Talk

Advanced search

Say You Were Dropped Onto Planet Earth

(5 Posts)
headinhands Wed 07-Feb-18 18:27:52

How would you explain your position on trans issues in a way they could understand using data, facts and so on. (Not insinuating it couldn't be done, just looking for a 'spoon fed' explanation)

isthistoonosy Wed 07-Feb-18 18:57:03

Animals are (for the vast majority) split into women who have xx chromosones and men who have xy. Xx's are oppressed by xy's and suffer violence at their hands vastly more often than the other way around.

For many years xx's have worn clothes, hair styles and worked jobs previously associated with xy's. All fine and most embraced increasing equality. No one suggested an xx could become and xy.

Some xy's decided to put on a dress, makeup and declare themselves xx - saying they need all the same rights as real xx people and we should all just pretend they are xx. The general public, polititians etc disappeared down a pc rabbit hole to appease them.

No one gives a shit about an xy calling himself Mary or wearing heels they do care that xy's (all of them) can access xx only spaces. Spaces put in place to protect xx's from xy's.

Thats how I'd explain it to an adult alien 👽

LefkosiaTigers Wed 07-Feb-18 19:28:38

"Where's your spaceship? Is there room for me?"

headinhands Wed 07-Feb-18 19:58:33

Some xy's decided to put on a dress, makeup and declare themselves xx - saying they need all the same rights as real xx people and we should all just pretend they are xx. The general public, polititians etc disappeared down a pc rabbit hole to appease them.

You've not provided any data for why that's a risk? Someone from outer space won't understand what PC or 'rabbit hole' means.** You've also made claims without evidence regarding the response of the 'general public'.**

Terftastic Wed 07-Feb-18 22:43:01

The Eloi and the Moorlock.

The Eloi live above ground, in fear of the Moorlock, who periodically come up from underground and eat them.

Some of the Moorlock decide they should have been born Eloi, in fact have always been Eloi, and dress as Eloi, and demand to live above ground. Despite the Eloi being terrified of them, and being regularly eaten by Moorlock, the Moorlock call them hysterical.

(Yes, I am joking).

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: