I have found 2 mascaras that don't smudge on me

[Aquamarine70]

I have eyelash extensions do just wear mascara on t bottom lashes. I don't have oily or watery eyes & find that most mascaras cheap, waterproof & high end just smudge or flake. I was in Mecca Maxima shop & they let me try Urbsn Decay Cannon ball & Too Faced Lash Injection. I had no smudging. The Too Faced had a gooey texture but it was ok to remove. I'm not sure if if will go sticky or clumpy after a few uses.The Cannon ball came off ok with Simple eye make up remover. I am so pleased to have finally found mascara that doesn't smudge.

[Itscurtainsforyou]

Ooh - do they do it in brown?
My mascara always smudges so have to wear waterproof, but can only ever find it in black

[Aquamarine70]

They only come in black only. I'm so happy that I have found one that works.
Have you tried Loreal Voluminous waterproof? That may come in brown. I have read good reviews on that one.