My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Get advice and support with infant feeding from other users here.

Infant feeding

Feeling criminalised for not wanting to BF

47 replies

RavioliOnToast · 22/01/2015 08:26

Hi all, first thread, not even sure if its in the right section. Anyway, here goes.

I'm 38+1 so D Day is looming, I've got all my bottles, steriliser and one tin of formula so far (incase it doesnt agree with her or whatever) so I am actively wanting to bottle feed. I have my reasons for this and while they are not reason enough for most, they're good enough for me. Mainly because I have DD and she will be 3 very soon, I am a SAHM and feel like this will limit all I am able to do with her aswell. I BF DD for a brief period, ended up with bleeding nipples and a blocked duct and I gave up. I stopped BFing with barely any perseverance. This I honestly regret, however, DD ended up being a very hungry baby, she was put onto extra hungry formula on recommendation of HV and if i'm honest, I had such a happy baby. Her feeds were clockwork, I knew how much she was drinking, when she would next wake etc it was a lot easier for us all. I was in an abusive relationship with DD dad also and I honestly feel like if it were not for DD I would not be still here, I was ground down so much, literally on the verge of a breakdown, I have my baby girl to thank for getting me through that, this reason is selfish but because of this I want to be able to spend as much quality time with her when the baby comes as possible, I dont want her to feel as left out as she may. I feel like if I can give My Mam or DH the bottle they can feed her while I spend a little time with DD.

Now for this baby, this baby is DH's first child (long story short, we worked together a few years ago, both in relationships, met back up with each other as friends when I split with DD dad and he had been split with long term ex for approx 8/9 months, we totally hit it off and now we're married :) lifes a funny old thing) anyway, as this is DH's first child, it is FIL's first biological grandchild, hes very paternal, when he and MIL divorced DH and his sister stayed with FIL etc. MIL is a cow tbf, but anyway i digress again, FIL is very defensive of the fact I should try to breastfeed, its BEST for his grandchild. Then you have the health visitors, who when I told them I wanted to bottle feed, looked so narked, like literally as though i'd pissed on her kids, then my MW is trying to push BFing aswell.

Why, oh why, can nobody accept the fact that I would really like to bottle feed, I knew exactly where I was when feeding DD, and it honestly worked for me, I don't feel like I bonded any less with her, she is a very happy 2 year old, tall, strong, active, absolutely beautiful and the HV tells me her speech rivals that of at least a 3 and a half y.o and while im not saying she wouldnt be the same if i did BF, i'm just saying formula feeding has done her no harm.

What I really want to know is are my reasons valid enough for not wanting to? Should i really even care what other people think?

More of a rant than anything but if you reply, Thankyou!

OP posts:
Report
ThinkIveBeenHacked · 29/01/2015 18:39

First step - get DP to tell FIL to back off

That doesnt work? Step two - "no breasts, no opion" said repeatedly every time he brings it up.

I FF. I hold no truck with interfering busybodies who try and tell me what is best for me and mine.

Report
Lunastarfish · 29/01/2015 18:38

It's your baby and your boobs. If you don't want to bf then you don't have to.

I do want to bf but I did find it a bit weird at my appointment this week when the midwife was going on and on about why 'breast is best' - she was preaching to the converted! But if I had decided not to bf, she would have completely pissed me off

Report
MoominKoalaAndMiniMoom · 29/01/2015 18:36

Good luck OP. I breastfed for two days, then FF from then on. DD is an incredibly healthy 9 month old, despite having been in nursery for 5 months, she's had one cough and cold, and one 24 hour bug. No bronchiolitis, nothing of that sort. And our bond is incredible, she is incredibly close to me and to DP.

I don't think I'll breastfeed future DCs beyond the second day. I prefer FF.

Report
Trooperslane · 29/01/2015 18:33

Just feed your baby.

I don't get how it's anyone else's business, even a dgf.

Report
RavioliOnToast · 29/01/2015 18:31

it came up in conversation when we were talking about the hv appt and the way she had reached when Id said I wanted to ff.

OP posts:
Report
Mammanat222 · 29/01/2015 17:44

What the actual fuck does it have to do with your FIL?

Sorry but why has this even been discussed? If my FIL asked me how I planned to feed my baby once I'd picked my jaw up off of the floor I'd ask him what business it is of his.

The issue isn't how you plan to feed your baby but why other people are being involved in your decision.

Report
Aherdofmims · 28/01/2015 20:42

There really is nothing wrong with formula in a country with a clean water supply.

And if you can afford it I suppose.

There are many upsides to ff such as knowing how much baby is getting, establishing a routine, guaranteed supply, others can feed the baby for you giving you time for other things (and dh or relatives time with the baby).

They may get more colds as a baby. And you have to make sure you feed them in a cuddly way rather than at arm's length (not suggesting you would do this!) but they are the two main things IMO.

Report
noreplacementsfound · 27/01/2015 19:11

I totally beat myself up about not BFing DS1. Tried and failed. Next time I won't give it a second thought.

commonhealth.wbur.org/2014/02/sibling-study-finds-no-long-term-breastfeeding-benefits-for-kids

You may find this an interesting read.

Report
girliefriend · 27/01/2015 18:17

It is your body and your choice, however you may want to keep an open mind and feel differently once baby is here. It sounds like you are in a happier place now to when your dd was born.

