My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

To think that if we are not going to pay benefits to foreigners because they haven't contributed

84 replies

IceBeing · 12/01/2014 13:41

then we should also not pay benefits to people born in the UK that haven't contributed?

Like my grandmother...she's never paid any tax (married early when married women weren't expected to work). Or my cousins who have not been able to find work since leaving school. Or many of the locals around here who have not had work in their family for three generations now. Or my friend's brother with Downs Syndrome who has never worked.

Alternatively..and this might be crazy....maybe the point of benefits is to support people who can't support themselves, whatever the reason, irrespective of whether or not they have been able to in the past and also irrespective of where they or they parents happen to have been born.

OP posts:
Report
lifehasafunnywayofhelpinguout · 13/01/2014 20:23

To be honest I think it's terrible that poor people who may have came here to seek refuge are to be denied benefits. These people need help and support. As a U.K National. I have to say I feel proud that they have chosen that U.K as their new adopted home. Also what about their children? Why should they be left to starve.
In regards to people here who have never contributed well we don't know their reasons for never being in work do we, so I don't think it's fair to say just because a person has not contributed then they should go with out. After all denying people benefits could lead to crime because people will do anything to survive. The welfare state is there for the needy. xxx

Report
CHJR · 13/01/2014 19:49

*Also, we didn't know when we moved here that DS2 was so disabled (though I was beginning to suspect). I just wonder what the Daily Mail and UKIP would make of me. How bad all this sounds really depends on which facts you emphasize and omit, and whether you firmly believe that MY HUSBAND'S income somehow justifies my and DS's neediness. If that works within one family can it never work in the greater family of the human race? Yet I well understand that sometimes it's just too expensive. As I say, DH is a higher-rate taxpayer (something I never foresaw when we married, and attribute in great part to sheer damn luck), yet we find it very, very costly having even one disabled child. As a society, I see that we cannot afford to have too high a proportion of dependents to workers.

Report
CHJR · 13/01/2014 19:38

It preys on my mind that I'm a scrounging foreigner who came into this country and have been sucking off benefits ever since without working. Ok. I've been here 7 years now, but have never held a job in the UK. Because of DS2's disabilities I collect disability living allowance and various schooling benefits. And though all 3 DC are in school full-time and I am looking for a job, it is uphill work given that I've been off for 15 years.

Now, granted, DH is British and a higher-rate taxpayer, and DC are all therefore British (though born abroad). But that isn't anything that I really do myself, is it? I am, and DS2 is doomed to be, a drain on resources and a net loss to the world.

I sure understand how other people end up in this situation through no real fault of their own. And also why at some point you just give up trying to get a job and give up all hope of being able to make a dent in the world outside your own tiny circle.

Report
charitymum · 13/01/2014 02:46

Actually - on average - rich pay lot less that those on much less money both in % per earnings and in real terms as a 'group'. Philanthropy on this country is very weak. Of course there are exceptions but most charity public donations comes from average or below average earners giving little and often and fundraising.

And while charity donations are welcome they are not a substitute for tax. Tax avoidance is crap. Not paying taxes is fraud. Government could address both and address deficit in welfare bill.

I'm rich. I don't mind being taxed heavily. I have more that most. I don't care if some people play the system. I'd rather people get welfare who shouldn't than one more kid in this country has to use a food bank.

Report
MomsStiffler · 12/01/2014 22:46

I say "yes" to British benefits for Britons. Germans can have German benefits and so on.

Maybe pulling up the drawbridge for a few years & counting what's left in the kitty is what we need....

Report
softlysoftly · 12/01/2014 20:43

You mean the ones paying a shed load in charity? Hmm

How about we just make the money we already take work better ey?

So NO to no benefits

And

NO to taxing the well off until they just get utterly fucked off with it all

This approach of Labour spend spend spend "hate the rich".

Or Torys cut cut cut "no hate the poor" has got us precisely nowhere so far.

Report
Piscivorus · 12/01/2014 20:16

I know you can't believe everything you see or read but haven't several documentaries and articles shown that it is quite easy for new arrivals to get fake documentation to enable them to claim?

