My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Join our Sleep forum for tips on creating a sleep routine for your baby or toddler.

Sleep

What worked for us. Hope this helps.

870 replies

nectarina · 29/01/2012 21:03

This post is going to be massive - no apologies however.

So I've posted at least 5 queries about DD's sleep and read about 1 billion threads, because DD only napped for 30mins  in the day, would only BF to sleep (since a newborn I wanted to get out of the habit, but nothing else did it). She spent  the first 5 months in her cot, only for us to end up co-sleeping so we could get a bit of rest. She would BF every 2 hours at  least in the night, and by the end she'd wake every half hour before we went to bed. I knew I couldn't do CC/CIO, I'm not  strong enough even if I thought that was the right thing to do, but I thought that I would be forced to if things carried on  the way they were.

We read No Cry Sleep Solution, which is complicated and didn't work for us.

So a friend had tried a technique, that she recommended and I thought that it was too much of a leap for DD, but i kept  the email, and one evening I sort of snapped and decided that IT WAS TIME. DD was  8 1/2months. I don't know from  what age this technique is recommended, but I don't think I'd have wanted to do this earlier, as you still have to cope with  the baby crying. I knew DD was ready because now she quite clearly has two cries - one properly sad and scared, the  other a bit shouty and put on, so when doing this technique you know what's going on (but I'd like to add that I still  comforted DD when she was shouty - she's still trying to say something, but I deÞ nitely wouldn't pick her up and panic!)

 I'll paste her email to me, hoping she won't mind. We didn't do it in the ten days, as it was just a bit too much, but i wonder if the way we did it made things a bit complicated. So I recommend doing it as laid out.  

But now DD takes 20mins to fall asleep by herself (with one of us in her room) in her cot, in her room. and I do not feed at  all between 7pm and 7am. Dh goes in in the night and he gives her water in case she's thirsty but she's quite happy  without. It takes him no more than about 3mins to resettle her (unless ill).

After starting this at the beginning of January  she still wakes up once or twice a night but it doesn't affect me as I wear earplugs and DH goes in! ha ha ha! (I still hear  her and wake up, but I don't wake up fully and find it difFicult to go back to sleep) Do I need to tell you how I feel like a  different woman?

So here's the email -  

^"Ok, this is a plan thing that we first tried with dc1 when we got to the point where we knew something had to change. There seems to come a point where not only do you get tired of 'helping' your baby get to sleep, but whatever you do seems to work less and less - as if they know something has to change too! It takes a bit of work for about ten days or so but mostly the first couple of days you really put your back into it and then it gets easier. I remember vaguely doing it with dc1 and have just rediscovered it with Dc2 she is a bit of a firecracker so I was expecting trouble but babies love to learn something new, especially around this age and she only woke once last night despite having a cold, which is a HUGE improvement. Dc1 found this very easy and never shed a tear. Dc2 screamed 'TRAITOR!!' at me many times during the first night (she does that a lot), so I'm not saying that there won't be some crying because you will be doing something different to before but you don't have to leave her side and can reassure her as much as you need to, physically and verbally. 
The idea is that you are no longer going to help her go to sleep - in whatever way - if you rock her, feed her, jiggle her, whatever it is. You can be there and reassure her but it is no longer your job to MAKE her go to sleep. It is your job to support her whilst she does it herself. 
First of all, you know that thing that everyone says about having a bedtime routine (which I imagine you already have) is utterly true. By the time they are a toddler, the sound of a running bath is enough to set the bedtime clock going. When you choose to do this thing, it is really important to stick to your bedtime routine without fail for the ten days and it needs to be between 20 and 45 minutes long. Also, this plan also applies to naps, so you need to be able to be at home for naptimes - just until Dd has the thing established - ten days usually does it. Lastly, you are aiming for Dd to be in bed by 7ish in the evening and not much later. If you're like me you're knackered by about half four, so starting bedtime at a quarter past six is no trouble. You've probably done all that so on to the plan. I'll do bedtimes first and then naps. 

