My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

To stop doing anything for my son?

116 replies

RudeDS · 11/12/2018 11:46

Adult Son aged 25 lives with me. Pays no rent, no bills and has 24/7 access to broadband, Sky TV in his room (paid for by me) and invites his friends round as and when he wants. I also make all his meals for him.

He has borderline personality disorder so not sure if it’s part of his condition. Earlier this year I went on holiday for 2 weeks, I asked him to feed the cats – I left enough food for 3 weeks plus money in case he ran out (expected him to use it on himself). He refused to feed them, saying he wouldn’t know what to do put a pouch in the bowl and top up the water, not difficult. Thankfully my DD whose older than him was available and fed them for me, but he then moaned when DD took the £20 I’d left and bought a magazine and a bar of chocolate for herself and a cheap £1 DVD for her DD. He also complained that she bought her then 2 year old with her as she apparently makes too much noise when he’s trying to sleep (she’s now 3 and is a happy girl, who has problems communicating so does get overexcited and squeal or shout random things when she’s very happy – I love it but Son says it’s annoying and she needs to be quiet).

He sleeps all day and then is up all night. Complains when GD comes over but invites his friends over from 10pm onwards when I have to be up for work the next day – I never complain.

Yesterday I saw some new pieces of furniture I wanted – a chest of drawers and a new toy box for my GDs toys (she has a box of toys at my house). I rang my son asking if he would help me carry the furniture up from my car to our flat (we live in a block, we’re on the 1st floor – 1 set of stairs so not far at all). He shouted down the phone that I’d woken him up, that it was the middle of the night for him and we shouldn’t be encouraging my GD to want to come to my house anyway as his sister (my DD) already doesn’t look after her often as it is* so no he won’t help me and then hung up on me.

I cried having him be so rude to me. I do so much for him and he can’t help me do one small thing.

So I’ve done nothing for him – not put his clothes that are in the basket in the washing machine, only cooked food for myself, and have text my DD to say I’ll go pick GD up from Nursery at 3pm.

AIBU? Or too harsh due to his disorder meaning he was always going to be so rude to me?

*My DD is 27, is a single parent to GD aged 3. DD works 3 days a week so GD is in Nursery, but to make the days shorter for GD I pick her up on 1 or 2 of those days and take her to mine. I also cook a Sunday dinner every Sunday for DD and EO Sunday for GD and they eat this at my house. My DD is a brilliant parent, GD has SN (as said previously) but tries her hardest to be polite and is a happy child – all the reports from her Nursery describe her as a contented, well liked child and I know that’s due to my DD who has a firm but fair attitude to parenting and does pull GD up on her bad behaviour while taking into consideration her SN. DD picks GD up from me and if I ever can’t pick GD up she gets her herself and never asks me to babysit or do extra childcare than what I offer. And DD helps me with Sunday dinner, either by providing a pudding or by cooking it herself at my house while I play with my GD and chat to my dad who also comes.

OP posts:
Report
Laine21 · 18/12/2018 00:51

if he wont move, find yourself a nicer flat closer to your daughter and granddaughter and leave him to it!

my parents in the end moved out and left my brother living on his own, the best thing they could have done in my opinion!

Report
Susiesoop · 11/12/2018 17:32

OP...your son has a MH issue AND he's acting poorly, the two maybe linked but one doesnt permit the other. You have a son with a MH disorder AND a lack of boundaries with your son. Again one doesn't necessitate the other. It might be difficult (and you may need some support from a counselor etc as situations like this don't appear over night and may need a bit of unpicking) but some clear expectations would help both of you here. For example 'Its not ok for friends to come to my home at any time' and set a boundary e.g if this happens I will come in and ask them to leave (or similar) then if he ignores you follow through. It's not going to be easy but it is possible. Unfortunately he's acting badly because it's theres no consequence of anything he does- that's not good for anyone! Even him, he may possibly get his act together but that's up to him...good luck x

Report
ChristmasRaven · 11/12/2018 17:16

Also, on that note, I'd say to those saying "kick him out" if OP has given him joint tenancy (I believe she said this in an update) then she can't. It's equally his place so she doesn't have a choice.

