ones. Very reasonably priced.

TDiddy Tue 04-Aug-09 11:18:08

fanjolina many thanks. Will have a look when i get back from work tonight.

fanjolina Tue 04-Aug-09 11:36:46

Excuse crap typing - am bf'ing and typing with two left fingers!

TDiddy Tue 04-Aug-09 12:53:47

Not at all. Thanks for going to the trouble. I am impressed that you are type and bf!

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now