Day 1, 2 and 3 - Place a chair right next to the cot. Make it a comfortable chair, you may get to know it fairly well. Have a duvet, cushions, iphone, book to hand. Do your bedtime routine and put Dd in the cot awake. She may well not know what to do next and try all sorts of things. If she stands up you can gently pop her back down again but only a few times - if she insists on standing for a bit then let her - it may just be one of those things she incorporates into her own burgeoning routine, and I daresay she is capable of getting back down again by now. You can pat the bed to let her know you want her to lie down. Sooner or later she is likely to sit down for a bit and eventually plop on to her front. She has to find her own way through this so she may try eating her blanket or playing with a toy before she lies down - that's up to her. If she cries, you can pat her and speak to her. As long as you remember that your patting and comforting is not there to get her to sleep, just to help her calm down in this new and confusing situation so as soon as she starts to settle, lighten your touch with a view to taking your hand off her, and stop speaking. She may go back and forth a bit needing you to touch and speak to her a few more times, but each time lessen your touch when she has settled. Stay there until she has fallen fast asleep and creep out. This bit can take ten minutes for some babies, but most fall asleep after 45 minutes. Two hours is the longest on record! I expected Dc2 to be a two hour effort but no - 45 minutes almost exactly. As long as you know that it is going to take that long, you can get through it. When she wakes up in the night, you do exactly the same thing, each and every time. The first few times she wakes, she will probably yell for you, but as she gets the idea that she can drift back to sleep herself, she may just squeak and go back (sounds unlikely? I thought that too.) The idea is that as time goes on you can wait a tiny bit longer before you go in, to give her the opportunity to practise her new skill.

Days 4, 5 and 6 - move the chair a few feet away from the cot. Keep everything else the same except you are further away. Once you have had your bedtime cuddle and put her in the cot sit down. You can still go to her if she really needs you, and you can still speak to her but she may not need as much help by now. Again, wait until she is asleep before you leave. Repeat as often as necessary when she wakes although, again, leave it a few minutes before you go in.

Days 7, 8 and 9 - move the chair to the door or the other side of the room. Make sure she can still see you, but once you have settled her in her cot and gone to the chair try not to go to her unless she has got herself into a daft position and can't get out. By now she will start developing her own strategy to get to sleep, and you will be able to tell what stage she is at, because you've been watching it all the way through.

Day 10 - you have several choices. If you think things are going really well and baby can cope with you not being there  you can leave the room and see how she gets on. You can hover by the door out of sight and watch what happens, and  reassure her with your voice. If you feel apprehensive about it and think she needs longer you can try the Bustle -  instead of sitting down, tinker about in her room, cleaning up or folding washing or whatever. Or you can continue in the  chair.  The idea of the plan is ultimately for you to be able to plonk and go, but I quite like spending that extra time with DC so I  use a mixture of the bustle and the chair. For night wakings you now really have to give her the chance to go back on her  own. Wait ten minutes ( I know - such a long time!) before you go in.  I got up last night to Þ nd by the time I got to DC's  door, she'd already curled up again! That's the main brunt of it. Just bear in mind that the first couple of nights are the worst - she might wake more frequently,  but stick at it and you'll see an improvement. The other thing is that when they start sleeping longer in the night they get  up properly a bit too early in the morning - but this usually improves over a few weeks as they get the hang of sleeping.  I've kind of assumed that you are going to move her into her own room - there's no reason you can't start this as soon as  you move her in. If DC get ill and it disrupts her sleep, go back to whichever stage in the plan you think works best. You can sleep in her  room if you want to keep an eye on her, but don't bring her in with you.

Naps - Do the same for naps as you do at night times only you can't sit there for as long as it takes - give it an hour and if  she hasn't gone to sleep, get her up and feed her or do something different and try again a bit later. If she resists  napping like this twice in a day you can resort to taking her out in the buggy or something. just so she gets a bit of sleep  in the day. You are aiming at two solid naps a day by the way. If you've started this thing at bedtime the night before, the  nap thing is usually not a problem.  I can't think of anything else right now! By the way this is based on a Canadian lady's idea. I chose to use it because it  doesn't mean leaving a baby to cry. They learn to fall asleep without you intervening, although you might argue that your  presence is a sort of intervention, but before long you will find yourself saying goodnight and shutting the door, because  she'd not taking any notice of you anymore!" ^


So for us the First night it took 3 hours 10mins, which is why for nightwakings later on that night I just fed her instead of  sitting with her. Within the first few nights she woke LOADS less and then DH would go to her and he would just ask her  to put her head down and she would and go straight back to sleep. Needless to say that sort of thing just wouldn't  happen before. So if I remember rightly it was only after 4 or 5 nights that I stopped feeding her. The other thing we've  found a bit hard is waiting a few mins before going in to her when she wakes. We just give it one or two minutes more  than we'd usually do instead of waiting 10.  