I still can't decide if we should be worried about immigration or not. I am damned certain that we should be worried about Cameron and his ilk running the country.

Report
MomsStiffler · 12/01/2014 19:58

If, as many people seem to believe, it's rare for "foreigners" to come here & claim benefits then surely new rules won't actually affect many, if any?

Any that don't have work and can't claim will have to leave, but it'll hardly be an exodus of epic proportions based on the above will it?

As for claiming child benefit. If the children live in this country with the parent permanently, then OK. If they're living in the original country with a parent, spouse, family etc, surely they'll be receiving benefits from their own government over there?

Report
cory · 12/01/2014 19:03

Do we have any statistics as to how many foreigners actually do manage to claim benefits straight after arriving in this country? I didn't think it was all that easy.

Report
PortofinoRevisited · 12/01/2014 19:01

We also have a great "service cheque" system which is designed to stamp out the black economy. If you want a cleaner/ironing/household jobs etc you buy cheques from a recognised agency. They cost 9 euros each - ie per hour. The employee is insured/gets NI and tax paid and actually takes home a larger amount. It is technically illegal to employ anyone cash in hand for domestic work. As they have to work through an agency it ensures that you only have workers with legal status.

Report
charitymum · 12/01/2014 18:57

So basically a whole thread about how we divide a little money between a lot of people - rather than focusing on the few people who have most of the money. Well played Cameron. Well played. Diversionary tactics at their best. Breeding hatred and envy; mistrust and intolerance through politics and media. Can't think of any occasion when that happened before or what the likely consequences might be.

Report
PortofinoRevisited · 12/01/2014 18:57

I am in Belgium and AFAIK was entitled to claim nothing when I first arrived. Dd got CB due to DH's work initially. That is more generous than the UK definitely and goes up for each child - eg 100 euros for DC1, 150 for DC1, 200 for DC 3 etc. Also. if I lost my job I would be entitled to about 70% of my salary for a defined period. None of this good wage to JSA drop. Mind you we hand over more than 50% of gross salary in tax and NI. Child care is subsidised and tax deductible. School is free from age 2.5 and offers wrap round care as standard ie 7.30 to 6/6.30.

You need health insurance though and would have to pay for it, if not covered by your employer. A visit to my GP costs 23 euros and I can claim back about 17 euros. If me and dd both were ill and went at the same time - I would have to pay twice.

Report
IceBeing · 12/01/2014 18:46

wobbly interesting point there....

OP posts:
Report
wobblyweebles · 12/01/2014 17:56

Those coming here as economic migrants should only be able to claim what they'd be entitled to from their home country.

Only makes sense if they should also only pay the taxes they'd be due if they were in their home country.

Report
Joysmum · 12/01/2014 17:33

Those coming here as economic migrants should only be able to claim what they'd be entitled to from their home country.

Report
FudgefaceMcZ · 12/01/2014 17:28

There are other ways of contributing than financial. I don't like that the supposedly anti-racist side of the 'immigration debate' has decided to take up classism instead and bash UK poor people rather than combating all forms of discrimination- I think it harms your cause and makes you look overprivileged and intolerant.

In practical terms, in light of the way the EU works, I would think the best solution would be a reciprocal agreement, something like the E111 medical card system, so that people moving within the EU are covered by their own government if they become unemployed or disabled, in order not to unduly burden countries who have democratically decided to promote equality through a social security system above those who are less responsible towards their citizens. Countries who refuse to participate could either repay social security payments for individuals to the government from whom they are claimed, or pay for their citizens to return 'home' should they become unable to support themselves in another country. The capitalist system has created the need for quite extreme geographical mobility, so it is reasonable to expect it to cover the fallout of this in terms of community inability to support vulnerable individuals when everyone is forced to move for work or work rather than carrying out caring responsibilities.

