My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

To feel sad that so few people are coming to my mother's funeral?

44 replies

theresnoonequitelikegrandma · 22/08/2015 12:08

My Mum, despite many health issues including heart failure and dementia, managed to reach her 90th birthday this month and then, as she had told us she intended to, passed away peacefully within a week of her celebrations. Her funeral is next week and I can't help feeling sad that there will only be a handful of people attending.

She spent the last years of her life in a care home local to me and the rest of our family are spread far and wide but it was her wish to have the service here, even though she and my late father lived in a different part of the country for many years. I don't know if it's distance that makes people unwilling to come (although there is a distant relative coming over from another country!) or if it's just that so many of her friends are also now elderly and infirm. We have had cards and messages, so it's clear that she touched people's lives.

It just seems so sad that after 90 years on the planet there will be fewer than 20 people there to say goodbye.

OP posts:
Report
xavierfondue · 22/08/2015 13:35

I'm so sorry to hear this. Flowers (((hug)))

My grandfather died at aged 94 and the only people who attended were my grandmother, their children, grand children and great grandchildren and a few spouses. There were about 15 of us.

When my grandmother died, my aunt decided not to have a funeral at all, but had my grandmother instantly and privately cremated, like a dog at the vet's. The aunt held a kind of memorial service at my cousin's house, but it wasn't the same at all. I felt awful about that but was powerless to do anything as there are some very strong minded women in my family.

OP, be sad. But be kind to yourself as well. She is, and will continue to be, remembered. You're seeing her off in style. You're doing the right thing.

Report
StampyMum · 22/08/2015 14:22

I've been to some enormous, packed funerals of mothers who lived only till 61, or 33 in one awful case. You wouldn't want to swap, I don't think. So sorry for your loss Flowers

Report
WitchOfAlba · 22/08/2015 14:27

So sorry to hear that OP.
My elderly father has left instructions that he doesn't want anybody to be at his funeral, he's paid for it in advance and has stipulated in the instructions for the funeral director that they are to do it exactly as he has instructed.

Report
CMOTDibbler · 22/08/2015 14:36

I'm so sorry for your loss.

My mum is only in her early 70's, but her dementia has cut her off from everyone, and so I expect that when she dies, in spite of teaching in their town for 40 years and very active in the community then, there will be very few people there.

Report
Greenlandrover · 22/08/2015 14:45

Ah, my widowed Gran also reached 90 and was living her last years in care. It's a lovely age to reach.

There were 5 people at her funeral.
Myself and partner, one of her best friends, and two of the care workers from where she lived. To be fair, I couldn't find remaining distant family, and her only other grandchild was incommunicado with her for years so wouldn't have attended anyway. Both her children had already died before her.

So if you only count friends and family, that's 3 at her funeral.

The funeral was sparse as she'd stipulated no flowers (I went against her wishes there though and just had one bouquet if lillies) and it was a Catholic service in a tiny graveyard chapel. It didn't really reflect her outward persona, anyone who only knew her superficially would have said, but she's so extravert and flamboyant and colourful - this funeral was so.. dour

But for the two of us there who did know her really well, we knew she was very religious, very frugal with her emotions deep down, and hated showiness in her personal life. This funeral was quality not quantity for her, I believe.


Anyway, just to summarise, the number of people attending doesn't matter, butI do recommend a nice speech by someone who knows the real person not just sit persona, as with our Catholic priest, he really didn't 'get' my Gran at all, consequently his speech was empty to me.

Report
Branleuse · 22/08/2015 14:46

Im sorry for your loss.

I went to a good friends funeral last year where there were 7 people present. It was moving, intimate and a beautiful small service, to an inspirational, humble person who lived his last few years very low key.n I know what you mean. Id never been to such a small funeral, but the people there were the ones who cared.

Report
BoboChic · 22/08/2015 14:50

My mother-in-law died aged 73. There were 150 people at her funeral. My mother died aged 77. There were 90 people at her funeral.

The vast majority of attendees in both cases were contemporaries. When someone lives to 90, they will have outlived most of their contemporaries.

Report
clicketyclick66 · 22/08/2015 15:01

OP, I'm so sorry for your loss Flowers
I live in Ireland, in an area where everybody knows everybody else - when my grandmother died at 94, the church was packed and loads had to stand outside. Of course, it meant a lot to us.
But afterwards, the funeral is over, and regardless of how many was there you will have to get on with living without your loved one while the whole world moves on.

