My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Relationships

Inviting a Crossdresser on your Hen Night

601 replies

rachelmonday1 · 04/04/2014 16:08

I'm actually a guy that enjoys crossdressing and am very fortunate to have a number of female friends, one of whom is getting married and has invited me to join her friends on her Hen Night. I don't look too bad when I'm dressed as Rachel and often go out with the girls with no problems.

I'm happily married and my wife understands the "Rachel" side of me, but thinks it's odd that a girl would invite a crossdresser on her Hen Night.

Any views out there?

OP posts:
Report
rachelmonday1 · 09/04/2014 15:08

Well that question certainly developed into an epic!

Thankyou all for your points of view, opinions, questions and concerns. I never expected to provoke such debate, but have learned a lot and it's been good to see opinions from all sides.

For me, some replies have suggested that I was looking for some kind of approval for my actions, which is not the case. Some have also suggested that my wife had issues with me going, but again this is not the case and I was probably mistaken in posting this in the Relationships section. I had posted both of the above earlier, but it was quite early on, in what became a very, very long thread.

I have come to consider whether the term "cross-dresser" is even correct for me. It certainly seems true in terms of various definitions that can be found in general dictionaries, but maybe the use is changing.

As for me, probably one of my very first memories is, a child of 2 or3, being dressed up by my elder sister, in her clothes, and taken to one of her friends houses to play. I had no problem with it, but I seem to recall that my parents did when they found out! All through my child and through to the present day, "pretty" clothes have always appealed to me and I do feel different when I wear them....whether this is "femininity" or not, who knows? All that I can say is that such clothes do make me feel and act differently.

As for being accepted by the Hen as Richard or Rachel; I was dressed as Rachel when she invited me. She has never met me as Richard and I wanted to go as Rachel. I didn't asked whether she wanted me to go as Richard or Rachel and simply (and I think naturallly) assumed that it would be the latter. To this end, I even asked her if any of the other girls would have a problem and, if they did, I wouldn't need to know who, but I would decline and not deliberately spoil anyones evening. None of the 15 girls had a problem.

I'm neither trying to defend or decry anyones thoughts on this thread, as it has been very interesting in catching up of with the posts of the last few days. I can see the much broader issues being brought up by some, but can also see the culture of "live and let live". No surprise that I subscribe to the latter, however I do sincerely hold women in the highest esteem and the only part of this discussion is where this is doubted , ie: aping, demeaning etc. Nothing could be further from the truth.

As it turned out, my wife dropped me off, I had a fabulous night doing things that it's mainly girls that do, my wife picked me up and all concerned are happy.

Thankyou all for your contributions and I think a lot of people have given a lot of thought to this...even though it was only intended as a simple question.

xx

OP posts:
Report
YouAreMyRain · 08/04/2014 12:16

That's the problem when people don't read the thread. They assume that previous posters are wrong and they think they can swoop in at the last minute, scatter a few pearls of wisdom and put us all straight.

Report
Grennie · 08/04/2014 12:06

Yes if he would be welcomed as himself, there would have been no issue. Everyone would have just said YANBU to go on a hen night you have been invited to, have a good time.

Report
Fairenuff · 08/04/2014 10:54

Oh fuck off.

Nice. And who is that comment directed at? Posters who have expressed a different opinion to you Pasithea, or just feminists in general?

What have you actually got to add to the debate, apart from insults?

Why do people have to make a big thing about feminism etc. so bloody what.

Just change the word 'feminism' to 'racism' and you might understand why so many people challenge it.

Op. Be who you want on your night out , wear what you want on your night out. Be happy that you are accepted as whoever by friends and your wife.

Actually, if you read the thread you will see that OP has said he would not be welcome as himself. His so called 'friends' would not 'accept' him if he turned up as himself. They only invited him if he would put on a dress and act 'effeminate', order 'girlie' drinks and adopt 'girlie' affectations.

HTH

Report
Pasithea · 07/04/2014 23:53

My post was a general any night out whenever wherever post . Not specific to one night.

Report
LRDtheFeministDragon · 07/04/2014 23:42

Thanks for reassuring me. I am (slowly) reading through what I missed.

Report
YouAreMyRain · 07/04/2014 23:37

It wasn't about you LRD, it was about the ones posting today telling the OP to "have a great night" (which Rachel did last Friday iirc) etc and asking questions that have already been covered. Trans/cis hasn't been.

Report
LRDtheFeministDragon · 07/04/2014 23:31

tiggy - dunno, but single-sex ones are a bit old-fashioned IME. Not that they were ever a big tradition?

youare I'm sorry if I came across that way. I know I should have read more, but I saw the posts about definitions of 'trans' and 'cis' and wanted to make the point that not everyone who dislikes those terms is disliking them for the same reasons, or to the same effect. Just as it is possible to question the reinforcement of stereotypes of 'masculinity' and 'femininity' while seeing that some people cope best in this world by identifying with the sex they feel themselves to be.

