Which girl's name?

[helppickaname]

Penelope, Robyn or Elise?

Current top 3. Siblings are Noah, Sophia & Chloe (I know the all have O in them but that's coincidence!). Will be Luca if it's a boy.

Would Robyn get called Rob/Robbie? I'd hate that! Would Elise become Ellie?

Also toyed with Isabelle (which I adore but HATE izzie), Lara, Poppy, Amaya, Posy and Alyssa/Alessia.

[goldenrachita]

They are all nice but I think Elise is the prettiest and also the best match for the other names. Penelope is too grand/a mouthful to fit with the other shorter names. I like Robyn but only for a Christmas baby.

[Pemba]

Elise is much the prettiest of your top three. Lara or Isabelle are gorgeous and Alyssa is pretty too.

[BuntyFigglesworthSpiffington]

I really like Robyn and Elise but think that Penelope is quite ugly. Although Penny is lovely.

[JennyPocket]

Also, love Alice as some PP has said.

[JennyPocket]

Penelope.

Robyn is (I'm really really sorry) ugly sounding and not a pretty name to read either. it's a bit stumpy, quite masculine and the nn would be - Rob or Robbie, probably.

Not keen on Poppy, I think it's too "of the moment' - it'll be tomorrow's Jenny or Rachel or Karen.

[JudgeJudySheidlin]

Another vote for Alice. Elise would be my choice from your list. Gone right off Robyn & never liked Penelope; no idea why so many people love it. Each to their own I suppose?

[cmxx]

Elise is the best, beautiful, classic, yet simple :) there's also the Elyse spelling, or the slightly spunkier Eliza.

[happystory]

Robyn, I love it

[HitsAndMrs]

I have a Robyn in the family. She's always Robyn or bobs.

[everythingis]

I love Penelope. A very close family friend has a child called Elise. It's very classy and not that common IMO. Penelope is quirky and elegant.
I am a bit meh about Robyn in comparison

[enchantmentandlove]

I like Robyn and Elise, not Penelope so much personally. I like all the other names you've suggested, especially Lara and Alyssa.

[SpidersFromMars]

You could get Posy or Poppy from Penelope. Nellie or Penny are cute too.

[Deadsouls]

Robyn

[eatyourveg]

Elsa or Ailsa?

[Paddingtonthebear]

I love Penelope but none of the nicknames. I just love the name in full.

How about Lana?

[User1987654]

Elise is gorgeous. I also like it as a shortening for Elisabeth / Elizabeth ( Elise is the French version).
I like Penelope as well. Love Penny for short.
Dislike Robyn.
Love Alyssa as I like the softness of ' lissy."
How about Alice? It would work well with Sophia and Chloe.
I like Posy but prefer it as a nickname for Josephine.

[DramaAlpaca]

Elise

[AmysTiara]

I like them all except Penelope

[ElornaElephant]

Elise probably sounds best with your other children's names however I'm not of the opinion that they all need to match

I like Robyn a lot, neither of the two I know have their names shortened either.

Suggestion: Elena? I recently met an Elena who pronounces her name Eh-layna and thought it was super pretty.

[JunebabyT]

From your top 3, Elise. From your wider list I prefer Lara.

[Hamiltoes]

Elise I may or may not be biased though.

It never gets shortened to Ellie. Just "Leecy" by under threes.

[myfriendnigel]

Elise.

[Sophronia]

Penelope

[Dingarees]

I love Penelope and Robyn.

[Hassled]

Penelope is lovely but it will become Penny (I like Penny but you may not).
Robyn - no. It's a bit try hard - you can stick a y in to make it seem less of a boy's name, but most people will still think it's a boy's name.
Elise is really nice - I like that lots.

I've never paid attention to whether names go together - siblings' names always go together, just because they're siblings.