2 twin sets - which one?

[Rainbows2016]

Hi! New here. We have 2 twin sets that we can't pick from.

Brodie and Gracie
Oliver and Elinor

Which one?

[QueenLizIII]

Oliver and Elinor

[eachtigertires]

Brodie and Gracie. (But I agree with the others who say it would be better as Grace with Gracie as a NN)

[TyrionLannistersShadow]

Brodie and Grace (not Gracie) or Brodie and Elinor. Oliver is OK but Brodie is nicer .

[ClockMakerSue]

I like Oliver and Grace. I'm not keen on how the other combinations almost rhyme-it makes them sound like they've been chosen for their rhyminess rather than to name individuals. Oliver and Grace are really lovely and go together well I think.

Brodie is my least favourite out of the four.

[PotatoBread]

Oliver and Grace for me with Gracie as a nn. Think it's a lovely combination.

Hate Brodie and don't like the way you've spelt Eleanor.

[Loyly]

Oliver and Elinor

[SteviebunsBottrittrundle]

Brodie and Gracie

[Blahia]

Not too keen on the 'matching' name endings in the pairs you've listed ('ie' and 'er'/'or') so I would choose Oliver and Gracie (and I would personally put Grace on the birth certificate )

[Cami12]

Brodie and Gracie.

[TwoLittleBlooms]

I know you haven't listed them together but I really like Brodie and Elinor together - they are lovely names

[Sophronia]

Oliver and Grace "Grace" or Oliver and Elinor

[MrsGsnow18]

I don't like the sound of Brodie and Gracie together, much too 'samey'
I don't really like Gracie at all, would prefer Grace.
So for those reasons I prefer Oliver and Elinor.
Though I do think Brodie and Elinor would be nice too!

[Holly1987]

Oliver and Grace sound lovely together Agree Gracie sounds more like a nn for people close rather an actual name.

But go with your instincts x

[user1471501988]

Oliver and Grace, Gracie at home.

[MitzyLeFrouf]

Brodie and Elinor.

[ilovesprouts]

Oliver and Elinor love the names

[DramaAlpaca]

X-post with Swearwolf, I was typing too slowly!

[DramaAlpaca]

Another vote for Oliver & Grace.

I like Oliver & Elinor, but they'll inevitably get called Ollie & Ellie. Depends if you'd mind that or not.

Gracie is a bit cutesy, and I'm not keen on Brodie.

[rosegoldie]

Oliver and Gracie!

[Swearwolf]

I think with Oliver and elinor, the danger is they will become Ollie and Ellie, which is really matchy!

[ThatsWotSheSaid]

Oliver and grace (or Gracie)

[Vixxfacee]

I agree with pp Oliver and Grace.

[BackforGood]

I think the less common spelling of Elinor will really annoy her throughout her life.
Out of the 4, I'd choose Oliver and Grace
OK - I know I've adapted it slightly, but, I think 'Gracie' is a real 'little girl's name'. why not call her Grace, and you can still refer to hr as Gracie while she is little, but it's not her actual name for more formal, adult times.

[NappingRabbit]

Oliver and Grace (sorry)

[RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie]

Far prefer the Elinor spelling.