Report
ChristmasRaven · 11/12/2018 17:14

@jay55

Depends how much the OP earns. If she's deemed to earn enough to pay it then he can't. It's calculated the same as it would be if they were partners.

Report
jay55 · 11/12/2018 16:50

So he could be getting housing benefit and council tax benefit and not handing it over to pay his share of those?

Report
APlanerideawayyy1 · 11/12/2018 16:13

I think that you need to have a conversation with your son and say that you need him to pay some money towards the cost of the house. If you lived alone you would receive single person council tax reduction if you live in UK. I would also let him know how much you spend on other bills like water, electric, gas, TV, insurance, food, internet, mobile phone and ask for a contribution. What would happen if you were I'll or something worse, how would he support himself ? There is a phenomenon in Asia where some people don't leave their house for years, perhaps he has something similar. I would give him a deadline and say that things need to change. Do you want to be in the same position in 5, 10, 20 years time. Why is he not volunteering if not working ?

Report
HolyandWild · 11/12/2018 15:39

BPD can be a seriously disabling condition and can take a huge toll on both the person and those who love them. It can be hard for people with BPD to develop mature relationships or to function successfully at home, school or work and can be very difficult to live with someone when they are treaing you the way you describe your son. It is most certainly not a 'dustbin diagnosis' and help is available - including for you. I recommend looking up information on BPD from Mind as they have some good resources. Understanding more about his diagnosis might help you to understand what you can do to help him and you. Please do understand that none of that excuses what has been happening and you are entitled to a better homelife free from the worry and abuse you have described.
Having said all that, by enabling him to carry on the way he is you are putting your own mental health at risk as well as letting him away with not taking any responsibility for his life. I suggest you go to the council to discuss your situation with the tenancy and any housing options that might be suitable for him.
Enjoy your time with your DD and GD and start looking after yourself more. This situation is not ok OP and Im sending you Flowers

Report
Cornishclio · 11/12/2018 14:58

Spaghetti Jumper

Once your sister reached adulthood there is very little your parents could have done. Really these issue need dealing with when problem "children" are much younger. Getting some advice from mental health professionals or maybe even SS intervention should be done in their teens not waiting until they are 25. The OP has a DD as well as a son and he seems to be abusing them both. It is all very well to say don't turn him away or kick him out but he needs a sharp dose of reality which he won't get from being allowed to live rent free, pay no bills or make any effort to help his mum. Refusing to help his mum would have me up there giving him grief but physically there is little she can do except withdraw support. He is an adult in size if nothing else.

Report
Cornishclio · 11/12/2018 14:47

You have been far too tolerant with your adult son who you should be encouraging to be independent. He is not a child and even with a BPD this is no excuse for his bullying and abusive behaviour.time for some tough love. H e needs to pay 50% of the rent as he should if you share the flat. He needs to find out what benefits he is entitled to but really he should get a job. I would cancel the Sky first as a way of making life slightly less comfortable for him. I would no longer shop for him or do his washing or cooking. Have your DD and GD over as much as you like. If he moans point out your DD is supportive whereas he is just a user and no support to you whatsoever.

In the end though you might want to save to get your own place if he doesn't change and won't move out.

Report
sherrysfortea · 11/12/2018 14:45

Something needs to be done or he is setting himself up for a miserable and lonely life which I fear you have contributed to by enabling him for so long.

Report
Angrybird345 · 11/12/2018 14:38

Stop enabling him!!!!

Report
aibutohavethisusername · 11/12/2018 14:34

I have BPD and I work 25 hours a week, have a good relationship with my partner and am Mum to a teenager.
I don’t think that your son’s BPD is the main reason he acts like this. I think he is just a lazy CF.

Report
Spaghettijumper · 11/12/2018 14:06

My parents' approach was to either ignore her behaviour or make me and my sister kowtow to her to keep her happy - I don't think they should have done either of those things. They basically avoided the problem as much as possible. Even when I was 25 and getting married I was still expected to let my sister have her own way - when I drew the line and said that actually I was now an adult and I wasn't going to do everything my bully of a sister said at my own wedding for fear she'd have a tantrum they seemed to finally get the message.

