Talk

Advanced search

We Are All Completely Beside Ourselves - suitable for 16yo?

(14 Posts)
mummybare Fri 05-Dec-14 09:10:45

She's into animal rights. Is it suitable?

Cheers!

Booboostoo Fri 05-Dec-14 09:59:58

It is moving and sad but sometimes it's good for us to be challenged and provoked into thinking more about things. I say she should read it.

Marlinspike Fri 05-Dec-14 10:01:45

Oh yes, absolutely. It's a great read! Does she know the "twist"? Makes it far more powerful if she doesn't, but it's not really something you can 'unremember'?

mummybare Fri 05-Dec-14 12:02:23

She's not my dd - extended family - but I saw a review and thought of her so I might get it for her for Christmas. I think I will. Thanks for the advice.

IHaveBrilloHair Fri 05-Dec-14 12:10:32

Yes, but its crap

mummybare Fri 05-Dec-14 13:21:34

In what way, Brillo?

IHaveBrilloHair Fri 05-Dec-14 15:07:17

It just felt like someone was giving me a really tedious lecture on animal rights where nothing much happens.

hackmum Fri 05-Dec-14 18:16:53

Very suitable. A great read.

Takver Sat 06-Dec-14 10:44:09

Yes, totally suitable for a 16 y/o. I thought it was an enjoyable easy read, I knew the 'twist' before hand and it didn't spoil it at all for me.

BringMeTea Sat 06-Dec-14 13:52:14

100% yes.

BringMeTea Sat 06-Dec-14 13:54:32

I can't think of any book that would not be suitable for a 16 year old.

mummybare Sat 06-Dec-14 15:08:04

I see your point, BringMe, but I wouldn't want to get her something with a lot of sex/violence/animal cruelty. It would be different if she were deliberately seeking it out, but it's a difficult age, isn't it? Some 16yos are so much more mature than others and it's difficult to know where to pitch these things if you only see them a couple of times a year. I think she'll like the book in this case though.

BringMeTea Sat 06-Dec-14 15:43:16

Oh I didn't realize it was a gift. Yes, in that case I probably wouldn't give American Psycho or Last Exit To Brooklyn. grin. I really enjoyed this book and one of the things I liked most was the animal rights angle as it is so thought-provoking so this could be right up her street.

AmeliaPeabody Sun 07-Dec-14 20:59:19

I think it would be fine for a 16 year old.

I found it an interesting read, though I almost gave up, especially just after the 'twist' was revealed.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now