DH would like to add that he thinks the important thing is to teach DC to put their head down and close their eyes - he  says' put your head down, put your head down, now close your eyes' and repeats it a bit like a mantra gently until DD  does, and then stops as soon as she does what he says. He says for our 9month old that after a week she knows what it  means and does what he suggests! He says that this is useful in the night and that's all he needs to do to get her to go back to sleep.

For the first night I recommend a large glass of wine that you take in with you. For the second night, have  the bottle waiting for you on the table in the lounge. Also on the first night we both did it together for a bit of moral  support and took it in turns but I'm assuming that none of you is as much as a wimp as I am.

I hope this isn't too much of a mess, my friend's writing is very clear, and mine is all over the shop. I'm just a bit  enthusiastic about how its gone. I hope this is of use to someone.

OP posts:
Report
SevenSwifty · 04/08/2023 12:24

I should add he doesn't wake so upset if I'm co-sleeping but still wakes and roots around for me, cries a little until he is fed 90% of the time.

Report
SevenSwifty · 04/08/2023 12:21

I know this an old thread but is basically the method a sleep consultant has suggested to us and I've tried to read it all but wondered if there was any more up to date experiences, particularly those who maybe tried it before. My baby is 10.5 months and currently goes to sleep in his cot after very consistent bedtime routine with a pat/cuddle (not fed) but then wakes every 2-3 hours and we co-sleep and I bf back to sleep. He wakes up hysterically crying, there is no escalation. It's 100 screaming blue murder, until he is fed. Which I totally understand is for comfort but I am thoroughly exhausted with a lm older toddler as well.

Did anyone try it with a very sensitive inconsolable baby re sleep? He is otherwise happy and content in the day.

Report
JustAnotherUserinParadise · 16/01/2022 21:10

Sorry Just realised I disappeared ane never updated.
So we spent most of December doing this and it got to the point where we would put her down and sit on a chair but then I kind of backslid a bit and we eventually had to sit there patting and shushing for up to half an hour... and she'd still be up to feed several times.

So about 10 days ago I started night weaning her - I did this by picking an interval during which she didn't get fed - if she woke I'd pick her up and rock and shush back to sleep, then put her down and pat/shush until she went back to sleep. I started with 12-5 as the interval, and worked up to 11-7. Fewer night feeds was good as DH could help, but wasn't really reducing the wakings.

So we have now started controlled crying (on night 3). Night one it took 49 mins of crying and then she slept 11 hours straight! Night 2 (yesterday) 29 mins of crying, woke after 90 mins and did it again for 40 mins, then slept 9 hours straight. Tonight (night 3) DH put her down and she sort of shouted for about 30 seconds and then went to sleep. He didn't even get to the first timer.

I was reluctant to do "proper" sleep training, but being back at work now I just realised I need more sleep. It's a shame the gradual retreat didn't fully work, and that was probably our fault really.
I know it's early days but the controlled crying so far hasn't been as bad as I thought (mostly because I made DH do it...). I'm glad I night weaned first though as it meant we knew she wasn't actually hungry.

Report
runoverhere · 13/12/2021 10:20

This has worked for me as an easier way to get ds to sleep at bedtime. He lays himself down and goes to sleep without crying.

It hasn’t worked for night time wake-ups (still every 1.5-2 hours) which require breastfeeding or rocking back to sleep.

I also can’t get it to work for naps. He gets so hysterical in the cot that I pick him up. He is currently napping on top of me.

Any ideas?