Report
RavioliOnToast · 27/01/2015 18:10

Thanks for all the replies, I know I shouldn't care but I still felt like someone should tell me it was okay to ff. so I thank you all for that! :D now it's just a waiting game. 8 days until Due Date and counting!

OP posts:
Report
hawaiibaby · 26/01/2015 14:32

TOTALLY your decision and FWIW I completely see where you're coming from. And that's not me as a FF mum, BF worked for us but I just don't get the big knicker twist thing with people being so nosey and judgmental. There is nothing wrong with formula and in the grand scheme of all the massive things you do to parent a child, how you feed them initially is not that big a deal. They are being fed - that's the main thing.

I wrote this if it's any help - I hope it made a small difference to judgey judge peeps, though who knows? sometimes people are determined to be right, regardless of other people's situations and feelings. It's your body Flowers

bigtroubleinlittlenappies.com/2014/06/15/feed-and-let-feed/

Report
CanISayOfHerFace · 25/01/2015 22:15

I'm the poster getting the negative comments from friends re breastfeeding.

Just wanted to add that midwives and health visitors put a lot of emphasis on breastfeeding before my baby was born and in the hospital. However at weigh in when my DS hadn't put on much weight at about 18 weeks (despite being in the 90 something centile for height and 70 something centile for weight) I was advised to give him baby rice and formula. No matter that he couldn't sit up, just pop him in his car seat she said! I was also advised to express some milk and give it in a bottle although I still don't know how this was supposed to help.

Anyway, what I'm trying to say is, sven if you think you're doing everything as they advise they can be quick to move the goalposts rather than support you. Do what you think is best for you, baby and your family.

People will have an opinion no matter what you do and you may need to develop a thicker skin. And if you work out how to do that please let me know! Smile

Report
Sunflower1985 · 23/01/2015 15:21

It seemed to me the window of time for which people (MWs, HVs etc) gave a damn was very small. I remember in hospital the lady opposite me had to fight for every bottle of formula, but once your home, it's your lives and they're not breathing down your neck any more. If only the same was true of family.

Report
Cupcakes123 · 23/01/2015 09:08

I didn't even attempt BF-ing and I have a perfectly healthy and happy 23 week old gorgeous son
Do I feel guilty? No Wink

Congratulations! And remember to take some of the pre made bottles with teats to the hospital with you. If you choose to bottle feed, some hospitals won't (mine didn't) provide milk

Report
tiktok · 23/01/2015 09:00

I get you, Starlight :)

Report
StarlightMcKenzee · 22/01/2015 23:54

Sorry tiktok, I was just making a leap from overall data and applying it to all professions. I don't think there are enough exclusively breastfed babies that would enable either profession to claim the majority of theirs were.

Report
tiktok · 22/01/2015 22:17

I imagine that's true Starlight seeing as how the majority of uk women use formula at some stage but I have not seen any stats that look at hvs and midwives specifically. Where did you see this?

Report
squizita · 22/01/2015 20:08

YY Ishallcallyousquishy ... a loved, fed, clean, cared for baby (as most are) is what matters. Smile

Report
StarlightMcKenzee · 22/01/2015 20:06

'Health visitors and midwives have a professional obligation to offer a discussion on feeding options with you'

Statistics show that the majority of health visitors and midwives bottle-feed their babies.

Report
StarlightMcKenzee · 22/01/2015 20:04

OP. It is your body. End of.

However, some of the benefits you think of for formula feeding won't necessarily be benefits this time around.

For me, breastfeeding meant I was able to spend more time with my older children because it was so efficient. No washing, sterilising or preparing bottles, and the nature of it (longer) meant we all got more peace from the demands of the baby.

For me (and I'm not you and not suggesting you should be me) breastfeeding made family time more doable.

Report
IShallCallYouSquishy · 22/01/2015 19:23

You're planning on feeding your baby right? Yes? Ok then, that's all that matters. Who cares if the milk comes from a breast or bottle?

Report
MagpieCursedTea · 22/01/2015 19:21

I still bf my 15 month old and I'm sure people judge me for that. However I'm confident that it's what's best for both of us. It was bloody hard to start with and I got a lot of negativity, people telling me I should give up etc but breastfeeding is very important to me so I stuck with it, I'm glad I did as it was easier in the long run.

If you're confident that you're making the best choice for you and your family, its really no one else's business. As a mother, I'm sure you know that we get judged for every choice we make. It's all about being confident in your choices and keeping answers short and sweet if people feel the need to interrogate about them.

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

seaoflove · 22/01/2015 19:16

I understand.

After a truly horrific experience trying to breastfeed my DD (basically I starved and dehydrated her for five solid days) I am pregnant again and thrust back into the world of infant feeding. I can't say I'd missed it.

I just cannot envisage things being any different this time around, and so to save my sanity, and avoid endangering the health of my baby from the start, I'll be opting for formula from the start.

Haven't had much contact with HCPs so far this pregnancy (am 23 weeks) but am already feeling a bit weary about having to justify myself.

Report
Brandysnapper · 22/01/2015 19:15

Feeling got at is not the same as being criminalised surely!
Agree with other posters, they'll get at you for something if not your feeding choices.

Report
CoolCat2014 · 22/01/2015 19:09

Do what makes you & your baby happy. If that's bottle feeding, great!

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.