When we were looking at primaries for DD, all were rated ‘good’ but 2 were ‘outstanding’. One was absolutely streets ahead of all the ‘good’ schools, the feel, the vibe, the work we saw and the staff were amazing. The other felt like a drone factory. The first had no uniform (like two of the ‘good’ schools we saw), the second did, and very neat and tidy the children looked too, but the school had no personality to speak of and the children were as quiet as mice, they had no oomph at all.
Now I’m not so dense as to put that down to uniform but for me it was part of the package that made it unappealing.
Our HT (at one of the ‘good’ schools, we were out of catchment for the amazing one) is immensely experienced and is, I believe, more than capable of making good decisions for his school that don’t have to conform to the norm in British schools. So no uniform, homework is minimal and laid back, year two Sats were pretty much ignored (I didn’t even know when Dd had done them, neither she nor her teacher made any mention of them. The HT clearly didn’t feel they were worth a damn). The staff are amazing and loyal, it is very well staffed, with plenty of additional teachers. I have, in four years, not heard speak of any bullying issues.
It is a wonderful school. Not perfect, but wonderful. The children love it, the parents love it and the staff clearly love it. An inner city school with a diverse intake. When I go to the summer concert in the playground, everyone there with their picnics, the classes and staff doing their songs - it’s an amazing community.
That’s not down to a lack of uniform, it’s down to a strong HT with fantastic staff support, who understands education and isn’t afraid to go against the prevailing norms to provide the best for the children in his school.