Report
runoverhere · 08/12/2021 18:55

@JustAnotherUserinParadise

Hi *@runoverhere* I am also trying this!
My DD was basically cosleeping in our bed a couple of weeks ago so I basically added a stage before the start where I moved into her room, and sidecar-ed her cot to the single bed in there and slept with her for a few nights. Then we were at my parents for a couple of nights, But last night I just read her a story, gave her a cuddle, put her down and turned the light out. She faffed about for a bit, whining and crawling around, then just plonked down (face down) and went to sleep! 11 minutes after light out!

Good to hear.

The rest of our night didn’t go so well and we had a lot of screaming before we caved and picked ds up for him to be asleep within seconds of me holding him.

Tonight is another night. He took 7 minutes to get down but I had to pick him up and sing to him for 30 seconds (at least I seem to have weaned him off rocking) and then put him down and rub his back for 20 seconds. He is overtired tonight after a day at nursery so I wasn’t expecting an easy night.
Report
JustAnotherUserinParadise · 08/12/2021 12:08

Hi @runoverhere I am also trying this!
My DD was basically cosleeping in our bed a couple of weeks ago so I basically added a stage before the start where I moved into her room, and sidecar-ed her cot to the single bed in there and slept with her for a few nights. Then we were at my parents for a couple of nights, But last night I just read her a story, gave her a cuddle, put her down and turned the light out. She faffed about for a bit, whining and crawling around, then just plonked down (face down) and went to sleep! 11 minutes after light out!

Report
runoverhere · 07/12/2021 19:45

I have just tried this. It took ds 17 minutes and I am gobsmacked. No matter how the rest of the night goes that was far easier than feeding him to sleep, having him wake up when I try to get him in the cot and rocking him back to sleep before trying for the cot again (and repeat hourly).

I am at the end of my tether after 10 months of broken sleep and boobs that are no longer effective at really knocking him out. His sleep has gotten worse and he has been waking hourly. So, I’m hoping this is the start of a better night.

Report
Giraffe888 · 18/02/2020 15:26

I’m thinking about trying to do some of this. My DS is 7 months and EBF. He wakes hourly just for a quick comfort feed (not for hunger just comfort/habit) but I’m back to work in April so need him to be sleeping longer!

Can anyone who’s done it offer any advice? I know he’s going to cry and be so distressed as I always pick him up to put on breast within a few minutes and if I don’t he really cries.

Report
MBM18 · 29/11/2019 12:23

@Faceache25 I’m in the same boat! I started this on Wednesday night and the first night it took her an hour to fall asleep. Last night and each nap since it’s only taken 10 minutes but she’s still waking in the night.
The first night she woke 6 times, last night it was 4. I’m hoping tonight is less.
We have co-slept since she was 3 months old (she’s 15 months now) and she’s had unlimited access to boob all night so I’m happy for the night feeds to fade out gradually as I feel her sleeping in her cot is a big change already.
My partner is going to try resettling her in the night over the weekend but I know it’s going to be hard as she just wants boob 🙈

Report
GWeatherwax · 27/11/2019 09:15

Aha. Right, here is a plan. Will start this tonight.

Report
Faceache25 · 24/11/2019 13:32

@Bagger288 how did it go last night? I've been trying gradual retreat for few days now, DS is falling asleep without too much trouble but hasn't made any difference to night wakings.

Report
Bagger288 · 23/11/2019 11:00

Oh my god it's a miracle.

Bathed him, nursed him, brushed teeth, read book, then put him in his cot awake but showing signs of sleepiness. He was happy for about 15 minutes faffing around and then started crying. I comforted him, spoke to him, tried to distract him, nothing worked. He was furious! Every time I tried to touch him he'd shove my hand away. Every soft toy I offered him he flung out of his cot. That made it so much easier - I could tell he was just frustrated and angry. If he'd been scared or sad and clingy I would've broken.

He was raging and crying (standing up) for about 1hr 30 mins in total. I tried to think of it like him being in the car seat when he was younger and used to scream blue murder - I could comfort, sing, talk, pat, offer food and water but at the end of the day he was in there to stay and just had to get used to it. I rubbed his back, talked, sang,even got the poor dog in to take his mind of things but he was outraged!

He drank water a couple of times, sitting down by himself, which again made me feel better - he wasn't so beside himself that he couldn't drink, whereas he has been before.

