My feed
Premium
Please
or
to access all these features

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

What we're reading

My Sister's keeper. Suitable for a 13 year old?

26 replies

smartiejake · 05/07/2009 10:33

My DD wants to read this. It's a while since I read it and not sure if I should let her.

Any opinions?

OP posts:
Report
lisad123 · 05/07/2009 10:36

I would say yes aslong as she is sensible. It is a sad book but then again so is life.

Report
stitchtime · 05/07/2009 10:38

age thirteen, i never had any books censored fore me.

Report
smartiejake · 05/07/2009 10:38

SHe is very sensible and don't think the themes would unduly worry her.

OP posts:
Report
yappybluedog · 05/07/2009 11:24

I would say yes too, you can discuss any questions she may have

Report
TheFool · 05/07/2009 11:42

At 13 I would say pretty much all books are ok except heavily sex based ones.

Report
giraffescantdancethetango · 05/07/2009 11:43

I would say yes. She may read it herself anyway in secret if you say no, but then feel unable to discuss it/ask questions which is where probs could arise.

Report
ChasingSquirrels · 05/07/2009 11:44

I was reading Harold Robins at 13/14 - good god!

I would think My Sister's Keeper would be fine, but then it's a long time since I was 13 and I only had 6 and 3yo boys.

Report
TheFool · 05/07/2009 11:45

To be honest as well - I think that it probably is more of a book to affect mothers than girls the same age iyswim

Report
janeite · 05/07/2009 16:35

I think it would be fine. Having said that, lots of teen fiction is much better written than Jodie P!

I was reading Virginia Andrews (incest), James Herbert (lesbians and masturbating teachers iirc!) and Stephen King (deranged clowns etc) at 13!!

Actually I think my 14 year old might like JP. She has just read all of Austen's and all the Shopaholic books and is in a reading-limbo again now.

Report
smartiejake · 05/07/2009 20:32

WHich teen fiction would you recommend then? janeite? SHe is going through a phase of thinking reading is boring (having spent most of her earlier years with her nose permanently in a book!)

I had thought about the "Noughts and Crosses" trilogy by Malorie Blackman but would be open to any other ideas (but not Twilight as she didn't like that.)

SHe has actually started "My Sister's keeper" today and seems hooked already.

OP posts:
Report
giraffescantdancethetango · 06/07/2009 11:37

I remember loving Happy endings by Adele Geras as a teenager.

Report
seeker · 06/07/2009 11:42

My 13 year old has refused to read any Jodie P because she's seen me weeping buckets over them!

Report
janeite · 06/07/2009 19:59

Noughts And Crosses and the next two in the series are excellent; the final one, however (published last year iirc) is rubbish.

DD has just read one called 'Before I Die' which she enjoyed: have not read it personally so can't vouch for it. It's about a girl dying from cancer I think, so hard-hitting in a JP way I guess.

Has she read the Shopaholic books? They are inane nonsense tbh but dd1 rather liked them!

Also the Angus, Things series is fun - and features teenage girls coming to terms with norks, snogging, make up etc.

Report
yappybluedog · 06/07/2009 20:27

Before I Die is fantastic, but utterly heartbreaking

Another good book for this age is Looking for JJ, and also Boy A - both books explore similar themes

Report
TheFool · 06/07/2009 20:39

Oh yes - Looking for JJ

Report
janeite · 06/07/2009 21:37

Boy A is v good. Looking For JJ is okay. Both v interesting, as you sympathise with people who did awful things and both leave you with more questions than they give answers. Boy A more 'mature' in content: I must admit I wouldn't want dd reading it yet.

Report
smartiejake · 06/07/2009 23:29

Thanks for your suggestions.DD has read all the Angus Thongs books (they look hideous but she seemed to enjoy them!) Will look into the other suggestions- hadn't thought of the shopaholics books.

OP posts:
Report
janeite · 07/07/2009 19:57

I read my first Georgette Heyer recently (Regency romance) and loved it. I kept thinking how I would have adored it as a teenager. It is like Jane Austen crossed with Jilly Cooper! I'm going to try and track some down for dd1 in the library.

Report
GetOrfMoiLand · 08/07/2009 10:20

I was reading Jackie Collins and good old Jilly Cooper at that age

Nick Hornby books are also very good for teenagers - my dd has read About a Boy and the one about Arsenal and seems to enjoy them.

Report
yappybluedog · 08/07/2009 14:53

I was reading victorian erotic fiction & the Joy
of sex that I'd found hidden in my mother's room

Report
janeite · 08/07/2009 17:49

Oh yes, 'About A Boy' is lovely -and the film is v good too. I often find that dd will read things if she watches the film too: that's how she read the Austens.

Report
smartiejake · 08/07/2009 18:49

"About a boy" yes I have that one I think she would love that- good idea! Perhaps she could see the film after she's read it though (prefer her to read it first)

OP posts:
Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

smartiejake · 08/07/2009 18:51

yappybluedog Joy of sex!

Did you develop a lust for lanky bearded hippy blokes as a result!

OP posts:
Report
yappybluedog · 08/07/2009 19:21

no, the very opposite

Report
janeite · 08/07/2009 20:09

yes - I think with 'About A Boy' book first, then film. With her first Austen (P&P) dd needed the 'security' of the film before the novel, just so she didn't get frightened off by the language. After that she read the books, followed by the films.

How about 'To Kill A Mocking Bird' or 'Of Mice And Men' or other more modern classics?

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.