Report
theresnoonequitelikegrandma · 23/08/2015 20:27

Thank you all for your kind messages. I kind of knew I was being a bit unreasonable but at least you have made me feel that it's understandable to feel the way I do.

I know it will be better to have 15 people who really want to be there than 50 who are only there because they feel obliged. Just want it all over now.

Unfortunately, as she was in a care home, we have to have the room cleared before the end of the week so we've been doing that and it feels much, much too soon.

OP posts:
Report
StepAwayFromTheEcclesCakes · 23/08/2015 20:42

my dear mum passed away just last month, 3 years ago my dads funeral was packed with people, they all thought he was a lovely man, he was to them and though not a bad man was a bit selfish and thoughtless with his family. my DM was a diamond, no where near as many people came for hers, ok some are no longer with us, some were maybe working, and I guess we were not in a place to ring everyone and assumed they would read the newspaper announcement. I wish i had rang more people to tell them but i was in bits Sad we did have maybe 50 or more so not a bad turnout and tbh all those mum really cared about were there so i shouldn't be upset but i really would have liked as many as my dad had.Flowers to you op , i know exactly how you are feeling. lets hope it gets better cos its crap right now isn't it.

Report
StepAwayFromTheEcclesCakes · 23/08/2015 20:45

the clearing up too is just beyond awful, mum was in a home but only for a while so not only did we have to do the room almost the day after we had the house too. so many memories to pack away and I could not help feeling like a ghoul jumping in to say 'i'd like to take this' felt horrid and I miss her Sad it will be hard op but as DH keeps telling me 'remember the good times'

Report
Dogsmom · 23/08/2015 20:47

So sorry to hear about your Mom, it's an awful time.

You may find on the day that you're glad there's only a few people, at my Dad's there were a lot as he'd died very suddenly aged 70 and at the wake I was exhausted having to make polite conversation with people many of whom I hadn't seen for years, all I wanted to do was get it over with and go home.

Report
greenfolder · 23/08/2015 20:54

We had similar with one of my grandparents. We had a simple service then all went for a nice meal together. It seemed fitting and sure they would approve. We drank a toast and really chatted about them and the old days. It was far better than something more formal.

Report
TalkinPeace · 23/08/2015 21:01

My grandmother was 96 when she died.
Her funeral was a purely official affair with none of us there.

Her memorial service / party / wake some months later
was an utter blast and was the biggest gathering of the family in many, many years.

Your Mum wanted something at the end of her life that may not have been how those who remembered her wanted to remember

so you have the chance to call another party and get everybody together, where the family are, for a joyous memorial

do it

Report
Dowser · 23/08/2015 21:01

Very sorry for your loss. It will be the same for my mum when her time comes.

I shall rejoice that my mum didn't pass in her forties when she was seriously ill.

Rather an empty church than an overflowing one because you / they passed too soon. Like my dear friend :-(

Report
AcrossthePond55 · 23/08/2015 22:18

Before she sank into dementia my mother brought this up, how so many of her loved ones were already gone, or were very ill. But I remember she said "Well, there may not be many left to say 'Goodbye' when my time comes, but there will be many waiting for me in Heaven to say 'Hello'.

She's still with us in body at 92, but her mind has slipped away. Dementia is a cruel bastard. So many are gone now and our family is spread so far that I don't even know who will be around, or able, to come to her funeral when the time comes.

Report
scarlets · 23/08/2015 22:32

I think that's the thing when people have reached a great age. Many friends are deceased or ailing. Don't feel sad - it's a sign that she had a long life. Best wishes.

Report
dotdotdotmustdash · 23/08/2015 22:50

My Grandfather died at 92, the last of his sibling set of 3 and my Grandmothers sib group of 11. Many of their nieces/nephews had already died, and their children didn't know my Grandad. It was a small funeral compared to my Grandmother's 10 years previously when there were more siblings and their families.

A smaller funeral is a small price to pay for precious extra years with your parent.

Report
DarthVadersTailor · 23/08/2015 22:53

It's quality, not quantity OP.

Sorry for your loss Flowers

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.