The third time he sat down to drink water he fell asleep sitting up. I just tipped him down on his side (a bit more grumbling) and then...

He slept for seven hours straight!!!!

This is the boy who hasn't slept longer for three hours at once in his entire life. It must be the first time he's ever joined up sleep cycles. Couldn't believe it. My tits were like cannonballs by the time he woke up (5am) so I did bring him in and let him nurse. I couldn't believe it.

Wish me luck tonight - I'm wondering whether it'll work faster or if he'll resist even longer now he knows what's happening??!

Report
Bagger288 · 22/11/2019 15:28

Bumping this thread again after seeing it recommended elsewhere. Am going to try it tonight with my DS (14 months old). Keep your fingers crossed for me. Will report back!

Report
onetwofive · 02/07/2019 11:40

Anyone done this and found it works well at night but terribly for naps?

Report
TeaPleaseBob · 24/03/2019 10:05

I’ve just started this method with my daughter who’s 9.5 months. I’ve always fed her to sleep but I’m returning to work in a month and won’t be around for bedtime days I’m working. Trying to get her happy to be put in cot and fall asleep herself so I can potter about and get my older daughter to bed.
Had a failed attempt to start on Friday night, I put her into cot drowsy and sat with her while she screamed at me and eventually got to sleep after 45 mins (felt longer so definitely good to keep not of how long it actually took!). Unfortunately my husband then went straight up to her and picked her up when she woke at 10pm- after 2 hours of crying I gave in and fed/ cuddled her to sleep as she was distraught.
Started properly last night with decision made not to feed her at all overnight and husband reminded not to pick her up but comfort in the cot. She took a bit longer at start of night, almost an hour and then woke up at 9pm and took 30 mins to settle. I was feeling optimistic but another wake up at 1.20am for an hour and a half almost broke me. Eventually she fell asleep sitting up in her cot and I had to lie her down and reassure her. There was quite a bit of knocking her head against cot Cooper82 which I found distressing but eventually she sat still. I’m hoping tonight she’ll lie herself down.
Woke up again at 6am and couldn’t be comforted back to sleep so I went out room for a minute then came back in happily, opened blinds and said good morning and we got up. She had a big feed and devoured her breakfast.
I’ve chickened out of doing naps as well as bedtime. I won’t feed her to sleep but have put her in buggy for morning nap and she’s been asleep about an hour and a half, I’ll wake her soon if she doesn’t wake so she can have decent afternoon nap too.

Report
cooper82 · 12/03/2019 08:04

Another update....we did get a spell of DD not waking. It lasted about 2-3 weeks.
Unfortunately, things have regressed...
DD will still go to bed no bother whatsoever, but when she wakes, she is completely inconsolable. Picking her up does nothing. She rolls around the cot, banging her head and has a blood curdling cry. Its like there is something up in the night. With DD being a pleasure all day and going to sleep at night with no drama, we are completely dumbstruck as to what can be up with her in the night.

Can anyone relate?

Report
cooper82 · 09/02/2019 19:46

I know I have posted a little in the past but haven't in a long time. I thought it might help with peoples current concerns.
My DD is now 19 months. Bedtimes are mostly still the same as I posted before, she knows its bedtime, sometimes she wants to jump out of our arms now to sleep. But we have never managed to leave the room before she is asleep. Whilst we haven't been able to leave the room, we have had a lot of DD sleeping through the night but then DD gets sick and things regress a little.

Right now, we are trying to put DD down and walk out the room. So far, its going so so, we do still have to go back in but its literally to tell her that its bedtime and she crashes back down and will eventually sleep.

The more frustrating thing is that she still wakes in the night, its usually once but when she does wake, DD will not go back to sleep unless you pick her up. This leads mum or dad being up with her for about 2 hours. I wish I could say it was just 15 mins but alas, its not the case. This has been going on for about 2 months and we have no idea what is upsetting DD but I guess we just have to ride it out I suppose.

Report
LoobeeLou · 25/01/2019 15:53

Thank you for bumping, I have been going crazy trying to find ideas for sleep training without crying!