As an aside, are UK citizens allowed to move to Scandinavian countries and benefit from their more generous social security systems? I don't think we are, so I don't see how there is an equivalence here. I would certainly choose to move to a country which provided free childcare if I could, but I believe (and have looked into this, so am fairly informed) that without a job offer, enough money to support myself indefinitely, or a legal partner with the appropriate nationality, I am not allowed to move there. I don't see why anyone would move to the UK to claim benefits all other things being equal, when Scandinavia is far more generous for these.

Report
tarantula · 12/01/2014 16:11

Don't see why people are complaining about child benefit being paid to people who are working in this country; after all those people are paying tax here so of course their cb should come from here. If I was living in Donegal and working in Derry then I would pay taxes to the UK and therefore it seems logical that the cb should come from the uk too and under EU law the opposite would also be true so someone living in Tyrone and working say in Cavan would get Irish cb instead.
AFAIK if you are living in Ireland and get UK cb this is then topped up by the Irish gov to the amount they pay as that is more. Same is I belive true in Germany so suspect it may be the same across the EU.

Report
YoureBeingASillyBilly · 12/01/2014 16:08

Nope- thick as fuck is pretty obvious regardless of where its coming from

Report
GlassOfPort · 12/01/2014 16:04

DirtyDancing, while the idea of restricting benefit claims from people who have just arrived seems sensible, I can't help wondering whether these proposals are being put forward to address a real problem (Hundreds of thousands of EU citizens alreday live in the UK, if they had bankrupted the welfare state, Channel 4 would have probably told us by now..) or they are just a political stunt.
What annoys me is that by proposing benfit curbs, the government is perpetuating the steroptype of the immigrant as a burden on public services. No wonder people think we are all benefit scroungers...

Report
softlysoftly · 12/01/2014 15:51

I have no answer to the benefits conundrum but I will say that I wish people would stop trotting out the "go for nasty big business tax avoiders" Hmm

Ok they may not pay the full rate of tax through perfectly legal loopholes but how much tax do they pay??

A relative of mine ran a business employing over 300 people for 70+ years (father to son), created the only employment in a community previously mining. Paid £000000s in income tax, corporation tax, vat, national insurance, paye etc etc. Export and national sales. When he sold the business he used a perfectly legal tax avoidance scheme. Still paid millions in capital gains but less than the "normal" %.

By your statement that makes him a bastard thief ripping off our country more than the 1000s who have never contributed.

Report
FanFuckingTastic · 12/01/2014 15:45

I'm sure it doesn't even occur to some people that there is more than one category of immigrant. They all just come here to steal our benefits obviously.

Ignorance is a sad thing, people don't take the time to try and understand, they just get angry and judgmental and find that scapegoat to blame. Made easier by the biased media right now I must say.

Having read some of the Benefits Streets comments, I can honestly say I'd rather spend my time in the company of immigrants and benefits recipients, because some of the abuse I've seen directed at them is simply vile and shows where the problem in this country is, it's not the poor, the disabled, the children, or the people from another country, it's the sheep who as so easily led by what they see on TV and by a corrupt, self-interested government who only want to fill their own pockets in the time they are in office. This country will never change while they believe the telly box and beat down those struggling to get by in life, instead of questioning the ethics of our own government.

Report
wobblyweebles · 12/01/2014 15:44

DirtyDancing If you stop thinking of them as 'they' and start thinking of them as 'us' you'll get your answer.

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

Hechan · 12/01/2014 15:42

Other EU countries also pay child benefit for children not living in that country.
My kids live in Ireland with me. Until recently I got my child benefit from the Netherlands. You can't pick and choose who pays your cb, there are cross border rules, so I was getting dutch cb of approx €440 per quarter instead of the €840 I would have got in Ireland.
And you can't just show up and demand cb for your imaginary kids, we got a bunch of forms twice a year from both countries.

Report
DirtyDancing · 12/01/2014 15:41

I don't think people realise the cost implications of paying benefits to all these people. The NHS, schools, transport services are all ready at breaking point. Why should we spend valuable money & resources bailing out people who have moved here from other countries & are unable to support themselves? Sometimes charity has to begin at home

Report
Dawndonnaagain · 12/01/2014 15:38

Well said, GlassOfPort

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.