I understand that you feel you get why your parents couldn't deal with the situation but my opinion is that as a parent you don't get to just give up and ignore the suffering of your children because you can't face a problem. They weren't stupid - they could see she wasn't (and still isn't) normal but they just did nothing. I should add that my younger sister also has a physical disability and they also ignored that, so they have truly shitty form for this sort of behaviour.

Report
exparrot · 11/12/2018 13:52

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Spaghettijumper · 11/12/2018 13:37

Your parents maybe couldn’t have done anything. I am in a very similar situation now with a sibling and grew up thinking the same as you about my parents. I now understand they were powerless at the time (poorly recognised issues back then, better recognised now but only if you can get access to CAMHS which is a whole other story) and they didn’t enforce boundaries because trying to made my sibling’s behaviour much worse. My parents don’t like talking about it and I used to wish they would, but as a parent now, I realise that’s because they blame themselves enough as it is and struggle to deal with it. IME you can’t move forward yourself unless you forgive everyone for their parts in it all and accept that the situation now is what it is.

@exparrot - My parents definitely could have done something - they could have at least prevented my sister from emotionally and physically abusing my other sister, who was 8 years younger. For context, she would constantly bully, shout at and harass my younger sister, even when she was 11 and my younger sister was only 3. I think most not shit parents would have done something, anything to stop that. I did a lot more than my parents did to prevent that and I was only a child myself.

Report
Velvetbee · 11/12/2018 13:24

DD is 19 and has BPD. She has started her own business this year as well as university.

She needs extra emotional support during stressful times and does occasionally swear around me. However I’m happy to tell her she was out of line when she calms down and she apologises.

I understand that treading on eggshells and trying to keep things pleasant can feel like the path of least resistance. Been there done that but it wasn’t until I pushed back that our relationship actually improved.

Report
ittakes2 · 11/12/2018 13:11

My b'n'law has borderline personality disorder - he not only supports his own family but he also supports his parents. But that said everyone's mental health issues are different.
A parenting coach once said to me when I complained that my son treated me like a slave...she told me that he was treating me like a slave because I was acting like one.
Please speak to your doctor as you need support and professional advice. Borderline personality can be tricky.

Report
RudeDS · 11/12/2018 13:11

I don't know. He doesn't seem to have drug problems (I'd kick him out if he did as I don't want my GD around it) or alcohol problems, so apart from his phone there seems to be nothing he spends it on, although he has a playstation or xbox (not sure which but he's always on it when his friends aren't here talking to them) so I assume he might spend some money on that.

OP posts:
Report
Rayn · 11/12/2018 13:08

What does he spend his money on?

Report
Rayn · 11/12/2018 13:08

You are been too soft. Does not matter how much you earn you both pay 50% each!

Report
Ggirl27 · 11/12/2018 13:07

@RudeDS Your last reply shows that you are going to need a complete mind change if this behaviour is not going to continue. There are two adults in the flat, that means that rent is split 50-50. Why should you pick up the extra 25% because you 'can afford it'? He needs to get a job and start contributing properly. Give him 3 months to get his life sorted and then payments will commence - and that is being generous. This is going to require strength and resolve from you - he is not going to like it at all...

Report
RudeDS · 11/12/2018 13:06

Not working and not sure what benefits he gets but he definitely gets something. He has a phone but I've never paid the bill on it so he must have money from somewhere?

OP posts:
Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

defectiveinspector · 11/12/2018 13:04

RudeDS Start doing what you want to do and tell your DS that he has to grow up. You can't force him to claim benefit for his share of the rent though, so it becomes up to you about what you do about that. If you do decide you want him to leave discuss it with your housing officer, I'm certain that they will be sympathetic.

Report
exparrot · 11/12/2018 13:03

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Singlenotsingle · 11/12/2018 13:03

You're treating him like a child and he's therefore behaving like one! He should be cooking his own meals, doing his own washing and ironing, and get a job! (Has he got a job? Presumably not if he sleeps all day and parties all night).

He should be paying for his own phone and Sky. How long is this going to go on? Never mind his Borderline Personality Disorder - he's using this as an excuse to do what he likes!

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.