DS is 6 months old on Monday, is this too early to start training? I can tell the difference between his cries (protest vs problem).

Also we are going on holiday on 2nd Feb, is it best to start training after then?

Thank you in advance for any advice.

Report
Jinglesplodge · 23/01/2019 21:47

Bumping this thread along because it gave me food for thought with DS1 who is now 4 (and sleeps brilliantly) and I'm now improvising on it to start helping DS2 to sleep independently.

He's 1 next week and has never ever approached sleeping through the night. He had bad reflux for months and I got used to feeding him to sleep and then holding him upright. As a result he has no idea how to lie down to sleep because he's never been asked to do it.

Last night he woke often and let me pat him back to sleep. This was cause for huge celebration: I know it's not how this method is meant to begin but for us it's a victory as he's used to being fed and rocked to sleep.

Over the next week or two I'll gradually dial back the help I give him but I'm overjoyed that after so long he has gone to sleep in his cot. This thread has great advice for people who are really uncomfortable with crying and sleep training.

Report
Socks99 · 18/10/2018 14:40

Ok thanks will try that

Report
newhousestress · 18/10/2018 14:20

@Socks99 you might want to try a kind of rapid return to him? Lie him down, give him a pat and a ssh and then sit on the chair. Keep doing it until he stays lying down. Then continue as per the OPs method. I would imagine the first night you'll have to do it lots, less so on subsequent nights hopefully.

Report
Socks99 · 17/10/2018 21:58

Hi

Anyone tried this with a baby who just stands and cries? I tried it today and I can't calm my little boy at all. Wondered if anyone had any success with this type of baby.

Thanks

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

MrsN022015 · 14/10/2018 20:14

Thank you I will be trying this

Report
NaiceHamPlease · 11/10/2018 14:13

@eatmycheese I think your youngest may be my boys twin..... 10 months here and no more than 2 hours consecutive sleep for me since he was 4 months. It's not fun is it?! Have you started? How are you getting on?

I started the gradual retreat with the first sleep of the night only, I'm so bloody exhausted I couldn't cope with anymore, I did previously try not to feed, just comfort DS on his second wake but he was absolutely hysterical. First two nights I was amazed, DS did 5hrs without waking, I then fed him to sleep and he went back into the cot for another couple of hours before coming in with me. This has now got shorter and shorter.... he'll sleep anywhere between 1hr and occasionally 3. The amount of time it's taking to get him to sleep can be between 15 and 60 mins, no pattern at all, I'm still sitting by the cot and lying him down, gently patting, although a lot less than I was. The only thing it has cured it his first 30min wake which he always did religiously.

We've had a huge step back in the last week or so as he's cut his top two teeth and been poorly, leaving him super clingy, and having to be fed to sleep. Naps have been really terrible to, 20 mins in cot unless I lie with him.... Hmm

I really want to carry on doing this as gently as possible for both our sakes, but I'm worried I'm just making him worse. After months of reflux, CMPA and terrible wind issues I'm always worried he wakes to feed and needs so much comfort with me as he's uncomfortable but I'm slowly losing my mind and my patience which is really upsetting me.

Any advice from anyone who's had success with a similarly delicate boy would be greatly appreciated....

@cooper82 did you just go for the whole night right away with your DD? did you still BF in the night? I don't think DS is eating nearly enough in the day for that but I'm thinking he's not hungry as he takes so much milk at night (I can't eat enough to keep weight on me...)

Report
Eatmycheese · 06/10/2018 09:40

I need to try this.
My youngest (three under five) is a chronic sleeper. He only naps in his buggy or on his grandma that’s it. Never the cot.
If we’re lucky he sleeps for a couple of hours in his cot after initially going in asleep and waking screaming half an hour later.
He’s mostly breast fed and almost 11 months old. He ends u in with me every night and I am getting desperate and worried as he now stands up in bed and despit the bed guard I fear he will fall out as he tries to climb it at random junctures during the night.

I’ve had - for almost a year now - no more than two hours of uninterrupted sleep apart from one night when I was away from him.
It is making feel hysterical and now I fully understand why sleep deprivation is a form of torture.

I’m going to read every bit of the OP post and see where it takes me.....

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.