My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

MNHQ have commented on this thread

AIBU?

MNHQ here - should we support the campaign to end ‘rough sex’ defences?

535 replies

JustineMumsnet · 04/06/2020 12:21

Hello

As lots of you will already know because their campaign originated on Mumsnet, the group We Can’t Consent To This has been running a campaign to end ‘rough sex’ defences - and we’d like to know what you think about MNHQ signing up as a supporter of their
campaign.

Their aim is to end a situation in which defendants can claim that the death of or injury to a woman was caused by ‘consensual sex games gone wrong’.

They say:

‘We’ve now found 60 UK women who’ve been killed by men who claim a sex game gone wrong - and in the last 5 years the defence was successful in 7 of the 17 killings of a woman which reached trial, with the man being found not guilty or receiving a manslaughter conviction. We've found many more women injured in what the accused men claim was consensual sexual violence.
Yet more women tell us it’s now commonplace to be assaulted and abused by men they’re dating, with 38% of UK women under 40 reporting being assaulted - choked, slapped, gagged or spat on - in otherwise consensual sex. That equates to 3.6 million women under 40 in the UK who have experienced unbidden violence in sex - and we know that women over 40 experience this too.
We do not believe that women can consent to their grievous injury or death, and will campaign until claiming this is no longer a useful defence.’
We Can’t Consent To This is currently lobbying to tackle these ‘rough sex defences’ by adding amendements to the Domestic Abuse Bill that is going through Parliament, meaning that now is the time to get writing to MPs to encourage them to support the changes.

We'd love to get behind this campaign but as ever we said we’d ask you what you thought - so please let us know by adding your thoughts here or voting YANBU for ‘Yes please I’d like Mumsnet to support this campaign’ and YABU for ‘No, I don’t think Mumsnet should support this campaign’. (Apologies for using the AIBU metric for this but it’s the best way we have at the moment to get a snapshot survey of people who’ve read the OP.)

Big thanks

OP posts:
Report

Am I being unreasonable?

1240 votes. Final results.

POLL
You are being unreasonable
3%
You are NOT being unreasonable
97%
ArriettyJones · 08/06/2020 09:29

Fantastic. Thank you.

Report
JustineMumsnet · 08/06/2020 09:28

Thanks everyone for the pretty unequivocal response. We're very happy to put our full weight behind this and will of course keep you posted on next steps.

OP posts:
Report
spicelader · 07/06/2020 14:09

Yes

Report
Oxyiz · 07/06/2020 10:56

I've already stated my unequivocal support for this early on in the thread. No need to be so aggressive at me. Save it for your actual opposition.

Report
MariaDingbat · 07/06/2020 10:41

Yes, please support the campaign.

Report
Dontknowwhyidoit · 07/06/2020 10:35

Yes, you should support the campaign to end this defence

Report
JackiFazaki · 07/06/2020 10:31

Really? Let us hear you condemn this violence, unequivocally, instead of waffling on about "freedoms".

Report
Oxyiz · 07/06/2020 10:24

I honestly can't see how you've extrapolated that from my post. The mind boggles.

Report
pollyskettles · 07/06/2020 10:17

@JackiFazaki

So Sawdust, Xenia, Oxyiz. You support freedom to murder ?
Harming someone to death, and claiming that they asked for it, is a freedom is it?
We see you.

How could anybody support that, least of all lawyers?

A lawyer who supports freedom to murder should not be allowed to practice law and should lose their licence.
Report
JackiFazaki · 07/06/2020 10:14

So Sawdust, Xenia, Oxyiz. You support freedom to murder ?
Harming someone to death, and claiming that they asked for it, is a freedom is it?
We see you.

Report
MrsKCastle · 07/06/2020 10:10

MNHQ, so glad to see this.

Report
mingetout · 07/06/2020 10:09

Yes!

Report
ShandlersWig · 07/06/2020 10:09

100% support this.

Report
lottiegarbanzo · 07/06/2020 10:02

Why are people talking about freedom of speech? Say what you like. The issue at play is freedom to murder. It that a freedom you want to defend?

Report
Lemonyfuckit · 07/06/2020 10:00

100% yes. Thank you.

Report
Xenia · 07/06/2020 10:00

This is not a thread on which it is worth my putting any more views than those I did about the existing case law above.

I agree that free speech is not without consequences where it breaches a law eg law of libel and that kind of thing. Anyway as I said this will be a popular campaign for MN to adopt.

Report
FannyCann · 07/06/2020 09:58

Great post ChattyLion and I echo thanks to Fiona. It terrifies me that my daughters have to negotiate dating in an age where men think violence in sex is normal.

Report
Oxyiz · 07/06/2020 09:52

I'm with Xenia on that - I'm uncomfortable with blocking all speech or free thought, even if we feel some things are distasteful or horrible. It doesn't help to just no-platform others.

Just look at the current "transphobia" debate where people are demonised for not going along with groupthink. Or the shock everyone here felt about Brexit as many people had apparently hidden their feelings until the vote.

It's better that we are allowed to talk about things and hopefully come to understand other points of view to come up with more realistic solutions to problems.

And free speech doesn't mean lack of consequences of course.

Report
PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 07/06/2020 09:44

I hope we can remain in a UK where people can have all kinds of views and express them freely.

Do you feel the same about racism,sexism,homophobia,disablism?

Report
TooSadToSay · 07/06/2020 09:40

Yes! Thank you Fiona Thanks

Report
Xenia · 07/06/2020 09:40

I now claim the prize as the bravest person on MN!

I hope we can remain in a UK where people can have all kinds of views and express them freely. However as I said above in my post this will be a popular cause so one MN may well want to take on.

Report
ChattyLion · 07/06/2020 09:39

Of course you should! Women are people, aren’t they? Absolutely yes please do this MNHQ.

Also to say here because I hope that she will see this, that Fiona MacKenzie is one of my absolute heroes both for starting We Can’t Consent to This and for running the campaign so brilliantly to change the system and to protect women and girls. Flowers

WCCTT and the legal and social changes needed will help to honour the memories of those women killed and help to protect all of us and our daughters by raising this issue as widely as possible. This is not only about giving justice where it is being shockingly denied by an elevation of men’s sexual rights. We have a terrible cultural problem, those statistics show. Thank you Fiona and everyone involved. Thanks MNHQ for taking this on too.

Report
ErrolTheDragon · 07/06/2020 09:14

I'd hope MNHQ were capable of reading a thread.

I'm sure they are, and will. As you say, the result is overwhelmingly supportive so it doesn't matter too much. But, if any tablet user wants to vote then it's really not difficult.

Report
QualityFeet · 07/06/2020 09:11

Obviously

Report
RandomWordsandaNumber5 · 07/06/2020 09:10

Yes of course MN should support it.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.