Report
YouAreMyRain · 07/04/2014 22:58

It is a shame how this thread turned out. The OP started it wanting lots of people to tell him how great he looked as "Rachel".

Some did, others discussed the politics of cross dressing.

Then some people decided to ignore more than 500 previous posts and just pile in at the end with their opinion about a hen do that has already happened.

Report
Grennie · 07/04/2014 22:47

The Op is not transgender. The thread has deviated.

I personally think women and man is about our biological sex, and gender is a tool used to oppress and justify the oppression of women by men as a class.

Report
TiggyKBE · 07/04/2014 22:45

Are hen/stag night getting increasingly mixed nowadays? I've never been on either. As a man working with all women I always get left out of things like that.

Report
LRDtheFeministDragon · 07/04/2014 22:26

Forgive me, I've been steering clear of this thread, but I will say - grennie, I don't think it's that (for me, I may be a minority).

I think the issue for me is that some people are not sure they have a gender identity, and are not sure gender identities help here. There are plenty of people who would sooner see us not use terms like 'cis' and 'trans', yes, but plenty of those people would also rather that it came as a strange idea to divide people into groups as 'men' and 'women,' too.

The OP is not somone who wants to live as a woman, but someone who has a persona as 'rachel'. I think that is very different from someone who identifies as trans, perhaps?

Report
cardamomginger · 07/04/2014 22:24

Ah. OK. Yup. Makes sense. Thanks.

Report
Grennie · 07/04/2014 22:17

Cis means having your gender identity in line with your biological sex. It is assumes that everyone who is not transgender is happy with their gender identity. Lots of feminists are not happy with the gender identity of "woman" and are fighting against it.

It is a controversial term.

Report
Pasithea · 07/04/2014 22:12

Oh fuck off. Guy has very nicely been asked to go on a hen night by someone who appreciates him as her and does not care or mind. Why do people have to make a big thing about feminism etc. so bloody what.

Op. Be who you want on your night out , wear what you want on your night out. Be happy that you are accepted as whoever by friends and your wife. And that they are not bigoted or embarrassed to be seen with you. Live your life as you seem fit.

Congratulations on living your choice and having the guts to go through with it. You are a very lucky. Dude.

Report
kim147 · 07/04/2014 21:59

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

cardamomginger · 07/04/2014 21:54

Ah - just googled it in conjunction with transgender! Makes sense.

(If you just google cis on its own, you get the Construction Industry Scheme or Commonweath of Independent States!)

Report
cardamomginger · 07/04/2014 21:52

Thanks though Grin!

Report
cardamomginger · 07/04/2014 21:52

Kim - are you talking to me? If so, I still have absolutely no idea what it means!

Is it an acronym or abbreviation? Is it used to describe someone who maintains their identity in accordance with the gender they were born with (not factoring in intersex babies)? Or vice versa?

Your first comment suggests in may be derogatory in some way?

Report
kim147 · 07/04/2014 21:40

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

cardamomginger · 07/04/2014 21:35

What does cis mean?

Report
Offred · 07/04/2014 19:54

Could you be any more arrogant?

If you want to express a coherent view in a discussion rather than come across as making generalised attacks on women you have decided to group together for some reason then just read the thread before commenting... Simple...

Otherwise what you are really doing is saying "I haven't read the thread but I'm going to assume I know what has been said anyway because you're those feminists, and I know what they all think/say already" it makes you look ridiculous. Why would anyone would want to read your "contribution" when you're proud of being ignorant of what's on the thread and still insisting you have something worth adding!

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

YouAreMyRain · 07/04/2014 19:49

Oh I get it now! Onemorechap finds some of the points of view on this thread (that he hasn't read) confusing so he's randomly thrown in some other stuff he finds confusing as well. (Purely coincidental that they are issues linked to feminism and that this thread has been discussing sexism - silly me!)

In case we doubt his intellectual authority on ...erm...confusing stuff(?) he has linked to some other stuff what other people wrote.

He is sooo clever (even if he's wading in with irrelevant stuff, he likes us to sit up and take notice of his presence)

Report
OneMoreChap · 07/04/2014 19:01

i) where do I say anything that faintly resembles "where [you] are all going wrong with what you have written"
ii) bait? Nah, some confusion because views on PIV = rape seem to be equally hard to process as some of the views on trans issues - and particularly TERF (thank you) views on it.
iii) Offred I refer you to the reply given in Arkell and Pressdram

[Actually, FWIW, I pointed out I had all sorts of conflicts about this stuff, but then my views are worth what you paid for them]

Report
Offred · 07/04/2014 18:26

*read

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.